Close X
Friday, January 10, 2025
ADVT 
National

Supreme Court Says Circumstantial Evidence Can Be Enough For Child Porn Cases

Darpan News Desk IANS, 29 Jul, 2016 01:26 PM
    OTTAWA — The Supreme Court of Canada says circumstantial evidence can be enough to convict someone of possessing child pornography.
     
    In a decision Friday, the high court ruled unanimously that the Crown does not have to disprove any other possible explanation for how child pornography ends up on a computer owned by an accused.
     
    "'Other plausible theories' or 'other reasonable possibilities' must be based on logic and experience applied to the evidence or the absence of evidence, not on speculation," Supreme Court Justice Thomas Cromwell wrote in the 32-page decision.
     
    "Of course, the line between a 'plausible theory' and 'speculation' is not always easy to draw. But the basic question is whether the circumstantial evidence, viewed logically and in light of human experience, is reasonably capable of supporting an inference other than that the accused is guilty."
     
    The decision concerned the case of Oswald Villaroman, who took his laptop to a Calgary computer shop for repairs in December 2009, and a service technician contacted the police after discovering child pornography downloaded through a file-sharing program.
     
    A judge convicted Villaroman of child pornography possession following a prosecution based on circumstantial evidence such as the fact that he owned the computer, which had only one user account labelled with his name.
     
    The Alberta Court of Appeal overturned the conviction last year, ruling the trial judge had erred excluding other possibilities as to how the pornography ended up on his computer.
     
    The Supreme Court disagreed with the appeal judgment Friday, setting aside the acquittal.
     
     
    The high court also handed a separate Charter of Rights issue related to the search and seizure of the laptop back to the Alberta Court of Appeal, which means Villaroman will have another chance to argue his case in the appeal court.
     
    In asking the Supreme Court to consider the case, the Crown argued requiring prosecutors to disprove all other possible conclusions concerning the presence of pornography would increase the burden of proof to an impossible degree.
     
    The Crown said this could have a devastating impact on the ability to prosecute child pornography cases and others that rely on circumstantial evidence.
     
    The lawyers representing Villaroman, however, said the trial judge had simply erred in finding the defendant guilty beyond reasonable doubt in a case where the prosecution had brought virtually no evidence of possession.
     
    The Supreme Court affirmed Friday that a judge or jury should consider other plausible theories and reasonable possibilities that point to innocence, and this might sometimes require the Crown to show why they would not apply.
     
    But the high court agreed with the trial judge that this need not extend into the realm of make-believe.
     
    "The Court of Appeal, my respectful view, erred by focusing on hypothetical alternative theories and, at times, engaging in speculation rather than on the question of whether the inferences drawn by the trial judge, having regard to the standard of proof, were reasonably open to him," Cromwell wrote.
     
    The Supreme Court acknowledged there were "gaps" in the evidence the Crown presented at trial, but the appeal court went too far in analyzing those gaps, effectively retrying the case.
     
    "In my view, while not every trier of fact would inevitably have reached the same conclusion as did the trial judge, that conclusion was a reasonable one," Cromwell wrote.
     
    The Supreme Court did not set any new rules for instructing juries on how to deal with circumstantial evidence, but did suggest that in cases that rely only, or largely, on circumstantial evidence, it might be "helpful" for a judge to caution the jury about its limits.
     
    The example Cromwell gave was looking out the window, seeing the road is wet and assuming it had been raining.
     
    A closer look, however, might reveal that the sidewalks are dry, or that a sound that could be coming from a street-cleaning truck can be heard in the distance.
     
    "The inferences that may be drawn from this observation must be considered in light of all of the evidence and the absence of evidence, assessed logically, and in light of human experience and common sense."

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Former Minister Hunter Tootoo Finishes Treatment For Alcohol Addiction

    Former Minister Hunter Tootoo Finishes Treatment For Alcohol Addiction
    OTTAWA — Former cabinet minister and Liberal MP Hunter Tootoo says he has completed his treatment for alcohol addiction.

    Former Minister Hunter Tootoo Finishes Treatment For Alcohol Addiction

    Triathlete Eyes Guinness Record During Swim Of B.C.'s Okanagan Lake

    Triathlete Eyes Guinness Record During Swim Of B.C.'s Okanagan Lake
    Michigan-based triathlete Adam Ellenstein intends to swim 105-kilometres from Okanagan Landing to Penticton.

    Triathlete Eyes Guinness Record During Swim Of B.C.'s Okanagan Lake

    3-Yr-Old Girl Found Roaming Toronto In The Middle Of The Night Reunited With Parents

    3-Yr-Old Girl Found Roaming Toronto In The Middle Of The Night Reunited With Parents
    A toddler who walked out of her family's Toronto home in the middle of the night has been reunited with her parents after spending a few hours watching cartoons at a police station.

    3-Yr-Old Girl Found Roaming Toronto In The Middle Of The Night Reunited With Parents

    Music Industry Gets $66 Million In Settlement With Canadian Bittorrent Search SiteisoHunt

    Music Industry Gets $66 Million In Settlement With Canadian Bittorrent Search SiteisoHunt
    Legal Fight Over isoHunt And Downloading Of Music Files Ends In Settlement  

    Music Industry Gets $66 Million In Settlement With Canadian Bittorrent Search SiteisoHunt

    Parks Canada Scales Back Recovery Operation For Missing Calgary Boy

    Parks Canada Scales Back Recovery Operation For Missing Calgary Boy
    Two boys fell into the river near the Takkakaw Falls Friday evening while visiting Yoho National Park with their family.

    Parks Canada Scales Back Recovery Operation For Missing Calgary Boy

    Richmond Police Seeking Public's Assistance In Locating Owner Of Capsized Boat

    Richmond Police Seeking Public's Assistance In Locating Owner Of Capsized Boat
    The 10-foot capsized boat was located at Gravesend Reach (5400 block of Dyke Road), in Richmond.

    Richmond Police Seeking Public's Assistance In Locating Owner Of Capsized Boat