Close X
Monday, September 30, 2024
ADVT 
National

Supreme Court Rules Quebec Infringed On School's Religious Freedom

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 19 Mar, 2015 02:35 PM

    OTTAWA — A divided Supreme Court of Canada disagreed over the subtleties, but in the end upheld the religious freedom of a historic Montreal Jesuit school to teach Catholicism in the way it chooses.

    The high court ruled Thursday that Quebec infringed on the religious freedom of Jesuit-run Loyola High School in Montreal by refusing it an exception from teaching the province's ethics and religious culture program.

    But the high court was divided by a 4-3 margin on how to resolve the clash between religious freedom and the need to follow the secular law of the province.

    A vocal minority, led by Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin, said they didn't think the majority struck the right balance between protecting freedom of religion and the need to follow the law.

    In the narrowest legal sense, the ruling grants the school's appeal so it can use its own course and teach the province's Ethics and Religious Culture or ERC program from a Catholic perspective.

    The school can now reapply to Quebec's education ministry for an exemption to teach the ERC course and that decision must be guided by Thursday's ruling.

    Paul Donovan, Loyola's principal, said the school encourages debate and discussion in its classrooms, and has educated many prominent people, politicians and clergy, since its founding in 1848.

    "We want them to know what it is they're accepting or rejecting," he said. "To say, I don't want to be a Catholic, that's up to each individual. But you got to know what you're saying no to."

    John Zucchi, the Loyola parent who was the main appellant in the case, said he didn't want to put his son "in a Catholic ghetto" by sending him to the school.

    Loyola, he said, "was completely engaged with the world," and has educated politicians and other prominent people.

    The ruling comes amid the backdrop of political, cultural and religious acrimony that has arisen in Ottawa around the issues raised by Prime Minister Stephen Harper's position that women taking the oath of citizenship should not be allowed to wear a face-covering niqab.

    The high court ruled on the issue in 2012 in a similar case in Drummondville, Quebec involving a public school.

    In that case, the Supreme Court ruled that teaching students about world religions did not infringe the rights of Catholic parents who wanted to raise their children in their faith.

    Thursday's case revolves around Quebec's law that requires schools to teach religions from a secular, cultural and morally neutral perspective in private schools.

    Under the law, schools can apply for an exemption that allows an alternative course to be taught as long as the minister of education approves it. Schools are only allowed to teach an alternative course as long as teachers steer clear of injecting their own religious beliefs.

    "To ask a religious school's teachers to discuss other religions and their ethical beliefs as objectively as possible does not seriously harm the values underlying religious freedom," wrote Justice Rosalie Abella for the majority.

    "But preventing a school like Loyola from teaching and discussing Catholicism in any part of the program from its own perspective does little to further those objectives while at the same time seriously interfering with the values underlying religious freedom."

    Loyola's exemption, the court held, "cannot be withheld on the basis that Loyola must teach Catholicism and Catholic ethics from a neutral perspective."

    However the minority opinion, penned by McLachlin and Justice Michael Moldaver, took issue with how all of this would play out in a practical sense in a classroom.

    "Requiring Loyola's teachers to maintain a neutral posture on ethical questions poses serious practical difficulties and represents a significant infringement on how Loyola transmits an understanding of the Catholic faith," they wrote.

    "The net effect would be to render them mute during large portions of the ethics."

    MORE National ARTICLES

    CBSA officers seize 17 kg of suspected heroin at Toronto's Pearson Airport

    CBSA officers seize 17 kg of suspected heroin at Toronto's Pearson Airport
    MISSISSAUGA, Ont. — Canadian border officials say 17 kilograms of suspected heroin was seized at Toronto's Pearson International Airport after a flight came in from Pakistan.

    CBSA officers seize 17 kg of suspected heroin at Toronto's Pearson Airport

    Feds looking to expand no-fly regime, detention provisions in anti-terror fight

    Feds looking to expand no-fly regime, detention provisions in anti-terror fight
    OTTAWA — The Conservative government wants to retool Canada's no-fly list procedures to make it easier to stop a suspected terrorist from boarding an airplane.

    Feds looking to expand no-fly regime, detention provisions in anti-terror fight

    Saskatoon museum learns prized bust once belonged to French emperor

    Saskatoon museum learns prized bust once belonged to French emperor
    SASKATOON — A museum curator in Saskatoon says a bronze bust donated in 1988 once belonged to French emperor Napoleon Bonaparte.

    Saskatoon museum learns prized bust once belonged to French emperor

    Murder charges dropped against man accused in Toronto neighbourhood shooting

    Murder charges dropped against man accused in Toronto neighbourhood shooting
    TORONTO — Two first-degree murder charges have been withdrawn against a man accused in a July 2012 shooting that sparked panic at a community barbecue in Toronto.

    Murder charges dropped against man accused in Toronto neighbourhood shooting

    Finance Minister Oliver says he won't meddle with banks' decisions on rates

    Finance Minister Oliver says he won't meddle with banks' decisions on rates
    OTTAWA — Federal Finance Minister Joe Oliver says he has no intention of pushing Canadian banks to follow the Bank of Canada's lead and drop their rates.

    Finance Minister Oliver says he won't meddle with banks' decisions on rates

    Montreal man charged with terrorism hoax to undergo more psychiatric tests

    Montreal man charged with terrorism hoax to undergo more psychiatric tests
    MONTREAL — A Montreal man facing a terrorism-related charge will undergo an additional six weeks of psychiatric evaluation.

    Montreal man charged with terrorism hoax to undergo more psychiatric tests