Close X
Wednesday, December 4, 2024
ADVT 
National

Researchers At Edmonton University Cast Doubt On Vitamin D Supplements

The Canadian Press, 17 Jun, 2016 01:11 PM
    EDMONTON — Researchers at the University of Alberta are suggesting there might not be as much medical benefit to vitamin D supplements as previously thought.
     
    A team led by Michael Allen, director of the Evidence-Based Medicine Department at the faculty of medicine, recently examined the evidence for 10 common beliefs about the pills.
     
    Those range from their touted ability to reduce falls and fractures to their use in preventing rheumatoid arthritis and treating multiple sclerosis.
     
    The professor says his review, published in the Journal of General Internal Medicine, shows many of the beliefs aren't validated by science.
     
    In fact, he says there's little evidence vitamin D has much effect at all as a nutritional supplement.
     
    Most significantly, he says the team concluded vitamin D pills have only a minor impact in reducing the number of falls among the elderly and reducing fractures.
     
    “If you were to take a group of people who were at higher risk of breaking a bone — so had about a 15 per cent chance of breaking a bone over the next 10 years — and treated all of them with a reasonable dose of vitamin D for a decade, you’d prevent a fracture in around one in 50 of them over that time," says Allen.
     
    “Many people would say taking a drug for 10 years to stop one in every 50 fractures is probably not enough to be meaningful. And that’s the best vitamin D gets as far as we know now.”
     
    According to Health Canada, vitamin D is a nutrient that helps the body use calcium and phosphorous to build and maintain strong bones and teeth, and is synthesized by the body after exposure to ultraviolet rays from sunlight.
     
    The Canadian Cancer Society says on its website that "there is ... evidence that vitamin D may reduce the risk of some types of cancer, particularly colorectal and breast cancers" while the Multiple Sclerosis Society of Canada says "a growing body of evidence demonstrates that vitamin D deficiency is associated with multiple sclerosis."
     
    However, Allan says much of the existing research around vitamin D supplements was poorly executed and consists of poor quality evidence.
     
    While he welcomes ongoing research in the area, he says moving forward it needs to consistently be of a higher calibre to be of clinical relevance.
     
    “Wouldn’t it be great if there was a single thing that you or I could do to be healthy that was as simple as taking a vitamin, which seems benign, every day?" says the professor.
     
    "There is an appeal to it. There is a simplicity to it. But for the average person, they don’t need it.”

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Vancouver Police Looking For Witnesses To Attempted Abduction

    Vancouver Police Looking For Witnesses To Attempted Abduction
    The Vancouver Police Department has been investigating an attempted abduction that occurred in April and are asking for any witnesses to come forward.

    Vancouver Police Looking For Witnesses To Attempted Abduction

    Northwestern B.C. Woman Accused Of Stealing Cab After Spray Painting Driver

    Northwestern B.C. Woman Accused Of Stealing Cab After Spray Painting Driver
    Terrace RCMP Sgt. Mike Robinson says 27-year-old Kim Archambault is charged with robbery.

    Northwestern B.C. Woman Accused Of Stealing Cab After Spray Painting Driver

    Two Teenage Girls Struck, Killed By Train In Small Nova Scotia Community

    Two Teenage Girls Struck, Killed By Train In Small Nova Scotia Community
    RCMP say they were called to an intersection at Mader Street and Highway 2 in Lantz, N.S., around 1:40 a.m. after someone on the train called 911.

    Two Teenage Girls Struck, Killed By Train In Small Nova Scotia Community

    Defence Urges Jury To Find Stepmom Accused Of Killing Teen Not Guilty

    Defence Urges Jury To Find Stepmom Accused Of Killing Teen Not Guilty
    TORONTO — A Toronto jury hearing the case of a woman accused of killing her stepdaughter is being told she was unaware the teen's life was at risk and that her husband in fact drowned the malnourished and abused girl.

    Defence Urges Jury To Find Stepmom Accused Of Killing Teen Not Guilty

    New Office To Help With No-Fly List Headaches, A Step Toward Full Redress System

    New Office To Help With No-Fly List Headaches, A Step Toward Full Redress System
    OTTAWA — The Liberal government is creating an office to handle inquiries from travellers who have run into problems at the airport due to aviation-security lists.

    New Office To Help With No-Fly List Headaches, A Step Toward Full Redress System

    Trial Hears Alberta Had Little Record Of Diabetic Teen Before He Died

    Trial Hears Alberta Had Little Record Of Diabetic Teen Before He Died
    CALGARY — A trial has heard that a teen who died of untreated diabetes and starvation virtually disappeared from public life once his family relocated to Alberta from British Columbia.

    Trial Hears Alberta Had Little Record Of Diabetic Teen Before He Died