Close X
Sunday, November 10, 2024
ADVT 
National

Supreme Court Dismisses Chevron Appeal In Ecuador Environmental Damages Case

The Canadian Press, 04 Sep, 2015 12:35 PM
    OTTAWA — The Supreme Court of Canada has dismissed an attempt by oil giant Chevron to block Ecuadorian villagers from using an Ontario court to collect billions in damages for environmental contamination.
     
    The 7-0 ruling allows the case to proceed in Canada, but it makes no finding on the merits of the long-running legal saga that has played out in courtrooms across the Western Hemisphere.
     
    The key issue at play was whether there was a real and substantial connection between the villagers and the dispute on one hand and the province of Ontario on the other.
     
    The high court decided there was no need to prove that connection, as long as a foreign court assumed valid jurisdiction over a case.
     
    "Canadian courts, like many others, have adopted a generous and liberal approach to the recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments," Justice Clement Gascon wrote for the court.
     
    Chevron Corp. has no assets in Ecuador, but that country's highest court has affirmed a $9.5 billion US judgment against the company, so the villagers pursued its subsidiary, Chevron Canada.
     
    The Supreme Court made clear that it was not prejudicing any future decision in the case. But it said the Chevron entities had to show up in an Ontario court, where they were free to defend the action.
     
    "A finding of jurisdiction does nothing more than afford the plaintiffs the opportunity to seek recognition and enforcement of the Ecuadorian judgment," Gascon wrote.
     
    "I take no position on whether Chevron Canada can properly be considered a judgment-debtor to the Ecuadorian judgment," he added.
     
    "Similarly, should the judgment be recognized and enforced against Chevron, it does not automatically follow that Chevron Canada's shares or assets will be available to satisfy Chevron's debt."
     
    Lawyers for the villagers have turned to courts in Brazil and Argentina, as well as in Canada, to collect.
     
    The Supreme Court decision upheld a December ruling by the Ontario Court of Appeal, which said the villagers could pursue their action for damages in a Canadian court.
     
    The appeal court ruling overturned a lower court judge, who found that Chevron Canada should not be held responsible for the judgment because its assets are not directly owned by the California-based multinational.
     
    The Supreme Court did not address another key issue put forth by Chevron — that subsidiaries are separate and should not be held liable for the actions of their corporate parents.
     
    It was simply enough that Chevron Canada was properly served at its office in Mississauga, Ont., the court said.
     
    "Where jurisdiction stems from the defendant's presence in the jurisdiction, there is no need to consider whether a real and substantial connection exists," it said.
     
    The Ecuadorian villagers have not gone after Chevron in the U.S. because a New York judge ruled in favour of the company, saying the judgment in Ecuador was obtained through fraudulent and corrupt means. That matter is under appeal as well.
     
    The Supreme Court also said there was nothing wrong with a creditor looking around in foreign jurisdictions for a way to collect on a judgement against a company.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    New Offence Prompts One Day In Jail For Man Who Dragged Victim To Death In 2005

    New Offence Prompts One Day In Jail For Man Who Dragged Victim To Death In 2005
    The father of a man killed 10 years ago in a horrifying gas-and-dash in Metro Vancouver is furious about the latest sentence handed to his son's killer.

    New Offence Prompts One Day In Jail For Man Who Dragged Victim To Death In 2005

    North American Stock Markets Rebound In Early Trading After Global Tumult

    North American Stock Markets Rebound In Early Trading After Global Tumult
    The Toronto Stock Exchange's main index rebounded Tuesday morning, making up much of the 420-point drubbing it got in the previous day's tumult as traders adjusted to persistent concerns about the strength of China's economy.

    North American Stock Markets Rebound In Early Trading After Global Tumult

    Heavy Wildfire Smoke From U.S. Has Small Upside For Firefighters In B.C.

    Heavy Wildfire Smoke From U.S. Has Small Upside For Firefighters In B.C.
    Smoke from wildfires burning in Washington state has caused visibility and air quality problems in British Columbia, but it's also helping to keep the province's own fires in check.

    Heavy Wildfire Smoke From U.S. Has Small Upside For Firefighters In B.C.

    Amid Swooning Markets, Leaders Battle Over Who's Best Suited To Manage Economy

    Amid Swooning Markets, Leaders Battle Over Who's Best Suited To Manage Economy
    Stephen Harper was asked about the previous day's phone conversation with the governor of the Bank of Canada, which was publicized by the Prime Minister's Office on a day of widespread market anxiety.

    Amid Swooning Markets, Leaders Battle Over Who's Best Suited To Manage Economy

    Four Brits Among Six Victims In Quebec Plane Crash

    Britain's Foreign Office says four Britons were among six people killed when a sightseeing seaplane crashed in a remote area of Quebec's North Shore on Sunday.

    Four Brits Among Six Victims In Quebec Plane Crash

    Windsor Housekeeper Finds And Returns Guest's Purse With US $4,700

    Windsor Housekeeper Finds And Returns Guest's Purse With US $4,700
    A Windsor, Ont., housekeeper said she expected the usual haul of linens and towels when she began cleaning a room at a Days Inn hotel — not a bag filled with US$4,700 in cash.

    Windsor Housekeeper Finds And Returns Guest's Purse With US $4,700