Close X
Tuesday, October 1, 2024
ADVT 
National

Verdict oddity gets man off dangerous driving causing death charge

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 14 Jan, 2015 02:45 PM

    TORONTO — A man jailed four years ago for dangerous driving causing death had his conviction quashed Wednesday because of an oddity in the jury verdict that went unnoticed at the time.

    In entering an acquittal, Ontario's top court said its hands were tied in terms of ordering a new trial for Sean DeForest.

    The strange case arose in Angus, Ont., in September 2007 when the car DeForest and his girlfriend, Ashley Catton, were in made a left turn and collided with a car coming the other way. A motorcycle then slammed into the rear of the second vehicle, leaving the rider injured and his passenger fatally wounded.

    Police charged DeForest, then 20, with dangerous driving causing death and with dangerous driving causing bodily harm. The pair were also charged with obstruction for lying to police about who was driving.

    At trial, the defence argued Catton, then 19, was the driver. However, the jury appears to have accepted the prosecution view that DeForest was driving.

    In announcing their verdict, the jury declared DeForest guilty on Count 1: Dangerous driving causing the death of the motorcycle passenger.

    At the same time, however, jurors acquitted him on Count 2: Dangerous driving causing bodily harm to the motorcycle's driver.

    No one noticed the contradiction, and Superior Court Justice Anne Mullins later sentenced DeForest to 15 months for the dangerous driving conviction.

    On appeal, DeForest's lawyer argued jurors could not have felt certain DeForest was the driver who caused the death, but might not have been the driver responsible for the motorcyclist's injuries.

    The Ontario Court of Appeal agreed it made no sense.

    "The irreconcilable inconsistency between the verdicts on Counts 1 and 2 undermines the legitimacy and reliability of the convictions on the other charges," the court states.

    "All of the convictions must be quashed."

    Trial transcripts show the jury orally affirmed it had found DeForest guilty on the first count, but not on the second. There is no indication the trial judge looked at the verdict sheet filled out by the jury or made any further inquires.

    However, an examination of the jury sheet indicates the jury did in fact convict DeForest of dangerous driving in Count 2 — but intended to acquit him only of the bodily harm part.

    It appears, the Appeal Court concluded, jurors had no doubt DeForest was driving, but were not convinced the injuries to the motorcyclist amounted to bodily harm.

    That is not what they announced in open court and it is too late now to ask what they meant to do, the Appeal Court said.

    "I find no basis upon which the conviction on Count 1 and the acquittal on Count 2 can be reconciled," said Justice David Doherty, writing for the top court.

    Even though the problem might have been a simple communication error, the Appeal Court said it was legally constrained from ordering a new trial given the off-chance the jury did intend to acquit DeForest outright on the second dangerous driving charge.

    The court did order a new trial for both accused on the charges of obstructing police.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    PM Harper sets November date for federal byelections in Ontario and Alberta

    PM Harper sets November date for federal byelections in Ontario and Alberta
    OTTAWA - Prime Minister Stephen Harper has set Nov. 17 for two federal byelections in Ontario and Alberta, including the seat occupied by late finance minister Jim Flaherty.

    PM Harper sets November date for federal byelections in Ontario and Alberta

    Lax climate policy hasn't resulted in 'energy super power' status for Canada

    Lax climate policy hasn't resulted in 'energy super power' status for Canada
    OTTAWA - When the federal environment commissioner reported this week that Canada would not meet its 2020 international commitment on greenhouse gas emission cuts, no one was surprised.

    Lax climate policy hasn't resulted in 'energy super power' status for Canada

    How Terrorists Attract Lone Wolf Attackers

    How Terrorists Attract Lone Wolf Attackers
    Magazines of some of the world's most dreaded terrorist organisations are experimenting with strategies to increase motivation for lone wolf attacks, new research has found.

    How Terrorists Attract Lone Wolf Attackers

    Slocan Manhunt: Police Continue Search For Peter DeGroot Many Residents Being Allowed Home

    Slocan Manhunt: Police Continue Search For Peter DeGroot  Many Residents Being Allowed Home
    SLOCAN CITY, B.C. - The man at the centre of an RCMP manhunt in this small B.C. community is being described by his neighbours as someone who loves his animals but was a loner.

    Slocan Manhunt: Police Continue Search For Peter DeGroot Many Residents Being Allowed Home

    Hang On To Your Wallet And Put On An Extra Sweater For 'T-rex' Of Winters

    Hang On To Your Wallet And Put On An Extra Sweater For 'T-rex' Of Winters
    Energy industry players say they've learned from last year's so-called polar vortex and are bracing for what the Farmer's Almanac says will be another bitterly cold season — one that's already being dubbed the "T-Rex" of winters.

    Hang On To Your Wallet And Put On An Extra Sweater For 'T-rex' Of Winters

    PM Harper and Prentice meet in Calgary to discuss wide range of issues

    PM Harper and Prentice meet in Calgary to discuss wide range of issues
    CALGARY - Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Alberta's new premier are both describing their first meeting since Jim Prentice was sworn in last month as productive.

    PM Harper and Prentice meet in Calgary to discuss wide range of issues