Close X
Monday, November 25, 2024
ADVT 
National

Supreme Court Affirms Privacy Rights For Canadians Who Share A Computer

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 13 Dec, 2018 10:11 PM

    OTTAWA — Sharing a computer with someone does not mean giving up privacy rights over the material stored on the machine, the Supreme Court of Canada has ruled.


    In a 9-0 decision Thursday, the high court restored the acquittal of Thomas Reeves of Sudbury, Ont., on child-pornography charges — even though his common-law spouse had consented to police seizure of a jointly used computer from their home.


    In October 2012, police arrived at the home without a warrant after Reeves' spouse reported finding what she believed to be child pornography on the computer.


    The ruling says although the couple shared the computer, Reeves had a reasonable expectation of privacy concerning its contents.


    Section 8 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms protects Canadians against unreasonable search and seizure, including in cases where police have found some evidence of criminal activity.


    The court found the warrantless seizure of the computer and subsequent search were unreasonable, meaning the child-pornography evidence should be disallowed.


    Although the decision was unanimous, two of the nine judges provided their own rationales.


    The majority reasons by Justice Andromache Karakatsanis stress that the case affects the privacy rights of all Canadians who share computers with others.


    "Shared control does not mean no control," she wrote. "We are not required to accept that our friends and family can unilaterally authorize police to take things that we share. The decision to share with others does not come at such a high price in a free and democratic society."


    Deciding otherwise could disproportionately affect the privacy rights of low-income people, who might be more likely to share a home computer, she added.


    Child-pornography offences are "serious and insidious" and there is a strong public interest in investigating and prosecuting them, the decision said. However, in applying charter rights, the question is not whether a person broke the law but whether the police exceeded the limits of the state's authority.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Higher Fines And More Rules Coming For B.C.'s Party Bus Industry: Ministry

    Higher Fines And More Rules Coming For B.C.'s Party Bus Industry: Ministry
    VICTORIA — The British Columbia government is boosting fines for party buses that don't meet inspection standards and is considering other measures to make the industry safer, especially for minors.

    Higher Fines And More Rules Coming For B.C.'s Party Bus Industry: Ministry

    Two Youth In Surrey, B.C., Sent To Hospital With Stab Injuries

    Two Youth In Surrey, B.C., Sent To Hospital With Stab Injuries
      RCMP is investigating an assault with a weapon which occurred in the parking lot of a convenience store on Wednesday morning.

    Two Youth In Surrey, B.C., Sent To Hospital With Stab Injuries

    Rituraj Kaur Grewal Charged In Surrey Crash That Killed 17-Year-Old Soccer Captain Travis Selje

    Police say Rituraj Kaur Grewal, who was 22 at the time of the May 2017 collisions, faces charges of criminal negligence causing death, criminal negligence causing bodily harm and leaving the scene of a crash.

    Rituraj Kaur Grewal Charged In Surrey Crash That Killed 17-Year-Old Soccer Captain Travis Selje

    Indian Arrested In Thailand For Visa Breach, Giving Loans Illegally

    Indian Arrested In Thailand For Visa Breach, Giving Loans Illegally
    An Indian man was arrested in Thailand's Phichit province on Thursday for overstaying his visa and for allegedly providing loans with interest rates higher than the legal limit.

    Indian Arrested In Thailand For Visa Breach, Giving Loans Illegally

    WorkSafe BC Report Cites Safety Failures In Derailment That Killed 3 Workers

    WorkSafe BC Report Cites Safety Failures In Derailment That Killed 3 Workers
    VICTORIA — Decaying railroad ties and the failure of a safety mechanism to prevent a train derailment are cited in a report by British Columbia's workers' safety agency as factors in a crash that killed three people and injured two others.

    WorkSafe BC Report Cites Safety Failures In Derailment That Killed 3 Workers

    New Teachers In Ontario Will Be Made To Take Math Test Before Getting Licence

    New Teachers In Ontario Will Be Made To Take Math Test Before Getting Licence
    TORONTO — The Ontario government says all aspiring teachers in the province will be required to pass a math test before receiving their licence to teach.

    New Teachers In Ontario Will Be Made To Take Math Test Before Getting Licence