Close X
Thursday, December 12, 2024
ADVT 
National

Toronto's police chief will not be called to testify at G20 hearing

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 14 Jan, 2015 10:43 AM

    Toronto's police chief will not have to testify at a disciplinary hearing for the most senior officer charged over mass arrests made during the city's G20 summit, a retired judge ruled Wednesday after finding that the top cop's evidence would be irrelevant.

    The proceeding is looking into the actions of Supt. David Fenton, who has pleaded not guilty to five Police Services Act charges stemming from two "kettling" incidents that occurred over the tumultuous 2010 summit weekend.

    When he took the stand in his own defence in mid December, Fenton told the hearing his superiors were fully aware of the manner in which he had ordered the arrests, which became the largest in Canadian peacetime history.

    After hearing his statements, lawyers for complainants involved in the case had requested that Chief Bill Blair and retired deputy chief Tony Warr be called before the hearing to explain their involvement in Fenton's decisions.

    Counsel for Blair and Warr argued that the two senior officers' evidence would be irrelevant and that the police chief could not be compelled to appear.

    Retired Ontario judge John Hamilton, who has been hearing the case, agreed with those arguments.

    "I find that procedural fairness would be trampled upon if I were to allow deputy Warr or Chief Blair to be summoned to testify in this hearing," Hamilton said as he delivered his decision on Wednesday.

    "I would like to continue with the business of hearing evidence pertaining to the allegations of misconduct against Supt. Fenton."

    Blair was found to be "not a compellable witness" as he has the authority of a hearing officer under the Police Services Act — powers he has delegated in Fenton's case to Hamilton, but authority he still nonetheless holds.

    "The legislature set this up this way so that the chief keeps the authority," said Hamilton. "I find that the role of the chief of police when dealing with conduct of his officers, is adjudicative in nature. The chief is the employer."

    Hamilton also found that counsel for the complainants who had sought to have Blair and Warr testify already possessed information on the extent of the two senior officers' involvement in the events that took place during the summit weekend.

    "I find that Chief Blair does not have evidence relevant to the decision I must make about Supt. Fenton's conduct," Hamilton said.

    A lawyer for the three complainants who had tried to have Blair and Warr summoned expressed disappointment at Hamilton's ruling and noted that the testimony of the two senior officers was only sought after Fenton brought up their involvement.

    "Supt. Fenton is the one who put their evidence, their conduct, into evidence and that is directly relevant to the issues in the proceedings," said Adrienne Lei

    "If Fenton's going to be running the Nuremberg defence then the prosecution should have the right to put the evidence of Blair and Warr directly to him. If he's just following orders, we need to talk to the person who is giving the orders."

    Fenton is expected to resume testifying in his own defence on Thursday.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Michael Hume B.C. Trial Hears Phone Message From Alleged Sexual Assault Victim Pleading For Help

    Michael Hume B.C. Trial Hears Phone Message From Alleged Sexual Assault Victim Pleading For Help
    KAMLOOPS, B.C. — The trial of a longtime youth and justice worker accused of sexually assaulting a resident in a community he once helped has heard a recording of a phone call as the alleged victim pleaded for help.

    Michael Hume B.C. Trial Hears Phone Message From Alleged Sexual Assault Victim Pleading For Help

    School Prank By B.C. Boy Costs His Parents Nearly $50,000, Breaks New Legal Ground

    School Prank By B.C. Boy Costs His Parents Nearly $50,000, Breaks New Legal Ground
    The case involves a then-14-year-old boy who caused $48,630 in damage when he attached a padlock to just one sprinkler head inside Wellington secondary but set off other sprinklers. 

    School Prank By B.C. Boy Costs His Parents Nearly $50,000, Breaks New Legal Ground

    Court nixes rule requiring Air Canada to separate pooches, allergic passengers

    Court nixes rule requiring Air Canada to separate pooches, allergic passengers
    The Canadian Transportation Agency has been ordered to reconsider a ruling that required Air Canada to separate pooches from passengers with dog allergies in its airline cabins.

    Court nixes rule requiring Air Canada to separate pooches, allergic passengers

    Bill Cosby moves on to second Ontario show after standing ovation last night

    Bill Cosby moves on to second Ontario show after standing ovation last night
    LONDON, Ont. — Bill Cosby's first Canadian performance may have gone ahead without a hitch but it remained to be seen whether his second appearance would roll out as smoothly in a city where residents opposing the embattled comedian vowed to send him a message.

    Bill Cosby moves on to second Ontario show after standing ovation last night

    Journalism has made some targets in Canada as well

    Journalism has made some targets in Canada as well
    Ottawa teenager Nora Sharmarke was only ten when her journalist father, Canadian Al Iman Sharmarke, was killed over his coverage of Islamic extremism in his native country of Somalia.

    Journalism has made some targets in Canada as well

    Mount Saint Vincent University instructor resigns, says he had sex with student

    Mount Saint Vincent University instructor resigns, says he had sex with student
    HALIFAX — A lecturer at a Halifax university has issued a public apology and resigned from his position after saying he had sex with a student and exchanged explicit images with her.

    Mount Saint Vincent University instructor resigns, says he had sex with student