Close X
Sunday, December 1, 2024
ADVT 
National

Supreme Court to rule on carbon tax next week

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 19 Mar, 2021 09:00 PM
  • Supreme Court to rule on carbon tax next week

The Supreme Court of Canada says it will issue its ruling on the fate of the national carbon tax next week.

The court decision expected Thursday will determine the fate of the central pillar of the Liberal climate change plan.

In 2019 Ottawa imposed a price on pollution on provinces without one of their own.

Saskatchewan, Ontario and Alberta all went to court to argue the Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act was unconstitutional because Ottawa was stepping into provincial jurisdiction.

In 2019, appeals courts in Saskatchewan and Ontario determined the policy was constitutional, while in February 2020 the Alberta Court of Appeal said it was not.

The cases were all appealed to the Supreme Court, which heard the cases together in two days of hearings last September.

Environment Minister Jonathan Wilkinson said late last year he was confident the court ruling would go the government's way.

"We remain very confident in our legal position. We have been for some time," he said in an interview with The Canadian Press in December.

"As you know, we've won two out of three of the cases at the provincial level and we remain confident that we will win in the Supreme Court."

Josh Ginsberg, a lawyer with Ecojustice, says the ruling will decide if Canada can have a national approach to combating climate change or if it must be left up to each province.

"This is a very big deal," said Ginsberg.

"It'll be much more difficult for Canada to meet its climate targets, if we can't ensure that there's national carbon pricing," he said.

Currently the national carbon price on input fuels applies in Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba and Ontario. All other provinces have a carbon-pricing system Ottawa deems to be the equivalent or better of the federal version.

There is a separate program for big industrial emitters, who pay the price on a portion of their emissions rather than on the fuels they purchase.

The national carbon price is now $30 for every tonne of greenhouse gases produced when a particular fuel is burned. It adds about seven cents to the cost of a litre of gasoline.

Ottawa returns the revenues from the carbon price mainly through tax rebates to families in the provinces where the national price is paid.

 

MORE National ARTICLES

Plea set for accused man in Rideau Hall incident

Plea set for accused man in Rideau Hall incident
Hurren allegedly drove a truck onto the grounds of the official residence July 2 and set out on foot toward the house where the prime minister lives.

Plea set for accused man in Rideau Hall incident

Trudeau urges Canadians to cancel travel plans

Trudeau urges Canadians to cancel travel plans
Canada has had a ban on non-essential travel into the country by anyone who isn't a citizen or permanent resident since last March but it can't as easily bar the flow of Canadians in and out of the country.

Trudeau urges Canadians to cancel travel plans

Allegedly flying to Yukon 'despicable': minister

Allegedly flying to Yukon 'despicable': minister
The allegations against them have not been proven in court and the tickets indicate the couple can challenge them.

Allegedly flying to Yukon 'despicable': minister

Bill Morneau drops out of OECD campaign

Bill Morneau drops out of OECD campaign
In a statement on Twitter today, Morneau says he did not have enough support from member countries to make it to the third round of the campaign.

Bill Morneau drops out of OECD campaign

Trudeau sanguine on Biden's Buy American threats

Trudeau sanguine on Biden's Buy American threats
Trudeau says it's worth remembering that Canada survived former president Donald Trump’s persistent attacks on NAFTA and Canadian steel and aluminum exporters.

Trudeau sanguine on Biden's Buy American threats

Europe threatens export controls on vaccines

Europe threatens export controls on vaccines
Anger in Europe at both Pfizer and AstraZeneca led the European Commission Tuesday to threaten export controls.

Europe threatens export controls on vaccines