Close X
Sunday, November 24, 2024
ADVT 
National

Top court touts role of free expression

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 10 Sep, 2020 08:31 PM
  • Top court touts role of free expression

The ability to express oneself helps create a healthy democracy, the Supreme Court of Canada said Thursday in setting out rules for deciding when a lawsuit has merit or is intended simply to quell participation in matters of public interest.

The detailed guidance came as the high court ruled on two Ontario cases that involved speaking out on issues of public significance.

Strategic lawsuits against public participation — known as SLAPPs — are levied against people or organizations that take a position on an issue, with the aim of limiting their free speech.

In response to a spate of such cases, Ontario, British Columbia and Quebec have enacted laws to curb them. Both matters before the Supreme Court entailed the application of Ontario's Protection of Public Participation Act, which took effect five years ago.

In the first case, the Supreme Court applied its new framework for interpreting the law in unanimously deciding a developer's breach-of-contract action shouldn't proceed against a not-for-profit corporation that had opposed a planned subdivision in Sault Ste. Marie, Ont., on environmental grounds.

"Freedom of expression is a fundamental right and value," wrote Justice Suzanne Cote on behalf of the court, adding "the ability to express oneself and engage in the interchange of ideas fosters a pluralistic and healthy democracy by generating fruitful public discourse and corresponding public participation in civil society."

In the second case, the high court ruled 5-4 that a medical doctor's libel case over email remarks by a lawyer could go ahead.

The dispute began when Dr. Howard Platnick was hired in 2014 to help assess a claim related to an auto accident on behalf of an insurer.

Following settlement, Maia Bent, lawyer for a client who claimed serious injury as a result of the accident, posted critical comments about Platnick on an automated email service for members of the Ontario Trial Lawyers Association.

Bent's email was leaked to the media, prompting Platnick to request an apology and retraction, and later to sue Bent and her law firm for libel.

Bent and her firm successfully moved for dismissal of his action on the basis that her communication concerned a matter of public interest, but the Ontario Court of Appeal overturned the decision.

In its ruling Thursday, the Supreme Court said Dr. Platnick "deserves to have his day in court" to potentially vindicate his reputation.

MORE National ARTICLES

Appeal heard in N.S. assisted death case

Appeal heard in N.S. assisted death case
A Nova Scotia Appeal Court judge has reserved her decision in a case involving a woman who is trying to stop her husband from receiving medical assistance in dying.

Appeal heard in N.S. assisted death case

N.B. parties look for all-important majority

N.B. parties look for all-important majority
When Progressive Conservative Leader Blaine Higgs called a snap election last week, he said he wanted to bring political stability to New Brunswick following two years of a minority Tory government — but a look at the province's electoral landscape reveals how difficult that is to do.

N.B. parties look for all-important majority

No charges in Korchinski-Paquet death

No charges in Korchinski-Paquet death
Regis Korchinski-Paquet fell to her death while trying to sidestep onto a neighbour's balcony, said a report released Wednesday by Ontario's police watchdog, which concludes there are no grounds to charge officers who were in her home at the time.

No charges in Korchinski-Paquet death

WATCH: Drug Overdose crisis sees 175 deaths for July, Trudeau invests $2B in schools, Canucks win against Vegas

WATCH: Drug Overdose crisis sees 175 deaths for July, Trudeau invests $2B in schools, Canucks win against Vegas
Drug Overdose crisis for BC Up by 136% - 175 deaths in July 2020, hospitalizations on the rise in BC due to COVID-19, Vancouver Canucks showed they could do better as they win Tuesday night's game against the Golden Vegas Knights.

WATCH: Drug Overdose crisis sees 175 deaths for July, Trudeau invests $2B in schools, Canucks win against Vegas

Indigenous teen remembered as driven and hilarious

Indigenous teen remembered as driven and hilarious
Roderica Ribbonleg had big plans to make her family proud and her first milestone was her high school graduation.

Indigenous teen remembered as driven and hilarious

Disability aid to cost $792 million, says PBO

Disability aid to cost $792 million, says PBO
The parliamentary budget office says a one-time payment to people with disabilities this fall will cost the federal treasury $792 million.

Disability aid to cost $792 million, says PBO