Thursday, March 28, 2024
ADVT 
National

Supreme Court To Hear B.C. Case Attempting To Halt Trans Mountain Expansion

The Canadian Press, 15 Jan, 2020 10:39 PM

    OTTAWA - The B.C. government will ask Canada's high court Thursday to give it authority over what can flow through the expanded Trans Mountain pipeline from Alberta.

     

    The case is a make-it-or-break-it affair for the multibillion-dollar project: if B.C. is allowed to prevent heavy oil from flowing through the pipeline, it would crush the expansion's entire reason for being. It is also a significant case for the federal government, which bought the pipeline in 2018 when B.C.'s court challenge convinced Kinder Morgan Canada the political opposition created too much risk that the project would never be completed.

     

    The federal government will argue that letting B.C. regulate what can flow through the pipeline would give the province a veto over interprovincial projects it doesn't like, counter to the constitutional authority given to Ottawa over any transportation project that crosses provincial boundaries.

     

    B.C.'s NDP government, which was elected in 2017 in part on a promise to oppose the expansion, acknowledges the Constitution but says B.C. has authority to protect its environment. There, the province argues it should be able to restrict heavy oil flows in the pipeline because it is B.C. that will bear the environmental brunt of any spill if the pipeline ruptures.

     

    B.C. specifically wants to be able to require companies to get permits before shipping heavy oil through pipelines in B.C. A permit could be withheld if a company can't show efforts to prevent a spill and policies to clean up and compensate if one does occur.

     

    In a factum filed with the Supreme Court of Canada, the B.C. attorney general says "the heart of the Constitutional questions before this court" is whether B.C.'s authority to protect its own environment can include interfering in a federal project.

     

    Last May, the B.C. Court of Appeal said it cannot.

     

    B.C. is appealing that decision to the Supreme Court of Canada and the hearing is set for Thursday morning in Ottawa. Four provinces, the cities of Burnaby and Vancouver, several Indigenous communities, the environmental law charity Ecojustice, and more than half a dozen oil companies and advocacy groups have been granted intervener status in the case.

     

    In their written arguments filed with the Supreme Court, Ottawa's lawyers say the B.C. Court of Appeal was correct when it said B.C.'s proposed permitting process is not a general environment law, but rather one specifically intended to restrict or even bar heavy oil from flowing through the Trans Mountain expansion.

     

    The Trans Mountain expansion involves building a new pipeline roughly parallel to the existing Trans Mountain Pipeline that runs between Edmonton and a marine terminal in Burnaby, B.C. The existing pipeline would continue to carry mostly refined products like gasoline, and light crude oil. The expansion, with almost twice the capacity, would ship diluted bitumen, a heavy crude oil produced in Alberta's oilsands, to be loaded onto tankers for export.

     

    If B.C. can prevent heavy oil from flowing through the new pipeline, there is no reason to build it.

     

    The expansion has been in the works for almost a decade and has become a political lightning rod for Canadians advocating for the phasing-out of fossil-fuel production in Canada to curb climate change and those fighting to support an industry that is a critical part of Canada's economy. First proposed in 2012 during the former Conservative government's tenure, the pipeline was approved by the federal Liberals in 2016 a year after they came to power.

     

    Almost two years later, the Federal Court of Appeal overturned that approval, saying Ottawa had failed in its duty to consult affected Indigenous communities and hadn't fully considered the impact on marine life from having more oil tankers in B.C. waters, carrying heavy crude from the pipeline's terminal.

     

    Ottawa undertook another round of Indigenous consultation and reconsidered the marine impacts, before approving the project a second time in June.

     

    In 2018, after B.C. announced its proposed plan to restrict heavy oil from flowing in the expanded pipeline, Kinder Morgan Canada halted work on the project and told Ottawa unless it could provide some certainty the expansion could be built it was going to walk away. When Ottawa couldn't convince B.C. to back down, Kinder Morgan sold the pipeline to the federal government for $4.5 billion.

     

    Ottawa intends to sell both the existing pipeline and the expansion to a private sector or Indigenous partner, once the expansion is completed.

     

    Work on the expansion, which was halted after the 2018 Federal Court decision, restarted in August.

     

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Canadian Firefighters Expect To Use Tailored Tactics To Battle Australia Blazes

    Canadian Firefighters Expect To Use Tailored Tactics To Battle Australia Blazes
    HALIFAX - As Canadian firefighters boarded flights Wednesday to battle blazes in Australia, they noted they will likely have to employ some different tactics than they do to fight local fires.    

    Canadian Firefighters Expect To Use Tailored Tactics To Battle Australia Blazes

    Alberta Government Promising To Fix Rules On Aging Energy Wells

    Alberta Government Promising To Fix Rules On Aging Energy Wells
    A group tasked with cleaning up thousands of abandoned energy sites in Alberta says the province's rules for ensuring polluters reclaim their wells before selling them off are inadequate.

    Alberta Government Promising To Fix Rules On Aging Energy Wells

    Pipeline At Centre Of B.C. Conflict Is Creating Jobs For First Nations: Chief

    Pipeline At Centre Of B.C. Conflict Is Creating Jobs For First Nations: Chief
    A pipeline at the centre of a conflict between hereditary chiefs and a natural gas company in northern British Columbia is creating jobs for Indigenous people and lifting communities from poverty, says an elected chief of a band that supports the project.    

    Pipeline At Centre Of B.C. Conflict Is Creating Jobs For First Nations: Chief

    Anonymous Internet Posters Successfully Sued For Defamatory Comments

    Anonymous Internet Posters Successfully Sued For Defamatory Comments
    The judgment in Ontario Superior Court of Justice comes despite the difficulties in suing people who post inflammatory comments anonymously, and who then fail to respond to the resulting legal proceedings against them.

    Anonymous Internet Posters Successfully Sued For Defamatory Comments

    Argument Over Iran Nuclear Deal Complicates Tehran Crash Probe

    LONDON - Iran's president levelled threats Wednesday against Europe in response to European countries' new crackdown on his country's violations of their nuclear deal — a move Canada is also supporting.    

    Argument Over Iran Nuclear Deal Complicates Tehran Crash Probe

    Man Convicted Of Sexually Abusing 18 Boys Over Three Decades Released On Parole

    Man Convicted Of Sexually Abusing 18 Boys Over Three Decades Released On Parole
    The man at the heart of the Maple Leaf Gardens sexual abuse scandal has been released on day parole after officials found he presents a low risk of reoffending.    

    Man Convicted Of Sexually Abusing 18 Boys Over Three Decades Released On Parole

    PrevNext