Close X
Thursday, November 28, 2024
ADVT 
National

Trans Mountain Says Pipeline Will Boost Economy As Critics Cite Flawed Process

IANS, 21 Aug, 2015 11:40 AM
    VANCOUVER — An expanded Trans Mountain pipeline would add $18.2 billion to Canada's gross domestic product over 20 years, benefit First Nations and reduce environmental harm, Kinder Morgan says.
     
    The energy giant filed its final written submissions to the National Energy Board on Thursday, arguing the $5.4-billion proposal is a safe and viable option to transport diluted bitumen from Alberta's oilsands to British Columbia's coast.
     
    "The scrutiny and rigour this project has undergone, both inside and outside of the formal NEB process, is unprecedented," said Ian Anderson, president of Kinder Morgan Canada.
     
    "Our team takes pride in the efforts made to consider input and present the very best scientific and technical evidence to both the public and the regulator," he said in a statement.
     
    Kinder Morgan hopes to triple the capacity of its Trans Mountain line by laying almost 1,000 kilometres of new pipe from Edmonton to Metro Vancouver. The project would increase the number of tankers to 34 per month from five in Burrard Inlet.
     
    The Metro Vancouver regional council and North Vancouver's Tsleil-Waututh Nation are among the interveners who staunchly oppose the project, citing environmental and public health risks and little benefit to the economy.
     
    The energy board will make a recommendation to the federal government in January.
     
    In documents filed Thursday, the company addressed scathing evidence issued by interveners earlier this year. One expert report from Metro Vancouver found toxic benzene fumes from a spill could make up to one million people sick.
     
    Kinder Morgan said the report, conducted by Levelton Consultants Ltd., is misleading because it presents a worst-case scenario without qualification and doesn't account for its planned $100-million investment in spill response.
     
    It also vowed to meet 145 draft conditions issued last week by the energy board, but asked for scheduling changes. For example, the board asked for some reports to be filed a year before construction, but the company hopes to begin some work in June 2016.
     
    The company said it has signed 28 mutual benefits agreements with First Nations and promised to create employment and training opportunities for aboriginal communities.
     
    Trans Mountain spokeswoman Ali Hounsell said public feedback has prompted changes to the project, including thickening pipeline walls in cities, and routing to avoid 22 major river crossings.
     
    "We believe that the input and feedback we've received has made a better project — a stronger, safer, more responsible project. And we will continue to listen."
     
    Spencer Chandra Herbert, environment critic for B.C.'s Opposition New Democrats criticized the board for only requiring Kinder Morgan to respond to written questions rather than face oral cross-examination.
     
    "Just imagine any trial, in any court in this land, where the judge and jury would not have the benefit of cross-examination," he said. "The process wouldn't work.
     
    "Yet, the National Energy Board and Kinder Morgan want us to think that's OK here, for a project of such high risk to millions of people."
     
    Vancouver's deputy city manager Sadhu Johnston defended the city's expert reports, including its spill model, which found oil would float into English Bay in two hours.
     
    He said the model was done to National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration standards, while Kinder Morgan's model appeared to be "something they came up with on their own."
     
    Johnston said the company had two months to reply to the reports, while interveners now have just two weeks before responding at hearings in Burnaby in September. 
     
    He also lambasted the energy board for not considering climate change in its review.
     
    "This proposal is saying the project is in our best interests, when we're facing one of the worst droughts in our history," he said. "This process is an embarrassment for the NEB."

    MORE National ARTICLES

    B.C. First Nations Lawyer Says Crown Didn't Consult On Specific Site C Permits

    B.C. First Nations Lawyer Says Crown Didn't Consult On Specific Site C Permits
    VANCOUVER — Two northeastern British Columbia First Nations will suffer "irreparable harm" if thousands of hectares of old-growth forest are cleared to build the Site C dam, their lawyer says.

    B.C. First Nations Lawyer Says Crown Didn't Consult On Specific Site C Permits

    Mississauga Girl Manasvi Noel Crowned Miss India-Canada 2015

    Mississauga Girl Manasvi Noel Crowned Miss India-Canada 2015
    Dubai-born Noel won the esteemed title, the final top contenders for which included Sharon Philipose, Kajill Aujila, Tanpreet Parmar and Priya Sharma

    Mississauga Girl Manasvi Noel Crowned Miss India-Canada 2015

    Dangerous Bacterial Disease Claims 15-Month-Old Toronto Boy's Legs; Vaccination Has Made Hib Rare

    Dangerous Bacterial Disease Claims 15-Month-Old Toronto Boy's Legs; Vaccination Has Made Hib Rare
    One-year-old Ethan Faria has had part of both legs amputated in an attempt to save him from a blood infection triggered by Hemophilus influenzae Type B.

    Dangerous Bacterial Disease Claims 15-Month-Old Toronto Boy's Legs; Vaccination Has Made Hib Rare

    NDP Wants RCMP To Consider Charging Wright, Other PMO Staffers, In Duffy Affair

    NDP Wants RCMP To Consider Charging Wright, Other PMO Staffers, In Duffy Affair
    OTTAWA — The NDP wants the RCMP to consider laying charges against Nigel Wright and up to a dozen other staffers in the Prime Minister's Office for their part in covering up the scandal over Sen. Mike Duffy's expenses.

    NDP Wants RCMP To Consider Charging Wright, Other PMO Staffers, In Duffy Affair

    Then And Now: Top Conservative Aides And What They Said About The Duffy Affair

    Then And Now: Top Conservative Aides And What They Said About The Duffy Affair
    Top Conservative aides have made statements over the course of the scandal around Sen. Mike Duffy's expenses that have been later contradicted, or substantially changed. Here are a few examples.

    Then And Now: Top Conservative Aides And What They Said About The Duffy Affair

    Quebec Bar Owners Threaten To Sue Over Bill That Would Ban Smoking On Patios

    Quebec Bar Owners Threaten To Sue Over Bill That Would Ban Smoking On Patios
     The head of a group of bar owners has threatened to take legal action if Quebec goes ahead with legislation to ban smoking on outdoor patios.

    Quebec Bar Owners Threaten To Sue Over Bill That Would Ban Smoking On Patios