Close X
Sunday, November 17, 2024
ADVT 
National

Supreme Court To Rule On Use Of Sexual History In Edmonton Assault Trial

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 28 Jun, 2019 11:59 PM

    OTTAWA — A Supreme Court decision due this morning could clarify the law on how much of the history between a complainant and a person accused in a sexual-assault case can be brought into court.

     

    Patrick John Goldfinch was charged in 2014 with assaulting a woman he once lived with.


    He was acquitted at his trial in Edmonton after a jury heard evidence that he and the alleged victim still had a "friends-with-benefits" relationship.


    A complainant's sexual history can't ordinarily be used as evidence unless it's directly relevant to the charge.


    But in this case, the judge allowed it, worried that jurors would have thought the relationship was platonic if they didn't know about Goldfinch's history with the woman.


    Alberta's Court of Appeal said last year that could have been avoided without specifically talking about their sexual history, and now the Supreme Court is to make a final decision.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Quebec Newborn Found In Shoebox In Stable Condition; Mother Could Face Charge

    Quebec Newborn Found In Shoebox In Stable Condition; Mother Could Face Charge
    Laval police received a 911 call around noon Wednesday from a woman who said someone left the baby girl in a box on her balcony.

    Quebec Newborn Found In Shoebox In Stable Condition; Mother Could Face Charge

    Aunt Desperate To Know What Happened To Missing Calgary Toddler And Her Mother

    Aliyah Sanderson, 22-months old, and her mother, Jasmine Lovett, have not been seen since April 16.

    Aunt Desperate To Know What Happened To Missing Calgary Toddler And Her Mother

    Can't Ignore Frustrated Patient's 'Heartbreaking' Video, Doctors Group Says

    Dr. Gigi Osler called the situation described by 33-year-old Inez Rudderham "heartbreaking."

    Can't Ignore Frustrated Patient's 'Heartbreaking' Video, Doctors Group Says

    Appeal Court Raps Feds For Inaction On Inmate Segregation; Grants Brief Stay

    Appeal Court Raps Feds For Inaction On Inmate Segregation; Grants Brief Stay
    A clearly unhappy Ontario Court of Appeal has granted the federal government another reprieve from an earlier ruling that found parts of its solitary-confinement regime to be unconstitutional.

    Appeal Court Raps Feds For Inaction On Inmate Segregation; Grants Brief Stay

    Ex-Afghanistan Hostage Boyle To Fight Wife's Appeal Over Assault-Trial Evidence

    Boyle, 35, has pleaded not-guilty in Ontario court to offences against Coleman, 33, including assault, sexual assault and unlawful confinement.

    Ex-Afghanistan Hostage Boyle To Fight Wife's Appeal Over Assault-Trial Evidence

    Canadian Privacy Watchdog Takes Facebook To Court Over Privacy Failures

    Canadian Privacy Watchdog Takes Facebook To Court Over Privacy Failures
    Canada's privacy czar is taking Facebook to court after finding the social-media giant's lax practices allowed personal information to be used for political purposes.

    Canadian Privacy Watchdog Takes Facebook To Court Over Privacy Failures