Thursday, March 28, 2024
ADVT 
National

Supreme Court will hear Quebec comedian's case

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 30 Jul, 2020 08:01 PM
  • Supreme Court will hear Quebec comedian's case

The Supreme Court of Canada has decided to hear the appeal of Quebec comedian Mike Ward in a human-rights case that touches on the limits of artistic expression and the role of the country's human rights tribunals.

Ward is appealing a decision by Quebec's highest court that largely upheld a human rights tribunal's ruling requiring the comedian to pay damages to a disabled singer he mocked. As is customary, the Supreme Court gave no reasons for why it decided to hear the case.

The Quebec Court of Appeal ruled last November that Ward's comments about Jeremy Gabriel's disability compromised the young performer's right to the safeguarding of his dignity and could not be justified, even in a society where freedom of expression is valued.

In a 2-1 decision, the court said "comedians must nevertheless realize that artistic freedom isn't absolute and they are, like all citizens, responsible for the consequences of their actions when they exceed certain limits."

A 2016 Quebec Human Rights Tribunal ruling had ordered Ward to pay $35,000 in moral and punitive damages to Gabriel based on comments he made during shows between 2010 and 2013.

Gabriel has Treacher Collins syndrome, a congenital disorder characterized by skull and facial deformities. He became a celebrity in Quebec after he sang with Celine Dion and for the Pope.

In his act, Ward joked he thought Gabriel's illness was terminal and people were only nice to him because he would soon die. Ward then joked that after he realized the child was not going to die, he tried to drown him.

Julius Grey, a human-rights lawyer who represents Ward, said he and his client are relieved by the Supreme Court's decision.

Quebec's human rights commission can only act, Grey said, if someone is the victim of discrimination. At issue, he explained, is whether making fun of someone's disability is a form of discrimination. Grey said the ruling will have an impact on all of Canada's human rights tribunals.

The other important question the country's highest court will have to debate, Grey said, is what effect discriminating words have on freedom of expression. "There are not many cases on artistic content and it's extremely important for the Supreme Court, I think, to guide Canadians with respect to the limits of artistic and other expression," he said.

Grey said the dissenting voice in the Appeal Court decision demonstrates his case is strong. Justice Manon Savard disagreed with her two colleagues, writing that Ward's jokes were "shocking and degrading," but they did not amount to discrimination.

"The appellant's words do not convey discriminatory discourse and do not seek to arouse in his audience a belief that the dignity of the respondent, Jeremy Gabriel, because of his disability, is of less value."

Ward has defended himself on Twitter, saying comedy is not a crime. "In a 'free' country, it shouldn't be up to a judge to decide what constitutes a joke on stage," Ward has tweeted. "The people in attendance laughing already answered that question."

Meissoon Azzaria, spokeswoman for Quebec's human rights commission, said the agency "takes note" of the court's decision. "The issues debated are important for society in order to clarify, in particular, the balance between freedom of expression and the right to equality ... regarding the protection of one's dignity, honour and reputation."

Gabriel did not immediately respond to a request for an interview.

Grey said it will take about one year for the parties to be ready to plead before the Supreme Court.

MORE National ARTICLES

N.B. woman found after almost two weeks missing

N.B. woman found after almost two weeks missing
A New Brunswick woman says she was able to survive in woods in the northeast of the province for nearly two weeks by drinking rainwater from puddles and eating wild berries.

N.B. woman found after almost two weeks missing

Airports begin screening for temperatures

Airports begin screening for temperatures
Four major Canadian airports will begin taking passengers' temperatures starting today as part of the effort to curb the spread of COVID-19.

Airports begin screening for temperatures

Few regrets for Toronto's 1st Black police chief

Few regrets for Toronto's 1st Black police chief
Ask the outgoing head of the country's largest municipal police force about defunding or cuts to its $1-billion budget, and the response reflects typical disdain for what he views as sloganeering in response to complex problems.

Few regrets for Toronto's 1st Black police chief

Judge in Quebec hijab case to offer apology

Judge in Quebec hijab case to offer apology
A Quebec judge who refused to allow a Muslim woman to appear in court wearing a hijab in 2015 will apologize.

Judge in Quebec hijab case to offer apology

Shrubsall sentenced for fleeing to Canada

Shrubsall sentenced for fleeing to Canada
A New York state judge has sentenced a man who committed violent sexual crimes in Nova Scotia to between two and six years of additional jail time for absconding from justice and fleeing to Canada in 1996.

Shrubsall sentenced for fleeing to Canada

Man facing terrorism charges gets bail

Man facing terrorism charges gets bail
A judge has granted bail to an Alberta man facing four terrorism charges.

Man facing terrorism charges gets bail

PrevNext