Close X
Sunday, November 24, 2024
ADVT 
National

Supreme Court Rejects Appeal Of Man Ordered To Swab Genitals For DNA

The Canadian Press, 23 Jun, 2016 11:57 AM
    OTTAWA — The Supreme Court of Canada has dismissed an appeal from an Alberta man who was convicted of sexual assault after police ordered him to swab his own genitals for evidence of the victim's DNA.
     
    Ali Hassan Saeed was arrested and charged in 2011 after a complaint from a 15-year-old.
     
    While he was in custody, police had him swab his penis for DNA and matched it to the victim.
     
    The trial judge ruled the request an illegal search, but said the results were admissible because the police did not act in bad faith and society has a high interest in seeing justice in cases of sexual assault.
     
    Saeed was convicted of sexual assault causing bodily harm and unlawful touching for a sexual purpose and the Alberta Court of Appeal upheld the ruling.
     
    The Supreme Court in its judgment, said the evidence was properly admitted, leaving the verdict intact.
     
    Writing for the majority, Justice Michael Moldaver said the power of search upon arrest has a long pedigree and is an invaluable investigative tool.
     
    He said the swab did constitute a significant intrusion against the privacy rights of the accused, but the police acted properly.
     
    "I conclude that the police had reasonable grounds to conduct the swab and that in carrying it out, they took reasonable steps to respect Mr. Saeed’s privacy," he wrote.
     
    Saeed’s charter rights were not breached, he concluded.
     
    Justice Andromache Karakatsanis said she believed Saeed's rights were breached, but that the evidence was admissible, nonetheless.
     
    "On balance, I conclude that the trial judge was justified in concluding that the admission of the evidence would not bring the administration of justice into disrepute," she wrote. 
     
    Justice Rosalie Abella, writing in dissent, said she would have excluded the evidence and ordered a new trial.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    PM Justin Trudeau Announces $460 Million New Infrastructure Agreement With B.C.

    PM Justin Trudeau Announces $460 Million New Infrastructure Agreement With B.C.
    The Government of Canada remains committed to making significant investments in infrastructure that will improve our public transit systems, strengthen Canadian communities, and help grow the economy.

    PM Justin Trudeau Announces $460 Million New Infrastructure Agreement With B.C.

    Veterans Lawsuit Heading Back To Court After Settlement Deadline Passes

    VANCOUVER — A missed procedural deadline has set off a domino effect in a long-running court case about compensation for severely disabled veterans.

    Veterans Lawsuit Heading Back To Court After Settlement Deadline Passes

    2 Men Dead, One Rescued After Fishing Boat Capsizes Off Northern New Brunswick

    The RCMP says the incident occurred early Thursday morning off the Miller Brook wharf near Salmon Beach, about 11 kilometres from downtown Bathurst.

    2 Men Dead, One Rescued After Fishing Boat Capsizes Off Northern New Brunswick

    Senate Passes Assisted Dying Bill With Amendment To Delete Near-death Proviso

    Senate Passes Assisted Dying Bill With Amendment To Delete Near-death Proviso
    The bill, as amended over the past two weeks of lengthy debate in the upper house, passed late Wednesday by a vote of 64-12 with one abstention.

    Senate Passes Assisted Dying Bill With Amendment To Delete Near-death Proviso

    Panel To Start Reviewing Domestic Violence Deaths In Saskatchewan

    REGINA — A panel reviewing domestic violence deaths in Saskatchewan is to begin looking at cases next month.

    Panel To Start Reviewing Domestic Violence Deaths In Saskatchewan

    Can Inmates Ask To Die? Clarity Urged Around Doctor-Assisted Death In Prison

    Can Inmates Ask To Die? Clarity Urged Around Doctor-Assisted Death In Prison
    CALGARY — A Belgian man three decades into a life sentence for rape and murder wanted doctors to help him die — and he nearly got his wish.

    Can Inmates Ask To Die? Clarity Urged Around Doctor-Assisted Death In Prison