Close X
Friday, February 14, 2025
ADVT 
National

Supreme Court Rules Against Speeder In Dangerous-Driving Case

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 27 Mar, 2020 08:09 PM

    OTTAWA - A reasonable person should foresee the risk of driving almost three times the speed limit towards a major city intersection, the Supreme Court of Canada says in upholding a man's conviction.

     

    The 4-1 decision came Friday in the case of Ken Chung, whose silver Audi hit another car in Vancouver in November 2015, killing the driver.

     

    Chung, who was driving at 140-kilometres-an-hour in a 50-kilometre-an-hour zone, was acquitted at trial of dangerous driving causing death.

     

    Over the span of a block, Chung had moved in to the curbside lane, passed at least one car and accelerated quickly before entering the intersection. The trial judge found Chung was neither inattentive nor driving dangerously prior to this one-block span.

     

    The judge ruled Chung's speeding was only momentary and therefore amounted to a lapse of judgment rather than a significant departure from the standard of a reasonably prudent driver.

     

    British Columbia's appeal court overturned the decision and entered a conviction, prompting Chung to take his case to the Supreme Court.

     

    In its decision Friday, the high court said the trial judge's fixation on the momentary nature of the speeding was an error of law.

     

    In writing for the majority, Justice Sheilah Martin said Chung's actions were not comparable to momentary mistakes that might be made by any reasonable driver, such as a mistimed turn on to a highway or the sudden loss of awareness or control.

     

    "A reasonable person would have foreseen the immediate risk of reaching a speed of almost three times the speed limit while accelerating towards a major city intersection," she wrote. "Mr. Chung’s conduct in these circumstances is a marked departure from the norm."

     

    Driving is an inherently risky activity that is made all the more risky "the faster we drive, the harder we accelerate, and the more aggressively we navigate traffic," she said. "Although even careful driving can result in tragic consequences, some conduct is so dangerous that it deserves criminal sanctions."

     

    However, Martin cautioned against adopting "hard and fast rules" on actions.

     

    It is conceivable that in some cases even grossly excessive speed may not be a notable departure from the standard of care, she wrote.

     

    "Only when there has been an active engagement with the full picture of what occurred can the trial judge determine whether the accused's conduct was a marked departure from the conduct of a reasonable and prudent driver."

     

    MORE National ARTICLES

    B.C. Chief Ed John Faces Historic Sex Charges: Prosecution Service

    VANCOUVER - Ed John, a leader of the First Nations Summit and former British Columbia cabinet minister, is accused of four counts of sexual assault dating back to 1974.    

    B.C. Chief Ed John Faces Historic Sex Charges: Prosecution Service

    Today's Babies Won't Know Life Without Climate Change, New Report Warns

    Today's Babies Won't Know Life Without Climate Change, New Report Warns
    The Lancet medical journal's 2019 countdown on health and climate change has dire warnings about the kind of world we might be leaving to future generations.    

    Today's Babies Won't Know Life Without Climate Change, New Report Warns

    Supreme Court Sides With Naturopath In Manslaughter, Negligence Case

    Supreme Court Sides With Naturopath In Manslaughter, Negligence Case
    OTTAWA - A Quebec naturopath is not guilty of manslaughter or criminal negligence in the death of an elderly man, the Supreme Court of Canada has ruled.    

    Supreme Court Sides With Naturopath In Manslaughter, Negligence Case

    Adoption Centre Closes Despite Effort To Save It; B.C. Left With Two Agencies

    Adoption Centre Closes Despite Effort To Save It; B.C. Left With Two Agencies
    VANCOUVER - Patricia Pearson has dealt with the shock and disappointment of her adoption agency announcing its closure while she was still waiting for a child — twice.    

    Adoption Centre Closes Despite Effort To Save It; B.C. Left With Two Agencies

    Suspect Arrested After Documents Stolen From Quebec Immigration Minister's Car

    Suspect Arrested After Documents Stolen From Quebec Immigration Minister's Car
    QUEBEC - A rough stretch for Quebec immigration minister's continues with news that documents he left in his government vehicle were stolen this week.    

    Suspect Arrested After Documents Stolen From Quebec Immigration Minister's Car

    Laval Police Open Criminal Investigation After Patient Dies In Hospital

    LAVAL, Que. - Police in Quebec have opened a criminal investigation after a hospital patient died following an operating room incident.    

    Laval Police Open Criminal Investigation After Patient Dies In Hospital