Close X
Friday, January 24, 2025
ADVT 
National

Supreme Court Lays Out New Framework For Ensuring Right To Timely Criminal Trial

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 09 Jul, 2016 01:47 PM
    OTTAWA — The Supreme Court of Canada, citing a "culture of complacency" in the justice system, has set out a new framework for determining whether a criminal trial has been unreasonably delayed.
     
    In a potentially groundbreaking 5-4 decision Friday, the high court said the old means of determining whether a person's constitutional right to a timely trial had been infringed was too complex and unpredictable.
     
    The Charter of Rights and Freedoms says someone charged with an offence has the right to be tried within a reasonable time.
     
    Under the new framework, an unreasonable delay would be presumed should proceedings — from the criminal charge to conclusion of a trial — exceed 18 months in provincial court, or 30 months in superior court.
     
    However, these benchmarks are not set in stone.
     
    The Crown could challenge the notion that a delay is unreasonable by demonstrating "exceptional circumstances," a majority of the court said in its reasons.
     
    These circumstances could include something unforeseen and beyond the Crown's control, such as a sudden illness, or a case requiring extradition of an accused from another country. They might also arise in "particularly complex" cases that involve disclosure of many documents, a large number of witnesses or a significant need for expert evidence.
     
     
    In addition, a delay may be unreasonable even if it falls below the newly prescribed time limits. However, the defence would have to establish that it took meaningful steps to expedite the proceedings and show the case lasted "markedly longer" than it should have. 
     
    The Supreme Court said that as a transitional measure for cases already in the system, the new framework must be applied "flexibly and contextually."
     
    The court said a key problem with the previous system, which flowed from a 1992 high court ruling, was that long delays were considered reasonable unless the accused could show there was actual harm to his interests — a consideration that will not figure in the new framework.
     
    The right to be tried within a reasonable time is central to the administration of Canada's criminal justice system, wrote Justices Michael Moldaver, Andromache Karakatsanis and Russell Brown on behalf of the majority.
     
    "An unreasonable delay denies justice to the accused, victims and their families, and the public as a whole."
     
    However, unnecessary procedures and adjournments, inefficient practices and inadequate institutional resources have been "accepted as the norm and give rise to ever-increasing delay," the ruling said.
     
    The old framework failed to address this "culture of complacency," and participants in the justice system — police, Crown counsel, defence lawyers, courts, provincial legislatures and Parliament — were not encouraged to "take preventative measures to address inefficient practices and resourcing problems," the court said.
     
     
    The Supreme Court made the decision in ruling that the British Columbia drug convictions of Barrett Richard Jordan must be set aside due to an unreasonable delay.
     
    In a dissenting opinion, a minority of the court agreed the charges against Jordan should be stayed, but called the new framework for gauging delays "unwarranted and unwise," saying it could lead to thousands of prosecutions being tossed out. 
     
    If time limits are to be set out, Parliament — not the court — should do it, wrote Justice Thomas Cromwell on behalf of the minority, which lamented a lack of evidence on which to set the ceilings of 18 and 30 months.
     
    "For the vast majority of cases, the ceilings are so high that they risk being meaningless," Cromwell said. "They are unlikely to address the culture of delay that is said to exist. If anything, such high ceilings are more likely to feed such a culture rather than eliminate it."
     
    In a companion decision Friday, the Supreme Court affirmed that Kenneth Gavin Williamson's sexual assault convictions should be stayed due to delays in his case.
     
    A majority of the court said that at nearly three years, the relatively straightforward case took far longer than it should have, and the delay was unreasonable under either the old or new framework.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    B.C. Premier Says Men Play Important Role In Preventing Sexual Violence

    She made the comment a day after speaking publicly about being pulled into some bushes at age 13 as she walked down a street, but managed to escape from a man's grip.

    B.C. Premier Says Men Play Important Role In Preventing Sexual Violence

    Dying Liberal MP In Commons As Change To O Canada Lyrics Inches Closer

    Dying Liberal MP  In Commons As Change To O Canada Lyrics Inches Closer
    OTTAWA — The House of Commons is one step closer to adopting a dying Liberal MP's private member's bill to render the words to O Canada more gender-neutral.

    Dying Liberal MP In Commons As Change To O Canada Lyrics Inches Closer

    Crown Seeks Maximum Penalty Of 10 Years For Three Convicted In Cinar Case

    Crown Seeks Maximum Penalty Of 10 Years For Three Convicted In Cinar Case
    MONTREAL — The Crown prosecutor in the $120-million Cinar fraud case is asking a judge to sentence the three accused to the maximum penalty of 10 years in prison.

    Crown Seeks Maximum Penalty Of 10 Years For Three Convicted In Cinar Case

    Third Ontario Cabinet Minister Quits Ahead Of Expected Shuffle Monday

    Third Ontario Cabinet Minister Quits Ahead Of Expected Shuffle Monday
    TORONTO — Another Ontario cabinet minister has announced his resignation ahead of an expected shuffle.

    Third Ontario Cabinet Minister Quits Ahead Of Expected Shuffle Monday

    British Columbia Offers Free Family Fishing For Father’s Day

    British Columbia Offers Free Family Fishing For Father’s Day
    The Province is offering licence-free freshwater fishing this Father’s Day weekend, making it easy for everyone get out and enjoy one of British Columbia’s most popular recreational activities.

    British Columbia Offers Free Family Fishing For Father’s Day

    Vancouver Police Need Your Help To Catch A Killer

    Vancouver Police Need Your Help To Catch A Killer
    Vancouver Police are asking the public again to help them catch a killer. Two more cases have been added to the Department’s Cold Case website vpdcoldcases.ca, which is dedicated to generating tips to solve these crimes.

    Vancouver Police Need Your Help To Catch A Killer