Close X
Thursday, November 28, 2024
ADVT 
National

Sex Consensual But Ontario Pharmacist Mohamed Hanif's Licence Loss Ruled Constitutional

The Canadian Press, 25 Sep, 2015 01:01 PM
    TORONTO — A pharmacist whose licence was automatically revoked because he had consensual sex with a patient has lost his bid to have the relevant rules governing health professionals thrown out as unconstitutional.
     
    In its written decision released this week, Ontario's top court rejected arguments from Mohamed Hanif that provisions of the province's Health Professions Procedural Code regulate morality and therefore stray into federal territory.
     
    "Treating a patient while involved in a sexual relationship undermines the integrity of the professional-patient relationship," the Appeal Court ruled. "The intended, and in fact overwhelming, effect of the provisions is to protect the public."
     
    Hanif, who was a pharmacist at Loblaws in Simcoe, Ont, fulfilled prescriptions for a cashier at the store. In 2008, they developed a romantic and consensual sexual relationship. When Loblaws found out, it fired him and referred the situation to the Ontario College of Pharmacists, which began disciplinary proceedings against him in 2011.
     
    Under the code, any sexual activity between a health professional and a patient constitutes sexual abuse that automatically leads to loss of a licence to practise for at least five years.
     
    Hanif did not challenge the purpose of the code — to prevent sexual abuse. Instead, he maintained that automatically stripping him of his licence effectively stigmatized him as a sexual abuser.
     
    As a result, he argued, the provincial code had crossed the line into "impermissible regulation of morality in the context of consensual sexual relations," something only the Criminal Code can do.
     
    Last November, Superior Court Justice Graeme Mew rejected Hanif's arguments.
     
    "The imposition of mandatory licence revocation in certain cases of sexual abuse may well be seen by some as too blunt an instrument to address the undoubted harm caused by health-care professionals who have sexual relations with a patient," Mew said in his decision.
     
    "That does not render the impugned provisions of the code criminal law."
     
    Mew found the code's mandatory revocation provisions are concerned with preventing sexual abuse of patients by professionals.
     
    Their aim is to make sexual acts "inconsistent with a professional-patient relationship," he said.
     
    The Appeal Court agreed, saying Mew's analysis was correct.
     
    For one thing, the Appeal Court said, the provisions do not have the effect of regulating morality but are aimed at maintaining the integrity of the professional-patient relationship.
     
    "They do not have the effect of importing notions of sexual morality on consenting adults," the court found.
     
    In addition, the Appeal Court noted all offences involve some stigma that may lead to a loss of respect in the public eye — and that includes breaking provincial law.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Verdict Delayed For Speedboat Operator Accused In Shuswap Lake Death

    Verdict Delayed For Speedboat Operator Accused In Shuswap Lake Death
    Leon Reinbrecht is charged with criminal negligence causing death and criminal negligence causing bodily harm in the July 2010 crash on Shuswap Lake that claimed the life of Ken Brown.

    Verdict Delayed For Speedboat Operator Accused In Shuswap Lake Death

    Police Watchdog Probes Officer-Involved Death Of Man In B.C.'s Fraser Valley

    RCMP say British Columbia's police watchdog has been called to investigate the death of a man who apparently injured himself with a knife.

    Police Watchdog Probes Officer-Involved Death Of Man In B.C.'s Fraser Valley

    Municipalities Vote To Call On B.C. To Eliminate Local Auditor General Position

    Municipalities Vote To Call On B.C. To Eliminate Local Auditor General Position
    VANCOUVER — Municipal leaders in British Columbia have voted to call on the province to scrap a controversial office that audits local governments.

    Municipalities Vote To Call On B.C. To Eliminate Local Auditor General Position

    No Damage As Moderate Earthquake Shivers Off Northwestern Vancouver Island

    No Damage As Moderate Earthquake Shivers Off Northwestern Vancouver Island
    VANCOUVER — A moderate earthquake has been recorded off the northwest tip of Vancouver Island.

    No Damage As Moderate Earthquake Shivers Off Northwestern Vancouver Island

    Two B.C. Men Face Weapons Charges After Bull Elk Shot And Abandoned: Police

    Two B.C. Men Face Weapons Charges After Bull Elk Shot And Abandoned: Police
    Two men accused of shooting a bull elk and leaving its body behind on Vancouver Island face a list of firearms offences.

    Two B.C. Men Face Weapons Charges After Bull Elk Shot And Abandoned: Police

    Scholarship Still Honouring B.C. Soldier 99 Years After His Death

    Scholarship Still Honouring B.C. Soldier 99 Years After His Death
    Jack McMillan's death on a European battlefield 99 years ago resulted in a heartbreak so profound that it's still felt by those who win a scholarship created in his name.

    Scholarship Still Honouring B.C. Soldier 99 Years After His Death