Close X
Wednesday, September 25, 2024
ADVT 
National

Seizure Of Crime Proceeds Often A Provincial Cash Grab, New Report Finds

The Canadian Press, 08 Mar, 2016 01:20 PM
    TORONTO — Canadian provinces have confiscated tens of millions of dollars in assets as proceeds of crime, but a new report indicates the seizures are often a simple cash grab from innocent parties.
     
    The analysis concludes the rationale for the laws — to confiscate property from criminals and organized crime and compensate victims — has been lost in their application.
     
    "These laws are not fair," states the report by the Canadian Constitution Foundation and Institute for Liberal Studies.
     
    "Civil forfeiture laws allow provincial governments to seize property not only from criminals, but also from people who have never been charged with, or even suspected of, a crime."
     
    In criminal proceedings, the standard for guilt is proof "beyond a reasonable doubt." Civil cases work on lower "balance of probabilities." This makes it easier to go after cash and other assets, especially where evidence for criminal charges, let alone a conviction, is lacking, the report states.
     
    In one case, a man in Saskatchewan sold $60 worth of Oxycontin he legally owned to buy gas so he could drive to work. The government took away his $7,500 truck.
     
    One Ontario couple saw their $400,000 12-unit apartment building seized because some renters were involved in illegal activities. The province argued they should have evicted the tenants. In another Ontario case, the province sought to confiscate a couple's two rooming houses because some tenants allegedly sold drugs.
     
    Alberta assumes that if police find $10,000 or more in cash during an investigation, the money was illegally acquired. British Columbia confiscates expensive cars — in one case a $235,000 Ferrari — used in traffic offences.
     
    No province requires criminal charges or convictions to initiate civil-forfeiture proceedings. In fact, New Brunswick makes it explicit you can still lose your property even if you're acquitted criminally.
     
    Another issue, according to the report, is that money from such proceedings goes to provincial governments and police services with little accountability or transparency.
     
    B.C., for example, has seized $41 million in recent years, but paid out just $1.5 million to victims. Ontario reports distributing $21.2 million to victims to since 2003. Yet in 2013-14 alone, the province seized $22.9 million. One police board in Ontario, Peel region, used seized money to buy tens of thousands of dollars in tickets to mayoral galas. B.C. used none of the money it seized between 2006 and 2012 to compensate victims. Instead, all went into the civil forfeiture regime itself.
     
     
    In addition, some provinces appear to make no effort to track the money. The report states that none of the provincial forfeiture regimes has been subject to an auditor general's review.
     
    "It is difficult to know how much money collected by successful civil forfeiture applications goes towards compensating victims," the report states. "Instead, it seems that much is used to purchase equipment for the police or is spent on trivial and improper expenses."
     
    There was no immediate comment from the provinces to the report.
     
    The Calgary-based foundation, which bills itself as protecting the constitutional freedoms of Canadians, and the Ottawa-based liberal studies institute make several recommendations:
     
    — Forfeiture should only be available when a property owner has been convicted of a provincial offence.
     
    — Judges should have discretion to craft proportionate forfeiture orders.
     
    — Civil forfeiture should only be available for property used or acquired by an owner convicted of a corresponding provincial offence where an identifiable victim was harmed.
     
    — Revenue collected by successful civil forfeitures should compensate victims that suffered harm as a result of a convicted property owner's acts.
     
    — Each provincial civil forfeiture office should provide a full and accurate annual report on revenues raised and compensation disbursed.
     
    Only Prince Edward Island and Newfoundland and Labrador have no such laws among provinces. Neither do the territories.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    RCMP Credit Horn-honking Homeowner For Halting Thefts In Salmon Arm, B.C.

    RCMP Credit Horn-honking Homeowner For Halting Thefts In Salmon Arm, B.C.
    SALMON ARM , B.C. — A Salmon Arm, B.C., man didn't need a cellphone to call for help as he chased robbers from his home when a lower-tech method proved just as effective, and a lot noisier.

    RCMP Credit Horn-honking Homeowner For Halting Thefts In Salmon Arm, B.C.

    Death Toll Now At 2: Worker Badly Burned In Alberta Oilsands Explosion Dies

    Death Toll Now At 2: Worker Badly Burned In Alberta Oilsands Explosion Dies
    The critically injured man had been transported to the burn unit at an Edmonton hospital, where his family from Nova Scotia stayed by his side.

    Death Toll Now At 2: Worker Badly Burned In Alberta Oilsands Explosion Dies

    Justin Trudeau May Regret Resource Industry Comments Made In Davos: B.C. Mines Minister

    Justin Trudeau May Regret Resource Industry Comments Made In Davos: B.C. Mines Minister
    Bill Bennett says Trudeau may come to regret saying in a speech that Canada amounts to not just the resources under Canadians' feet but rather their resourcefulness and what lies between their ears.

    Justin Trudeau May Regret Resource Industry Comments Made In Davos: B.C. Mines Minister

    Military Reserve Running 19 Per Cent Under Strength As Part-Timers Bail

    Military Reserve Running 19 Per Cent Under Strength As Part-Timers Bail
    The numbers were released in federal departmental performance reports for the last budget year, which also show the military's medical branch has 367 unfilled positions — both uniformed and civilian.

    Military Reserve Running 19 Per Cent Under Strength As Part-Timers Bail

    New Documents Offer Little Insight On UBC President Arvind Gupta's Resignation

    The university has released 861 pages of documents in response to a series of Access to Information requests, including meeting agendas, receipts, emails and the terms of Gupta's resignation.

    New Documents Offer Little Insight On UBC President Arvind Gupta's Resignation

    17-Year-Old Suspect In Saskatchewan Shooting Teased, Called Himself 'Black Sheep:' Friends

    The teen, who made his first court appearance Monday, was known to hold his emotions inside and rarely spoke, even when hanging out with his high school buddies in La Loche.

    17-Year-Old Suspect In Saskatchewan Shooting Teased, Called Himself 'Black Sheep:' Friends