Close X
Thursday, November 7, 2024
ADVT 
National

Trans Mountain Granted Injunction Against Pipeline Protesters At Two B.C. Sites

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 16 Mar, 2018 07:16 PM
    VANCOUVER — Protesters must be restrained from obstructing the expansion of the Trans Mountain pipeline, says a British Columbia Supreme Court judge who has granted the company an injunction aimed at preventing people from entering within five metres of two work sites.
     
     
    Justice Kenneth Affleck said Thursday he felt it necessary to make a decision on the second day of a hearing instead of issuing a written order involving outraged demonstrators who have blocked vehicles and workers at the Burnaby Terminal and the Westridge Marine Terminal.
     
     
    The injunction is indefinite, allowing Trans Mountain to continue work it's legally entitled to do after the federal government approved the twinning of an existing pipeline from Edmonton to Burnaby in the belief it is in the best interest of Canada, Affleck said.
     
     
    Trans Mountain has said that while protests began last November, it sought an injunction after demonstrators began intensifying their blockades recently when trees were being cleared. It said construction at the sites in Burnaby, B.C., is expected to last until December 2020.
     
     
    Affleck agreed with lawyers for two of 15 named defendants in a notice of civil claim that a 50-metre perimeter as part of an interim injunction he granted last week was too broad because it encroached on private property and trails. 
     
     
    Trans Mountain's lawyer, Shaun Parker, requested a structure called Camp Cloud near the Burnaby Terminal be removed, calling it a "hotbed of aggressive activity" for protesters who want to "destroy the project."
     
     
    But the judge said it will stay.
     
     
    "In my view there has to be a means of allowing the protesters who object to this work to remain reasonably close to the site," Affleck said. "The plaintiff is going to have to tolerate a certain amount of agitation."
     
     
    Parker was also unsuccessful in his request for an order requiring the removal of a structure called the Watch House, saying it's on a pipeline right of way and would cause significant safety risks.
     
     
    "I'm sensitive to the concern of those who created this Watch House, that it is of considerable significance to them," Affleck said of the structure that was erected near the Burnaby Terminal on Saturday, when people marched against the pipeline.
     
     
     
     
    He said Trans Mountain would have to demonstrate any emergency need to remove the Watch House but would then have to replace it.
     
     
    Casey Leggett, a lawyer for one of the defendants, said citizens have a constitutional right to protest the expansion of the pipeline.
     
     
    "The inconvenience, which my friends call a blockade, hasn't gotten to the level of establishing irreparable harm," Leggett said.
     
     
    He read from affidavits presented in court by a Trans Mountain lawyer, saying the company's security staff noted protesters have sometimes stood peacefully at or near access roads to two marine terminals in Burnaby without disrupting vehicles or workers and left after police arrived.
     
     
    He said in one case, a woman was seen praying on a road and didn't engage with security staff while on another day a woman sat in a lawn chair as vehicles were guided around her at slow speed.
     
     
    Affleck said while the first protesters' conduct was unobjectionable, the second woman had no right to sit in the middle of a public road and the police would be justified in removing her.
     
     
    The judge also suggested Leggett was cherry-picking incidents that did not involve blockades aimed at stopping work at the terminals.
     
     
    Leggett replied that Trans Mountain had done the same and also focused on blockades rather than inconvenience, which he said does not justify an injunction.
     
     
    Activists have said they will continue opposing the $7.4-billion project despite the injunction.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Mississauga Gymnastics Coach Charged After Allegedly Sexually Assaulting Teen Girl

    Mississauga Gymnastics Coach Charged After Allegedly Sexually Assaulting Teen Girl
    Peel regional police say they were approached earlier this year by a 15-year-old girl from the area who reported multiple allegations of sexual misconduct over a four-year period.

    Mississauga Gymnastics Coach Charged After Allegedly Sexually Assaulting Teen Girl

    Insurer Must Pay $237,000 In Legal Costs To Elderly Woman Awarded $20,000

    Insurer Must Pay $237,000 In Legal Costs To Elderly Woman Awarded $20,000
    TORONTO — An insurance company that played litigation hardball with an elderly car-accident victim has been ordered to pay $237,000 to cover the legal costs she incurred in winning a $20,000 settlement.

    Insurer Must Pay $237,000 In Legal Costs To Elderly Woman Awarded $20,000

    2 Arrested After Volunteers Clash During Tiranga Rally In UP Town

    2 Arrested After Volunteers Clash During Tiranga Rally In UP Town
    The rally was taken out by activists of the Hindu Yuva Vahini and Bajrang Dal in the wake of the killing of a youth, Chandan Gupta, in Kasganj last week

    2 Arrested After Volunteers Clash During Tiranga Rally In UP Town

    Surrey Man Charged After Loaded Pistol, Drugs And Cash Seized During Traffic Stop

    Surrey Man Charged After Loaded Pistol, Drugs And Cash Seized During Traffic Stop
    Police Say John Schoch Faces Five Charges In Connection To The Incident, And More Are Possible

    Surrey Man Charged After Loaded Pistol, Drugs And Cash Seized During Traffic Stop

    Three Charged In 2016 Surrey Shooting And 'Targeted' Break-and-Enter

    Three Charged In 2016 Surrey Shooting And 'Targeted' Break-and-Enter
    After a lengthy investigation following a 2016 shooting, several charges have been approved against three people.

    Three Charged In 2016 Surrey Shooting And 'Targeted' Break-and-Enter

    Nick Geer, Businessman And Former Head Of ICBC, Dies In California Car Crash

    Nick Geer, Businessman And Former Head Of ICBC, Dies In California Car Crash
    VANCOUVER — Prominent British Columbia business leader Nick Geer has been killed in a car crash in California.

    Nick Geer, Businessman And Former Head Of ICBC, Dies In California Car Crash