Close X
Tuesday, November 26, 2024
ADVT 
National

Supreme Court Of Canada To Hear Federal Appeal In Via Rail Terror Case

The Canadian Press, 20 Feb, 2020 07:41 PM

    OTTAWA - The Supreme Court of Canada will review a lower-court decision to grant a new trial to two men accused of plotting to crash a Via Rail train.

     

    Raed Jaser and Chiheb Esseghaier were found guilty in 2015 of terror-related charges arising mainly from an alleged al-Qaida-inspired plot to derail a passenger train travelling between the United States and Canada.

     

    Both men appealed their convictions. Counsel for Jaser and a court-appointed lawyer for Esseghaier argued the jury at the trial was improperly constituted.

     

    In August last year, the Ontario Court of Appeal ordered a fresh trial for the men on grounds the jury was indeed chosen incorrectly.

     

    Following the decision, the Public Prosecution Service of Canada said it would proceed with a new trial. However, federal lawyers also exercised a right to seek the Supreme Court's permission to challenge the appeal-court decision.

     

    As usual, the high court gave no reason Thursday for agreeing to hear the case.

     

    In a submission to the Supreme Court seeking a hearing, federal lawyers noted Jaser and Esseghaier were convicted of the most serious terrorism offences in Canadian law after nearly nine months of pre-trial motions and a three-month jury trial.

     

    "Overturning these convictions on the basis of a technical error that had no appreciable effect on the conduct of the trial is a triumph of form over substance," the submission said.

     

    "Where, as here, there is no actual demonstrable prejudice to the fairness of the trial, the verdict properly reached by the trier of fact after a long and arduous trial should not so easily be set aside."

     

    Both Esseghaier and Jaser said the high court should dismiss the federal application for a hearing.

     

    "The Crown has failed to identify any error of law in the decision of the Court of Appeal, much less one that raises an issue of national importance," said Esseghaier's submission.

     

    He took issue with the suggestion the serious nature of the alleged offences should prompt the Supreme Court to grant leave to appeal.

     

    "The Crown has not advanced any argument as to why only serious cases involving overturned convictions, as opposed to convictions that are upheld on appeal, are sufficient to satisfy its new proposed test for leave," Esseghaier's brief said.

     

    "Profoundly serious cases are, sadly, not an uncommon occurrence in the Canadian criminal justice system."

     

    In his submission to the court, Jaser also rejected the notion that the gravity of the alleged offences would warrant a high-court hearing.

     

    "The seriousness of the allegations cannot transform an unimportant legal issue into an important one."

     

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Kelowna RCMP Investigating Incident Between Woman, Youth

    Kelowna RCMP Investigating Incident Between Woman, Youth
    Eyewitnesses To An Alleged Attack Tell Castanet Two People Were Attacked At The Corner Of Lanfranco Road And Gordon Drive Tuesday ...  

    Kelowna RCMP Investigating Incident Between Woman, Youth

    BC's Police Watchdog Investigating After North Vancouver Woman's Death

    BC's Police Watchdog Investigating After North Vancouver Woman's Death
    RCMP has notified the Independent Investigations Office of British Columbia (IIO BC) of an incident in North Vancouver which has resulted in a woman’s death in Squamish.

    BC's Police Watchdog Investigating After North Vancouver Woman's Death

    Canada Line Still Winning Ridership Gold: TransLink Celebrates The 10-Year Anniversary Of The Vancouver Winter Olympics

     New figures show that after 10 years in service, ridership on the Canada Line is still breaking records. The Canada Line had more than 50 million annual boardings for the first time in its history last year, representing a 30 per cent increase in ridership since 2010.

    Canada Line Still Winning Ridership Gold: TransLink Celebrates The 10-Year Anniversary Of The Vancouver Winter Olympics

    Masked Male Allegedly Chases Woman At Aldergrove Park In Langley

    Langley RCMP is seeking the assistance of the public with an investigation into a suspicious incident in January.    

    Masked Male Allegedly Chases Woman At Aldergrove Park In Langley

    NDP Criticises Andrew Wilkinson For Characterizing Domestic And Sexual Violence As ‘A Tough Marriage’

    NDP Criticises Andrew Wilkinson For Characterizing Domestic And Sexual Violence As ‘A Tough Marriage’
    The NDP on Wednesday stated that, BC Liberal Leader Andrew Wilkinson referred to individuals fleeing domestic and sexual violence as “people who are in a tough marriage.”

    NDP Criticises Andrew Wilkinson For Characterizing Domestic And Sexual Violence As ‘A Tough Marriage’

    Report Of Man Approaching Children In Oliver Prompts RCMP Investigation

    Report Of Man Approaching Children In Oliver Prompts RCMP Investigation
    Oliver RCMP are investigating a suspicious occurrence where a man stopped his vehicle and asked 3 young children if they would like to see his puppy.    

    Report Of Man Approaching Children In Oliver Prompts RCMP Investigation