Close X
Saturday, November 23, 2024
ADVT 
National

Trump 'poisoned' case against Meng: documents

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 24 Jul, 2020 05:54 PM
  • Trump 'poisoned' case against Meng: documents

New court documents accuse the United States president of "poisoning" the extradition case against a Huawei executive being held in Canada.

An application to B.C. Supreme Court by Meng Wanzhou's lawyers says misconduct by Donald Trump and interference by other U.S. officials meet the clear standard to stay proceedings for abuse of process.

The documents say Trump has used Meng's case to further his trade negotiations with China and that he intends to use her as a "bargaining chip" in the dispute, which is unrelated to the charges against her.

"By using Canada’s extradition process to gain a strategic advantage in its dispute with China, the United States has undermined — and is undermining — the integrity of Canada’s judicial proceedings," the documents say.

Trump has linked resolution of the U.S. government's dealings with Huawei to a potential trade agreement with China. He has said he would consider Huawei's role in a trade deal at the final stage of negotiations, the court application says.

"This prior conduct shows the reasonableness of (Meng's) fear that he will intervene in her case, and the merit of her submission that his comments have already poisoned the extradition process."

As long as Meng is the subject of an extradition process in Canada, "she can continue to be used as a bargaining chip by the U.S.," the document says.

Meng is being held on an U.S. extradition request over allegations that she lied about Huawei's relationship with a telecommunications company in Iran, violating American sanctions.

Both she and Huawei deny the charges.

Her arrest at Vancouver's airport in December 2018 has prompted increasing tensions between Canada and China. The arrests and subsequent spying allegations against Canadians Michael Kovrig and Michael Spavor in China are widely seen as an attempt to pressure Canada to release Meng.

She and is out on bail, living in her Vancouver home, while her legal team makes numerous applications for her freedom.

In May, Associate Chief Justice Heather Holmes dismissed the first phase of legal arguments by Meng's lawyers, who claimed the case should be thrown out because the U.S. allegations against her wouldn't be a crime in Canada.

The latest application filed with the court says continuing the proceedings "would inevitably undermine respect for, and confidence in, Canada’s judicial process. It would appear to condone and 'lend a stamp of approval' to the requesting state's intended misuse of the Canadian courts."

The documents say Prime Minister Justin Trudeau aligned Meng's case with Spavor and Kovrig by saying the United States shouldn't sign a final trade deal with China until the question of Meng and the detained men has been settled.

"Within this climate, every legal decision that (Meng) makes is improperly influenced by considerations about politics."

"These proceedings have been poisoned. They can no longer be reasonably regarded as fair, regardless of the undoubted good faith of the court," the document says.

"Prejudice to the fairness of these proceedings is made out by the president’s repeated assertions that (Meng's) liberty is effectively a bargaining chip in what he sees as the biggest trade deal ever."

Meng's lawyers are expected to make abuse of process arguments and apply for a stay in B.C. Supreme Court next February.

MORE National ARTICLES

RCMP probing hoax call to Lynn Valley care home

RCMP probing hoax call to Lynn Valley care home
A long-term care home in North Vancouver that was the site of Canada's first COVID-19 death says it received a hoax call as the outbreak began that created "needless fear" and compromised health and safety.

RCMP probing hoax call to Lynn Valley care home

B.C. brings in six judges to clear court backlog

B.C. brings in six judges to clear court backlog
Six more judges have been appointed to British Columbia's provincial court in an effort to clear away the backlog stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic.

B.C. brings in six judges to clear court backlog

B.C. plans to clear surgery backlog in 15 months

B.C. plans to clear surgery backlog in 15 months
British Columbia's health minister says the province has hired more staff and increased operating-room hours to catch up on cancelled surgeries but a significant surge in COVID-19 cases could impact recovery.

B.C. plans to clear surgery backlog in 15 months

Walmart to close its stores on Thanksgiving Day

Walmart to close its stores on Thanksgiving Day
Walmart Inc. said that it will be closing its namesake stores and Sam's Clubs on Thanksgiving Day this year, saying that it wants to have its employees spend time with their families during the coronavirus.

Walmart to close its stores on Thanksgiving Day

Closing arguments continue in cop's manslaughter trial

Closing arguments continue in cop's manslaughter trial
The injuries suffered by a Somali-Canadian man during an arrest in Ottawa four years ago did not cause or directly contribute to his death, defence lawyers told a police officer's manslaughter trial Tuesday.

Closing arguments continue in cop's manslaughter trial

Poll suggests parents want masks at schools

Poll suggests parents want masks at schools
Almost two-third of parents in a new poll say they believe that children returning to school in the fall should wear masks at least part of the time.

Poll suggests parents want masks at schools