Close X
Thursday, November 28, 2024
ADVT 
National

Supreme Court Of Canada Upholds Constitutionality Of Military Justice System

Darpan News Desk IANS, 19 Nov, 2015 10:35 AM
    OTTAWA — The Supreme Court of Canada has upheld the constitutionality of the military justice system.
     
    The court on Thursday dismissed four appeals which argued sections of the National Defence Act were broader than necessary and therefore violated the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
     
    The appeals related to offences committed by members of the Forces who were subject to the Code of Service Discipline under the defence act.
     
    The four members, accused of offences punishable under the Criminal Code and the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act, raised the issue of whether the provisions infringed on Section 7 of the charter because they create offences not directly related to military discipline.
     
    The section stipulates that everyone "has the right to life, liberty and security of the person and the right not to be deprived thereof except in accordance with the principles of fundamental justice."
     
    The court said Parliament's objective in establishing the military justice system was to provide processes that assure the maintenance of discipline, efficiency and morale in the military.
     
    "The appellants' contention fails because these provisions are not overbroad," the court found. "A law is overbroad when there is no rational connection between the purpose of the law and some of its effects."
     
    In the ruling, the justices said criminal or fraudulent conduct — even when committed in circumstances that are not directly related to military duties —may have an impact on the standards.
     
    "For instance, the fact that a member of the military has committed an assault in a civil context ... may call into question that individual's capacity to show discipline in a military environment and to respect military authorities," the court said.
     
    "The fact that the offence has occurred outside a military context does not make it irrational to conclude that the prosecution of the offence is related to the discipline, efficiency and morale of the military."

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Minnesota Transportation Commissioner Acquires Canadian Consulate General Residence For $1.65M

    Minnesota Transportation Commissioner Acquires Canadian Consulate General Residence For $1.65M
    Charlie Zelle confirmed Wednesday he purchased a five-bedroom, five bathroom Minneapolis lakeshore home that has been the Canadian consulate general official residence.

    Minnesota Transportation Commissioner Acquires Canadian Consulate General Residence For $1.65M

    Canada, Denmark Should Turn Hans Island Into A Condominium: Academics

    Canada, Denmark Should Turn Hans Island Into A Condominium: Academics
    Arctic experts from Canada and Denmark are proposing a novel solution to who controls an ice-bound speck of an island midway between the two countries.

    Canada, Denmark Should Turn Hans Island Into A Condominium: Academics

    Queen Elizabeth Grants Audience To Prime Minister Justin Trudeau

    Queen Elizabeth Grants Audience To Prime Minister Justin Trudeau
    The prime minister says he's looking forward to meeting and speaking with the Queen on his way to Malta near the end of the month.

    Queen Elizabeth Grants Audience To Prime Minister Justin Trudeau

    More Of Canada's Recent University Grads Overqualified For Their Jobs: Study

    More Of Canada's Recent University Grads Overqualified For Their Jobs: Study
    OTTAWA — A new report says a growing proportion of recent university graduates are overqualified for their jobs.

    More Of Canada's Recent University Grads Overqualified For Their Jobs: Study

    Bad Move For Canada? TPP's Rules On Intellectual Property Pulled Into Spotlight

    Bad Move For Canada? TPP's Rules On Intellectual Property Pulled Into Spotlight
    Concerns voiced by Jim Balsillie over the massive Trans-Pacific Partnership treaty have intensified scrutiny of the pact's intellectual-property provisions — and whether they represent a bad deal for Canada.

    Bad Move For Canada? TPP's Rules On Intellectual Property Pulled Into Spotlight

    Rape Kits Soon Available In Sea-To-Sky Region Of British Columbia

    Rape Kits Soon Available In Sea-To-Sky Region Of British Columbia
    VANCOUVER — A public health nurse will soon be available to administer rape kits in Squamish, B.C., after a fight by advocates to remove barriers to justice for sexual assault victims in the region.

    Rape Kits Soon Available In Sea-To-Sky Region Of British Columbia