Close X
Wednesday, November 13, 2024
ADVT 
National

Senators challenge name, need for Tories' new bill on cultural practices

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 04 Dec, 2014 10:32 AM

    OTTAWA — The need for and even the name of a new Conservative bill aimed at barring polygamous and forced marriages came under criticism Thursday in the Senate.

    Bill S-7, entitled the Zero Tolerance for Barbaric Cultural Practices Act, amends immigration and criminal laws and is aimed at keeping polygamists out of Canada and preventing women and girls from being married against their will.

    "We wish we could say in the Canada of 2014 that these were no longer challenges for us domestically," Immigration Minister Chris Alexander told the Senate human rights committee on Thursday.

    "But as we know from communities across the country and from the daily fact of violence against women, they remain challenges and we remain duty bound to act against them."

    Conservative Senator Raynell Andreychuk raised concerns that the government's goal of the bill to combat violence is overshadowed by its dramatic title.

    "I'm wondering, in that title, if you wanted barbaric cultural practices, which probably wasn't going to be my choice, but if you wanted that, I wished you had added something like violence in there," she said.

    Alexander defended the name, saying the fact that it's generated debate is a victory for the government's objective.

    "What is a barbaric practice? It is a practice that is unacceptable, it is a practice that involves violence that is in many respects indiscriminate, gratuitously meted out, behind closed doors, where women and girls are defenceless, whereby whole families conspire to ensure underage women lie about their age, take part in a forced marriage," he said.

    "It is, in my view, and I think in the view of many Canadians, barbaric to subject your family members to that kind of abuse."

    The new law would deny entry to Canada to those seeking to practice polygamy, which is illegal in this country.

    It would also require "free and enlightened consent to marriage" and sets a federal minimum age for marriage at 16 — there had been no such law on the books before.

    It also makes it an offence for anyone younger than that to be taken out of Canada to be married elsewhere.

    That's a direct reference to the polygamous community of Bountiful, B.C., believed to regularly shuttle teenage girls back and forth from the U.S. for marriage.

    Four members of that community are charged in relation to that practice under existing laws, but past attempts to convict members of polygamy have failed.

    The bill would also bar people charged in honour killings from arguing they were provoked to murder by cultural norms and thus reduce their sentences, though no one charged with an honour killing has ever claimed that, immigration officials told the committee.

    "The law you bring here has very little evidence based to it. We've heard of one case of forced marriage that this is based on and absolutely no successful cases of honour killing," said Liberal Sen. Art Eggleton.

    "You have current laws to deal with it and you seem more focused on trying to bring a new law in when you have existing laws you could deal with these matters."

    Alexander said Eggleton hadn't done his homework, noting extensive research has been done on the issue of forced marriages in Canada, pointing to the work of the South Asian Legal Clinic of Ontario.

    In a 2013 survey of social assistance agencies in Ontario and Quebec, the agency uncovered 69 forced marriage cases in 2010, 64 cases in 2011 and 77 cases in 2012.

    Yet, the organization itself opposes the proposed bill.

    "The government's statements in support of these changes are not based on any statistical data or research, perpetuate myths about practices of polygamy and forced marriages and lead Canadians to believe that violence against women is a 'cultural' issue that happens only in certain communities," a coalition of groups, including SALCO, said in a Nov. 18 news release.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Christy Clark Says Americans Not Behaving As 'Friends' In Prince Rupert Terminal Project

    Christy Clark Says Americans Not Behaving As 'Friends' In Prince Rupert Terminal Project
    VICTORIA — British Columbia Premier Christy Clark has lashed out at the United States, saying it's trying to impose its own federal purchasing provisions on the construction of a ferry terminal in Canada. 

    Christy Clark Says Americans Not Behaving As 'Friends' In Prince Rupert Terminal Project

    Vancouver Man Booked For Practising Illegal Dentistry Out Of Basement

    Vancouver Man Booked For Practising Illegal Dentistry Out Of Basement
    VANCOUVER — B.C.'s regulatory body for dentists is taking action against a man it claims was practising illegal dentistry in the basement of a Vancouver house.

    Vancouver Man Booked For Practising Illegal Dentistry Out Of Basement

    Ex-military intelligence officer apologizes for planning attack on Veterans Affairs office

    Ex-military intelligence officer apologizes for planning attack on Veterans Affairs office
    CALGARY — A former Canadian soldier who has admitted planning an attack on the Calgary office of Veterans Affairs says he is sorry and never intended to follow through.

    Ex-military intelligence officer apologizes for planning attack on Veterans Affairs office

    Grand Chief Stewart Phillip arrested at Kinder Morgan protest

    Grand Chief Stewart Phillip arrested at Kinder Morgan protest
    VANCOUVER — A prominent B.C. First Nations leader has been arrested for violating a court order, the same as more than other 100 other activists who have already opposed Kinder Morgan's plans to expand an existing pipeline.

    Grand Chief Stewart Phillip arrested at Kinder Morgan protest

    Clamouring for new mollusk: researchers say new species one-of-a-kind find

    Clamouring for new mollusk: researchers say new species one-of-a-kind find
    VICTORIA — Ten years after an unusually scalloped clam was dragged up from the ocean floor off northern Vancouver Island, the tiny mollusk is making waves in the research world.

    Clamouring for new mollusk: researchers say new species one-of-a-kind find

    Jian Ghomeshi will plead not guilty to sexual assault charges: Lawyer

    Jian Ghomeshi will plead not guilty to sexual assault charges: Lawyer
    TORONTO — A sombre Jian Ghomeshi stood silently by his lawyer on Wednesday as she told a large crowd of reporters at a Toronto courthouse that the former CBC Radio host would plead not guilty to multiple counts of sexual assault.

    Jian Ghomeshi will plead not guilty to sexual assault charges: Lawyer