Close X
Monday, November 11, 2024
ADVT 
National

Workers, employers want feds to pay off EI debt

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 14 Oct, 2022 11:15 AM
  • Workers, employers want feds to pay off EI debt

OTTAWA — With employment insurance premiums set to rise in the new year, both employers and workers are calling on the federal government to step in and rescue the program from the considerable amount of debt it has fallen into since the COVID-19 pandemic.

The program, which is financed entirely through premiums paid by workers and employers, accumulated $25.9 billion of debt by the end of 2021, according to the Office of the Chief Actuary.

The rise in debt comes after a staggering number of Canadians were unemployed during the pandemic and eligibility rules for the program were relaxed to ease access to jobless benefits.

Since then, the labour market has bounced back and temporary changes to the EI program have been reversed. However, the question that lingers is: who should pick up the tab on the accumulated debt?

Employers and workers are hoping the federal government will.

“The current deficit happened because of the pandemic, and it is not the fault of any employee and it's not the fault of any employer,” said Jasmin Guénette, vice-president of national affairs at the Canadian Federation of Independent Business.

After a two-year freeze, EI premiums are set to rise by five cents per $100 of earnings in 2023, which is the maximum increase allowed in one year by legislation.

However, the increase falls short of what the Office of the Chief Actuary recommended for the program to break even by 2029.

Nancy Healey, the representative for employers on the Canadian Employment Insurance Commission, said "both business (and) labour are concerned about the amount of debt that's in the EI account right now."

The EI system is overseen by a commission that regularly reviews problems and the appeals system, as well as its financing. The commissioners bring the voices of workers and companies to the table, often consulting their constituents and raising concerns with permanent officials.

The representative for workers on the commission, Pierre Laliberté, said the federal government hasn't indicated whether it has any intention to pay off any of the debt.

"Everyone was surprised by the fact that at budget, there was no or partial compensation for the cost incurred during the pandemic," he said.

When asked whether there are any plans for the federal government to pay off some of the debt, a spokesperson for Employment Minister Carla Qualtrough said in a statement "these debts are resolved over many years, with the premium rates being determined using seven-year break-even projections."

"With the 5 cent increase, the rate will become $1.63 in 2023, which remains one of the lowest rates observed in Canada’s history," said Jane Deeks, the minister's director of communications.

Who should pay for the accumulated debt is part of a larger discussion on EI reform.

In 2021, the Liberals campaigned on a promise to modernize EI and pledged to expand the program to cover self-employed workers and address gaps, including those highlighted by the COVID-19.

Miles Corak, an economics professor at the City University of New York and longtime researcher on EI, said the reform should include changes to how the program is financed.

In a note published by the C.D. Howe Institute earlier this week, Corak made the case for tripartite funding of the program, where employers, workers and the government contribute.

He argues workers and employers shouldn't be burdened by unexpected shocks to the economy like the pandemic that cause a spike in "involuntary" unemployment.

"Sometimes workers are willing to work, are in the right place, and have the required skills, but the jobs are just not available," Corak wrote in the note, which is addressed to Qualtrough.

Corak suggests the federal government should cover increased costs to the program caused by unexpected economic shocks. At the same time, it should collect any surpluses accumulated during times of low unemployment.

Corak, who participated in public consultations held on EI reform, said both employer and workers groups seemed to react positively to his proposal.

"I'm sort of looking between the tea leaves here thinking, OK, that might be a way to get federal government financing involvement into the program," Corak said.

While the Liberals haven't given a timeline on the implementation of reform, they are expected to present their plan by the end of the year.

The idea of having the government contribute to the program isn't new. Prior to the 1990s, EI was financed through contributions from workers, employers and the federal government.

Unifor president Lana Payne says the union wants to see federal contributions reinstated "to both mitigate the accrued program deficit and support long-term enhancements to the program for workers."

However, Jennifer Robson, a Carleton University associate professor of political management, said she would be surprised if there was much enthusiasm from the federal government to contribute financially.

"My impression is that the current mood from the Department of Finance is much more one of fiscal restraint," Robson said.

MORE National ARTICLES

Structure fire in Surrey lands 2 in hospital, road closures in effect

Structure fire in Surrey lands 2 in hospital, road closures in effect
At approximately 3:54 pm this afternoon, Surrey RCMP received a report of a structure fire in the 14800 block of 75a avenue. Upon arrival, police found the residence fully engulfed, and firefighters were hard at work trying to contain the fire. Police and fire crews are on scene. It is expected that traffic in the area will be disrupted for some time.

Structure fire in Surrey lands 2 in hospital, road closures in effect

Late night shooting in Maple Ridge over the weekend lands man in hospital

Late night shooting in Maple Ridge over the weekend lands man in hospital
When police arrived they confirmed the man, a 51 year old Maple Ridge resident, was suffering from gunshot wounds. The man was transported to hospital with serious injuries. The house remains secured by police while they execute a search warrant.  

Late night shooting in Maple Ridge over the weekend lands man in hospital

Expert flags potential for dental-care clawbacks as result of federal program

Expert flags potential for dental-care clawbacks as result of federal program
The government plans to offer cheques of up to $650 to qualifying low- and middle-income families with children under the age of 12 to help pay for their dental needs. Qualifying families will have to attest that they don't have private insurance, that they have out-of-pocket dental expenses and that they will keep their receipts.

Expert flags potential for dental-care clawbacks as result of federal program

Arrests after violent end to Vancouver concert

Arrests after violent end to Vancouver concert
Police say fights broke out inside and outside the PNE Amphitheatre following the sudden cancellation of the headline act in the final hours of the two-day BreakOut Festival. The police statement says hostile concertgoers also caused significant property damage to the amphitheatre, other PNE grounds and the surrounding neighbourhood before order was restored.

Arrests after violent end to Vancouver concert

Surrey residence riddled with bullet holes after Sunday morning shooting

Surrey residence riddled with bullet holes after Sunday morning shooting
At approximately 4:30pm, on Sunday, Surrey RCMP responded to a report of shots fired in the 12300 block of 68thavenue. Responding officers attended and found shots fired into a residence and confirmed there were no injuries.

Surrey residence riddled with bullet holes after Sunday morning shooting

B.C. school support staff have tentative deal

B.C. school support staff have tentative deal
The Finance Ministry says the deal is between the Public School Employers' Association and school presidents' councils representing 57 locals of the Canadian Union of Public Employees.  

B.C. school support staff have tentative deal