Close X
Saturday, November 23, 2024
ADVT 
National

Top court upholds escort service convictions

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 19 Nov, 2021 04:45 PM
  • Top court upholds escort service convictions

OTTAWA - The Supreme Court of Canada has upheld the convictions of two men arising from their operation of an escort service, settling a dispute over validity of the law when the offences took place.

In its 7-2 decision Friday, the high court said the Criminal Code provision under which the men were convicted was in effect at the time of the offences, despite having been found unconstitutional.

In a landmark 2013 decision, the Supreme Court declared the provision against living on the avails of sex work to be overbroad and in violation of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. For instance, the law criminalized actions, such as working as a bodyguard, that could enhance the safety of sex workers.

However, the top court suspended the declaration of invalidity for one year, to end on Dec. 20, 2014, giving Parliament time to pass a new law, which it did before the suspension expired.

Kasra Mohsenipour and Tamim Albashir were convicted in 2018 of several offences related to their operation of an escort service in British Columbia, including living on the avails of sex work, during 2014.

The trial judge quashed the counts of living on the avails because of the Supreme Court's earlier declaration of unconstitutionality, but the B.C. Court of Appeal overturned the decision and entered convictions for the men.

The Appeal Court said the "parasitic, exploitative conduct" of the two men could not be immune to criminal liability simply because it occurred during the suspended declaration of invalidity and the fact charges were laid afterward.

By imposing a suspension of its declaration of invalidity, the Supreme Court extended the life of the law, the Appeal Court said.

The men then took their cases to the Supreme Court of Canada.

In writing for the majority, Supreme Court Justice Andromache Karakatsanis said the purpose behind the suspension was to maintain the protection of vulnerable sex workers by avoiding the deregulation of sex work while Parliament crafted replacement legislation.

In light of that purpose, she concluded the declaration of invalidity was effective at the end of the period of suspension, making the men liable under the criminal provision for their conduct during the suspension period.

Karakatsanis also stressed that someone whose charter rights are breached by a law declared to be unconstitutional is not left without remedy.

She noted that if an accused were charged with conduct that had no relation to the living on the avails offence — for example because they were a driver or bodyguard — a judge may find a breach of the person's constitutional rights and grant an exception.

In this case, because the two men engaged in exploitative conduct that was always legitimately criminalized, such a remedy is not available to them, she said.

Karakatsanis said she would expect courts in the future to explicitly explain the timing related to declarations of invalidity to avoid any confusion.

"Where the court has been explicit, it is unnecessary to consider the necessary implications of a suspension."

 

MORE National ARTICLES

473 COVID19 cases for Friday

473 COVID19 cases for Friday
There are currently 4,265 active cases of COVID-19 in the province, and 204,963 people who tested positive have recovered. Of the active cases, 384 individuals are currently in hospital and 124 are in intensive care. The remaining people are recovering at home in self-isolation.

473 COVID19 cases for Friday

Police and SAR searching for Shannon White: Kamloops RCMP

Police and SAR searching for Shannon White: Kamloops RCMP
As part of the investigation, police received information confirming Ms. White’s vehicle left town for a 45-minute period on Nov. 1, shortly after Ms. White was supposed to have arrived at work.  Her vehicle was observed travelling west on the Trans Canada Highway, leading officers to the area being searched.  

Police and SAR searching for Shannon White: Kamloops RCMP

Canada could OK kids vaccine in '1 to 2 weeks'

Canada could OK kids vaccine in '1 to 2 weeks'
Canada's chief medical adviser Dr. Supriya Sharma said in a conference call with reporters Friday that the regulator is "actively continuing" its review of the Pfizer-BioNtech jab for children aged five to 11, which was authorized for use in the United States earlier this month.

Canada could OK kids vaccine in '1 to 2 weeks'

Ng disappointed, not daunted by US protectionism

Ng disappointed, not daunted by US protectionism
Mary Ng said that includes the revival of Buy American provisions in President Joe Biden's massive new infrastructure bill, which are creating more hurdles for foreign companies to bid on lucrative projects.

Ng disappointed, not daunted by US protectionism

B.C. Remembrance Day gatherings disrupted

B.C. Remembrance Day gatherings disrupted
A lawyer says he and his two young daughters left what he thought was a Remembrance Day ceremony In Kamloops after it turned out to be a protest against British Columbia's vaccine mandate. 

B.C. Remembrance Day gatherings disrupted

VPD investigates city's 15th homicide

VPD investigates city's 15th homicide
Yesterday morning, staff at a social housing complex near Main and East Cordova streets found Joshua Hough, 43, deceased in his suite. One arrest has been made, and the investigation is ongoing.

VPD investigates city's 15th homicide