Close X
Sunday, December 1, 2024
ADVT 
National

Supreme Court To Hear If Sex-Offender Registries Unfair To Mentally Ill

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 26 Sep, 2019 07:30 PM
  • Supreme Court To Hear If Sex-Offender Registries Unfair To Mentally Ill

TORONTO - The Supreme Court of Canada will have final say on the validity of laws requiring sex offenders to register when an accused is granted an absolute discharge after being found not criminally responsible.

 

In a decision on Thursday, the high court said it would hear the government's appeal of a ruling that declared the provisions unconstitutional for discriminating against the mentally ill.

 

The case involves a man charged with sexually assaulting his wife while in a manic state. He was found not criminally responsible in June 2002. The Ontario Review Board granted him an absolute discharge a year later and he has since led a "law-abiding and productive life," according to court records.

 

Nevertheless, under Christopher's Law enacted in Ontario in 2001, the man — identified only as G — was required to register as a sex offender for life. Among other things, he has to provide personal information to police, and report once a year to them.

 

Similar federal legislation, enacted in 2004, imposes the same requirements but allows termination of the obligation 20 years after the not criminally responsible finding.

 

G, 57, challenged the constitutionality of the registries as they apply to those found not criminally responsible and who have received an absolute discharge from a review board. Both Ottawa and Ontario argued the laws are in line with the charter, or are otherwise justified in a democratic society.

 

In November 2017, Superior Court Justice Thomas Lederer rejected G's challenge but the Ontario Court of Appeal sided with him in April.

 

The appellate court noted that people found guilty of sexual offences — but who then receive a discharge — are deemed by the Criminal Code not to have been convicted. As a result, they don't have to register as sex offenders.

 

However, those found not criminally responsible on mental health grounds are deemed to be not guilty and therefore can't use the same provisions. The Appeal Court said this amounts to discrimination against the mentally ill.

 

"The absence of any 'exit ramp' from the sex offender registries — apart from a termination order after 20 years in the case of (the federal registry) — reflects an assumption that persons who committed criminal acts while (mentally ill) do not change, but rather pose the same ongoing and indeterminate risk they posed at the time of the offence," the Appeal Court said. "This assumption feeds into the stereotypical notion that persons found (not criminally responsible) are inherently and indefinitely dangerous."

 

The court ordered G's information deleted immediately from the registries but gave governments 12 months to fix the offending legislation out of public safety concerns.

 

It's not clear when the Supreme Court will hear the case.

MORE National ARTICLES

Biggest Year Yet for Burnaby RCMP’s Soccer Camp

Now in its third year, Burnaby RCMP’s Soccer Camp played host to over 60 kids in late August at two venues in the City.    

Biggest Year Yet for Burnaby RCMP’s Soccer Camp

New Westminster Police Department Partners With ICBC For September Distracted Driving Campaign

New Westminster Police Department Partners With ICBC For September Distracted Driving Campaign
The New Westminster Police Department is teaming up with ICBC to tackle distracted driving, which is responsible for approximately one-quarter of all fatal crashes in the province.

New Westminster Police Department Partners With ICBC For September Distracted Driving Campaign

Surrey RCMP And Surrey Bylaws Target Underage Drinking In Strawberry Hills

Surrey RCMP And Surrey Bylaws Target Underage Drinking In Strawberry Hills
Surrey RCMP and Surrey Bylaw Enforcement have joined together to conduct targeted enforcement focused on underage drinking in chauffeured vehicles.    

Surrey RCMP And Surrey Bylaws Target Underage Drinking In Strawberry Hills

Naked B.C. Man Who Jumped In Toronto Shark Tank Pleads Guilty To Mischief

TORONTO - A British Columbia man accused of stripping naked and jumping into a shark tank at a Toronto aquarium has pleaded guilty to mischief.    

Naked B.C. Man Who Jumped In Toronto Shark Tank Pleads Guilty To Mischief

Health Organizations Call For End To Promotion Of Vaping Products

OTTAWA - Eight health organizations are calling for urgent action from the federal government to treat vaping like smoking.    

Health Organizations Call For End To Promotion Of Vaping Products

Unionized Workers Launch Walkout At Three Upscale Vancouver Hotels

Unionized Workers Launch Walkout At Three Upscale Vancouver Hotels
VANCOUVER - Unionized workers at three high-end Vancouver hotels say they have begun strike action to back demands for safe and stable work.

Unionized Workers Launch Walkout At Three Upscale Vancouver Hotels