Close X
Wednesday, December 4, 2024
ADVT 
National

Trade minister criticizes higher U.S. softwood lumber duties as unfair, unwarranted

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 14 Aug, 2024 09:46 AM
  • Trade minister criticizes higher U.S. softwood lumber duties as unfair, unwarranted

Canada's international trade minister is criticizing the U.S. Department of Commerce for nearly doubling duties on softwood lumber, saying the move is unfair and unwarranted.

Minister Mary Ng said the U.S. has significantly increased duties on softwood lumber from Canada, to 14.54 per cent from 8.05 per cent.

"Baseless and unfair U.S. duties on softwood lumber unjustifiably harm consumers and producers on both sides of the border," Ng said in a news release.

It's the latest salvo in a bilateral back-and-forth that Ottawa has described as a drag on efforts to improve the cost and supply of housing.

The increase in the so-called "all others" combined duty rate has received backlash from government and industry in British Columbia.

"We have said from the start and we will say it again now: The only solution is an end to unfair softwood lumber duties," said B.C. Forests Minister Bruce Ralston in a news release.

The U.S. Department of Commerce, under the Tariff Act, determines whether goods are being sold at less than fair value or if they're benefiting from subsidies provided by foreign governments.

Canadian lumber-producing provinces set so-called stumpage fees for timber harvested from Crown land. U.S. producers, who are forced to pay market rates, argue that amounts to an unfair subsidy.

Canadian lumber producers have already paid more than $9 billion in duties, which are held in deposit until this dispute is resolved.

The B.C. Lumber Trade Council said the increase couldn’t come at a worse time, exacerbating already challenging conditions. 

"The increase in U.S. tariffs on B.C. lumber products will exacerbate the extremely challenging conditions faced by B.C. producers and will impact manufacturing operations, jobs and communities around the province," president Kurt Niquidet said in a news release.

The softwood lumber dispute unfairly hurts small, family-owned companies "who are innocent bystanders in this long-standing dispute between American landowners and international lumber corporations," said Independent Wood Processors Association of British Columbia chair Andy Rielly.

Its members buy their lumber or logs on the open market the same as American companies, a news release said. The association is calling on Ottawa to negotiate a solution. 

A CIBC analyst note on the lumber duties said it's unlikely Ottawa or the Biden administration are focused on solving the issue as a trade dispute because it's not the major cause of job losses in the industry in Canada. It said job loss was linked to less robust lumber demand and B.C. fibre constraints.

Canada is using a litigation route, challenging the rates through a Canada-U.S.-Mexico agreement dispute panel.

Ottawa has seen previous success arguing at World Trade Organization dispute panels that its stumpage-fee system is not a subsidy. Last year a North American Free Trade Agreement dispute panel that found aspects of how the U.S. calculates the duties are inconsistent with federal law. 

The U.S. Commerce Department's fifth administrative review of the duties released Tuesday was a bit higher than the preliminary rate of 13.86 per cent announced in February. 

The new rate will likely be in effect until mid-August 2025 when the sixth administrative review rates will be applied.

The move was applauded by industry in America, including the U.S. Lumber Coalition, which said Canada's actions were deepening market downcycles.

"The United States does not need the unfairly traded Canadian lumber imports to supply current levels of home construction," Andrew Miller, the coalition's chairman, said in a news release.

Ng said it is in the best interests of both Canada and the United States to find a lasting resolution to the dispute.

"We will always fight for the best interest of Canadians and continue to use all available avenues to vigorously defend the workers, businesses, and communities who rely on softwood lumber for their livelihoods," she said. 

MORE National ARTICLES

First GST/HST credit payment set for July 5

First GST/HST credit payment set for July 5
The Canada Revenue Agency says single Canadians could get up to $519 over the course of the four payments, while those who are married or have a common-law partner could get up to $680. 

First GST/HST credit payment set for July 5

New poll on PM's future

New poll on PM's future
A Leger poll, conducted online of 1,521 people between June 28 and June 30, found two-thirds of those who responded believe Trudeau will remain as party leader all the way to the next election.

New poll on PM's future

Sudden death of a man in Vancouver

Sudden death of a man in Vancouver
Police in Vancouver are asking for the public's help to identify two men who they say might have information about the sudden death of another man. They say the 35-year-old man was found dead in his apartment in the city's West End neighbourhood on May 30th.

Sudden death of a man in Vancouver

Targeted shooting in Kamloops

Targeted shooting in Kamloops
Kamloops R-C-M-P say a 40-year-old man known to police has suffered serious, but non-life-threatening injuries after a targeted shooting that officers believe to be gang-related. Police say it happened last night in the 170 block of Tranquille Road.

Targeted shooting in Kamloops

48 year old Inderjit Singh Sandhu sentenced to life in imprisonment for killing wife Kamaljit Sandhu

48 year old Inderjit Singh Sandhu sentenced to life in imprisonment for killing wife Kamaljit Sandhu
Police say a 48-year-old Abbotsford man has been sentenced to life in prison without parole eligibility for 13 years for murdering his wife. Inderjit Singh Sandhu pleaded guilty in April to second-degree murder in connection with the July 2022 homicide in the Fraser Valley city.

48 year old Inderjit Singh Sandhu sentenced to life in imprisonment for killing wife Kamaljit Sandhu

Environment Canada issues multiple warnings as B.C. braces for weekend heat

Environment Canada issues multiple warnings as B.C. braces for weekend heat
The six warnings span Vancouver Island, where they will be in effect from Friday until early next week, and the North Coast including Kitimat and Terrace, where the warnings will be in place from Saturday until Tuesday night.

Environment Canada issues multiple warnings as B.C. braces for weekend heat