Sunday, February 23, 2020
ADVT 
National

Supreme Court Refuses To Hear Human Smuggling Case, Affirming Acquittals

The Canadian Press, 23 Jan, 2020
  • Supreme Court Refuses To Hear Human Smuggling Case, Affirming Acquittals

OTTAWA - The Supreme Court of Canada has effectively upheld the acquittal of three people who were charged with human smuggling after a rickety ship arrived off the coast of British Columbia carrying hundreds of Tamil migrants.

 

In a decision Thursday, the high court turned down the Crown's application for an appeal hearing in the case.

 

In August 2010, the Canadian navy intercepted the cargo ship MV Sun Sea carrying 492 people from strife-torn Sri Lanka and escorted it to CFB Esquimalt, near Victoria.

 

Lesly Emmanuel, Nadarajah Mahendran and Thampeernayagam Rajaratnam were charged with violating the Immigrant and Refugee Protection Act by organizing, inducing, aiding or abetting the illegal entry of people into Canada.

 

The Crown alleged the men were part of a human-smuggling operation linked to organized crime.

 

Emmanuel, who captained the ship, testified that he boarded as a passenger, then reluctantly took the helm to avert disaster for the vessel.

 

The Crown accused Canadian citizens Mahendran and Rajaratnam, who were not aboard the ship, of helping organize the voyage.

 

Both argued the evidence that led to their identification was seriously flawed.

 

The three men were acquitted in early 2017 by a jury in B.C. Supreme Court.

 

Last June, the B.C. Court of Appeal upheld the verdicts, saying the Crown had not demonstrated a reasonable possibility that any errors committed by the trial judge affected the outcome.

 

As usual, the Supreme Court gave no reasons for refusing to hear the case.

 

MORE National ARTICLES

Quebec Professors Appeal To Supreme Court Ruling On Succession To British Throne

Quebec Professors Appeal To Supreme Court Ruling On Succession To British Throne

MONTREAL - While Prince Harry is shaking up the British monarchy, Canada's Supreme Court is being asked to throw out a law that modified the rules governing succession to the throne.

Quebec Professors Appeal To Supreme Court Ruling On Succession To British Throne

Canadian Experts Returning Home After Probing Tehran Plane Crash, TSB Says

Canadian Experts Returning Home After Probing Tehran Plane Crash, TSB Says

Iran has admitted firing surface-to-air missiles at the airliner as it left Tehran's international airport Jan. 8, saying it was a mistake.

 

 

Canadian Experts Returning Home After Probing Tehran Plane Crash, TSB Says

Risk To Canadians Of Chinese Coronavirus Low, Health Minister Says

Risk To Canadians Of Chinese Coronavirus Low, Health Minister Says

OTTAWA - Federal Health Minister Patty Hajdu says several people in Canada are under observation for signs they may have contracted a coronavirus from China, but that the risk to Canadians remains low.

Risk To Canadians Of Chinese Coronavirus Low, Health Minister Says

Is Climate Action A $26-trillion Opportunity? 'A Little Baloney' In Minister's Claim

Is Climate Action A $26-trillion Opportunity? 'A Little Baloney' In Minister's Claim

This is not simply an environmental issue. It is an economic issue. The estimates going forward in terms of the size of the prize for countries that are in this game early

Is Climate Action A $26-trillion Opportunity? 'A Little Baloney' In Minister's Claim

Professional Lego Builder 'Hasn't Worn A Tie For Years' After Giving Up It Job

Professional Lego Builder 'Hasn't Worn A Tie For Years' After Giving Up It Job

VANCOUVER - Many years ago when Ryan McNaught was an IT professional, he got an email from his manager who wanted to have a meeting about the number of meetings they were having.

 

 

Professional Lego Builder 'Hasn't Worn A Tie For Years' After Giving Up It Job

'The Court Is Being Embarrassed': Meng Lawyers Say Crown Changed Argument

'The Court Is Being Embarrassed': Meng Lawyers Say Crown Changed Argument

VANCOUVER - A lawyer for Huawei executive Meng Wanzhou says the Crown has changed its arguments, telling a judge who issued an arrest warrant one thing and another to the justice who will rule on the extradition.

 

 

'The Court Is Being Embarrassed': Meng Lawyers Say Crown Changed Argument

PrevNext