Close X
Thursday, November 14, 2024
ADVT 
National

Squirrel And Surveillance Case: Montreal-Area Man Fought The Law And The Law Won

The Canadian Press, 25 Sep, 2015 12:13 PM
    MONTREAL — A Montreal-area man who went all the way to the Supreme Court in a battle that originated with his feeding squirrels and birds in public spaces says he was fighting for all Canadians.
     
    Lawrence Klepper, 73, received nine violations between 2006 and 2011 from the City of Westmount, a community located just west of downtown Montreal.
     
    The city took exception, for health reasons, to his animal-friendly practice of feeding wildlife with nuts and birdseed and had him followed by a public security official in an unmarked car.
     
    Westmount filed injunctions against Klepper but withdrew them when he stopped feeding the animals and birds.
     
    But Klepper proceeded to the Supreme Court with a cross demand to seek punitive and moral damages, alleging his right to privacy and dignity had been violated because of the surveillance.
     
    The high court said Thursday it would not hear his case.
     
    Klepper expressed disappointment and sadness with the decision.
     
    ''This was not a file of Klepper versus the City of Westmount,'' he said in an interview Friday. ''This file was really for citizens across Canada.''
     
    Klepper said he loves all animals and donates money to animal charities, hospitals and other organizations.
     
    ''I don't have any particular more love for squirrels or birds than I have for all animals and all humanity,'' he said.
     
    ''I don't have any unusual behaviour. I've never been in court in my life prior to the city taking an injunction against me.''
     
    His lawyer, Dominique Pion, called Thursday a ''sad day for the right of privacy in Canada.''
     
    ''We're both greatly disappointed that the Supreme Court didn't grant the leave in this case,'' Pion said in the same interview.
     
    ''Our main goal in making such an application was that the Supreme Court would set limits to the power of surveillance exercised by public security officers.''
     
    Westmount Mayor Peter Trent expressed satisfaction at seeing the case end and pointed to a Quebec Superior Court ruling from 2013 that said the city had the right to enforce its laws and that Klepper's case was without merit.
     
    Trent said Westmount received a letter in April 2010 from Montreal public health officials that talked about a large colony of rats having established itself near a very popular park because of peanuts being tossed on the ground.
     
    ''It's a matter of public health,'' Trent argued. ''We've had a rat-population problem for some years and feeding animals just exacerbates it, especially when you do it in industrial quantities. It's that simple.''
     
    On the surveillance front, the mayor referred to the following passage in the Superior Court ruling: ''If the enforcement of bylaws means the exercise of adequate surveillance, let there be adequate and reasonable surveillance.''
     
    As for Klepper, he doesn't believe he's still under surveillance.
     
    ''I'm very comfortable right now,'' he said. ''Hopefully, it will stay that way.''

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Groups To Protest Removal Of Historic Ruins Near Montreal Highway Construction Site

    Groups To Protest Removal Of Historic Ruins Near Montreal Highway Construction Site
    Archeologists unearthed the ruins of the former village earlier this summer. 

    Groups To Protest Removal Of Historic Ruins Near Montreal Highway Construction Site

    Former Harper Aide Bruce Carson Pleads Not Guilty To Influence Peddling

    Bruce Carson is charged in connection with the proposed sale of water purification systems to First Nations communities.

    Former Harper Aide Bruce Carson Pleads Not Guilty To Influence Peddling

    Federal Government Balances Books One Year Early, Posts Surprise $1.9 Billion Surplus

    The number ends a streak of six deficits under the Conservatives and is certain to reverberate on the campaign trail.

    Federal Government Balances Books One Year Early, Posts Surprise $1.9 Billion Surplus

    Victoria Sewage Woes Still Cause Stink As Region Sends Site Proposal Down Drain

    Victoria Sewage Woes Still Cause Stink As Region Sends Site Proposal Down Drain
     The Victoria region is on the hook for $750,000 now that plans have officially fallen through on the proposed site for a controversial sewage treatment plant.

    Victoria Sewage Woes Still Cause Stink As Region Sends Site Proposal Down Drain

    Elderly Indo-Canadian Woman Goes Missing In Surrey

    Elderly Indo-Canadian Woman Goes Missing In Surrey
    Mohinder Sodhi was reported missing on September 4 from her residence in the 6600 block of 127 A Street, Surrey

    Elderly Indo-Canadian Woman Goes Missing In Surrey

    Grizzly Bear Attack Survivors Thank B.C. Rescuers With Fundraiser

    Grizzly Bear Attack Survivors Thank B.C. Rescuers With Fundraiser
     A pair of British Columbia hunters recovering from a grizzly bear attack are taking extra steps to make sure their rescuers know just how thankful they are.

    Grizzly Bear Attack Survivors Thank B.C. Rescuers With Fundraiser