Close X
Tuesday, December 3, 2024
ADVT 
National

Toronto Man In Contempt For Refusing To Hand Over Dangerous Doberman To Be Put Down

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 22 Jul, 2016 01:49 PM
    TORONTO — A man who refused to turn over his aggressive Doberman pinscher to be euthanized was found in contempt of court Friday.
     
    In its ruling, Ontario's Court of Appeal sided with health authorities in finding Rob Szalas had defied the spirit of previous court orders by sending the animal to the United States.
     
    "Mr. Szalas demonstrated blatant contempt for the administration of justice by ignoring repeated orders and demands to surrender the dog," the Appeal Court ruled. 
     
    Dr. Jim Chirico, the medical officer of health for the North Bay Parry Sound District Health Unit, had ordered Szalas to turn over his dog to the humane society be put down after it bit four people, without provocation, in 2013 and 2014.
     
    Szalas initially handed over the Doberman but appealed the euthanasia order and was allowed to keep the dog pending the outcome of that battle. He breached several conditions, including that the dog be leashed and muzzled, court records show.
     
    His appeals were ultimately rejected and a representative of the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals went to his home to retrieve the dog so it could be put down. Szalas again refused to let that happen and, instead, sent the animal to the U.S.
     
    Chirico went back to court to argue the owner was in contempt of his euthanasia order but in April 2015, Superior Court Justice Paul Rivard dismissed the contempt motion, despite finding that Szalas had behaved in a "wilful and deliberate way."
     
    Rivard decided that the order had been to turn over the Doberman to the humane society — but it was the SPCA that came to collect it.
     
    Chirico turned to the Ontario Court of Appeal, which found Szalas had failed to follow the spirit of the order.
     
    "By not giving up possession of his dog to be euthanized, Mr. Szalas did just that," the Appeal Court ruled. "Simply put, the days are long gone when someone subject to a court order can get away with circumventing it by relying on a benign technicality."
     
    The Appeal Court referred the matter back to a lower court judge other than Rivard to allow Szalas the chance to purge his contempt. The lower court will then determine the appropriate sanction.
     
    The court also ordered Szalas to pay Chirico $1,500 in costs for the appeal.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Calgary Stampede Attendance At 22-year Low As Rain And Recession Thin Crowds

    Calgary Stampede Attendance At 22-year Low As Rain And Recession Thin Crowds
    CALGARY — The rain-plagued Calgary Stampede is reporting its lowest total attendance in 22 years.

    Calgary Stampede Attendance At 22-year Low As Rain And Recession Thin Crowds

    Nav Canada To Drop Fees For Airlines, Aircraft Operators By $150 Million

    Nav Canada To Drop Fees For Airlines, Aircraft Operators By $150 Million
    OTTAWA — Airlines and other aircraft operators are in line for $150 million of fee reductions over two years from Nav Canada, which operates Canada's air navigation system.

    Nav Canada To Drop Fees For Airlines, Aircraft Operators By $150 Million

    Declined: Walmart Kicks Off Visa Credit Card Ban In Thunder Bay, Ont.

    Declined: Walmart Kicks Off Visa Credit Card Ban In Thunder Bay, Ont.
    MONTREAL — Three Walmart stores in Thunder Bay, Ont., are no longer accepting Visa, the payment company said Monday as it encouraged its customers to take their business elsewhere.

    Declined: Walmart Kicks Off Visa Credit Card Ban In Thunder Bay, Ont.

    Jail Program Gives Moms A New Start, Helps Babies Develop, Advocates Say

    Jail Program Gives Moms A New Start, Helps Babies Develop, Advocates Say
    Mo Korchinski remembers what it was like being separated from her three children. Her struggle with addiction and cycle through British Columbia's corrections system led her to what she calls a state of denial of even having them.

    Jail Program Gives Moms A New Start, Helps Babies Develop, Advocates Say

    PM Signs Book Of Condolences At French Embassy Following Nice Attack

    OTTAWA — Prime Minister Justin Trudeau visited the French embassy in Ottawa Monday to pay his respects to the victims of a terrorist attack in Nice.

    PM Signs Book Of Condolences At French Embassy Following Nice Attack

    Peel Police Issue Internal Memo After Officers Failed To Return Sikh Man's Turban

    Peel Police Issue Internal Memo After Officers Failed To Return Sikh Man's Turban
    Charges of impaired operation and excess blood alcohol against Sardul Singh were dismissed because Peel Regional Police officers did not return his turban after it fell while he was being placed in a cruiser.

    Peel Police Issue Internal Memo After Officers Failed To Return Sikh Man's Turban