Close X
Thursday, November 14, 2024
ADVT 
National

Watchdog Has 'No Confidence' In B.C. Ministry's Review Of Child Sex Abuse Case

The Canadian Press, 19 Jul, 2015 12:35 PM
    VICTORIA — British Columbia's children's minister has promised a review after social workers violated a court order and allowed a father who had molested his kids unsupervised visits.
     
    Stephanie Cadieux said Thursday her ministry will examine all the policy, practice and human resource concerns raised by a scathing B.C. Supreme Court ruling.
     
    "This family, and the rest of British Columbia, deserve to know the child welfare system is responsive and accountable for the decisions it makes," Cadieux told the legislature as the Opposition New Democrats demanded she apologize.
     
    The province's children and youth representative, Mary Ellen Turpel-Lafond, said she has "no confidence" in the ministry's ability to investigate itself.
     
    "This is a child welfare ministry that for some time has felt that it doesn't have to answer to independent oversight or to a court," she said in an interview.
     
    "They're not capable of holding each other to account. They do not have the structures to do that."
     
    Turpel-Lafond, who heads the independent body that oversees the child welfare system, said she wants to participate in the review or see a third party hired to do it.
     
    The ministry said it was working with the Public Service Agency to determine what kind of staff conduct review would work best, and details would be announced later.
     
    Justice Paul Walker said in a written decision released Tuesday that the ministry showed "reckless disregard" when it falsely accused a mother of being mentally ill and removed four children from her care in 2009.
     
    Social workers failed to investigate the kids' claims that their father had sexually abused them and knowingly violated a court order banning unsupervised visits, the ruling said.
     
    Turpel-Lafond said the ministry needs to take immediate action against the workers named in the judgment and examine all other child welfare cases on which they worked.
     
    She said the ministry's decision to eliminate the provincial director of child welfare between 2007 and 2011 created a system akin to the "Wild West" and that even now the director has no power over regional bosses.
     
    Social workers employed by the government are not required to register in the B.C. College of Social Workers, meaning they are not regulated by a professional body, Turpel-Lafond said.
     
    Children's Ministry spokesman Sheldon Johnson said all child protection workers must take specialized university courses and get on-the-job training including interviewing kids who may have been sexually abused. He said workers must have the skills required by the college although they don't need to register.
     
    Johnson said the ministry cannot comment on the individuals named in the judgment due to privacy legislation.
     
    The mother's lawyer, Jack Hittrich, has said that a team leader involved in her case, William Strickland, is still employed by the ministry.
     
    In the legislature, NDP Leader John Horgan questioned how many other court orders the ministry had ignored.
     
    "How many other children are being put at risk because the government believes it's above the law?" he said.
     
    Walker concluded in 2012 that the father physically and sexually abused the couple's three eldest children and gave the mother sole guardianship.
     
    In his decision released Tuesday, Walker determined that the father had also molested his youngest child while the couple's kids were in ministry care.
     
    The ministry has not said yet whether it plans to appeal the ruling.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    British Man And Former Soldier Of The Year Missing In B.C. Diving Accident

    British Man And Former Soldier Of The Year Missing In B.C. Diving Accident
    VANCOUVER — A 27-year-old British army veteran described as "no stranger to challenge" vanished during a recreational dive in waters off Victoria, but his family hopes a search will continue.

    British Man And Former Soldier Of The Year Missing In B.C. Diving Accident

    Winnipeg Explosion Sparks National Safety Discussion For Those In Family Law

    Winnipeg Explosion Sparks National Safety Discussion For Those In Family Law
    TORONTO — Family law practitioners across the country are re-assessing the steps they take to protect themselves in the wake of letter bombs being mailed to Winnipeg lawyers by a man who allegedly targeted those involved in his divorce proceedings.

    Winnipeg Explosion Sparks National Safety Discussion For Those In Family Law

    B.C. Court Of Appeal Rules Doctor Didn't Breach Colleague's Privacy

    B.C. Court Of Appeal Rules Doctor Didn't Breach Colleague's Privacy
    Dr. Akushla Wijay was one of three Port Alberni doctors sued for defamation by Dr. Magdy Fouad for conduct he alleged was calculated to destroy his reputation. 

    B.C. Court Of Appeal Rules Doctor Didn't Breach Colleague's Privacy

    TSB To Examine Small Plane Searching For Cause Of Fiery Crash On Highway 97 Near Osoyoos

    OSOYOOS, B.C. — The pilot of the plane that crashed Tuesday on Highway 97 near Osoyoos, B.C., almost didn't take to the skies because of forest fire smoke across the southern part of the province. 

    TSB To Examine Small Plane Searching For Cause Of Fiery Crash On Highway 97 Near Osoyoos

    Evacuations, Air Quality Advisories Continue In B.C. Amid Wildfires

    Evacuations, Air Quality Advisories Continue In B.C. Amid Wildfires
    VANCOUVER — Residents in part of British Columbia's Cariboo region have been forced from their homes after a wildfire more than doubled in size. 

    Evacuations, Air Quality Advisories Continue In B.C. Amid Wildfires

    Election Debates Take On Different Lustre, As NDP Gain Momentum In Polls

    Election Debates Take On Different Lustre, As NDP Gain Momentum In Polls
    OTTAWA — The Conservatives have turned down a debate put on by the major networks — but what if Stephen Harper's rivals just shrug?

    Election Debates Take On Different Lustre, As NDP Gain Momentum In Polls