Close X
Tuesday, September 24, 2024
ADVT 
National

Quebec Law Professors File Appeal Against Monarchy Law Passed By Harper

The Canadian Press, 10 Apr, 2016 01:24 PM
    MONTREAL — The rules governing the ascension to the British throne are once again being challenged in Quebec.
     
    The province's top court will hear the case of two law professors after Superior Court rejected their challenge of a federal law aimed at changing the rules regarding the British monarchy.
     
    Quebec government lawyers will also present arguments at the appeals court level to defend the province's position that Ottawa should not be acting without consulting it.
     
    The conflict dates back to 2011, when leaders of Commonwealth countries agreed to modify the rules so that a woman, if she is the oldest sibling, could become Queen.
     
    That would put an end to the practice of giving men priority as heirs to the British throne.
     
    The changes were meant to be adopted in each of the Commonwealth nations. The former Conservative government did so in 2013 with a new law.
     
     
    Universite Laval law professors Patrick Taillon and Genevieve Motard went to court, claiming the law was unconstitutional.
     
    They argued there is no unwritten rule in Canada that makes the British Queen automatically the Queen of Canada, as the federal government asserted.
     
    Furthermore, they said any changes to the rules of the monarchy succession necessitate changes to the Canadian Constitution, which would require the consent of the provinces.
     
    A Quebec judge sided with the federal government in February.
     
    "No amendment to the Constitution is required," Superior Court Justice Claude Bouchard wrote.
     
    Taillon said he has decided to appeal the decision because the law "calls into question Canadian independence."
     
     
    "It also challenges rights acquired with the repatriation of the Canadian Constitution in 1982."
     
    The British parliament no longer has the power to make laws for Canada and Taillon believes the Superior Court judgment contradicts that.
     
    Taillon says Canada would have two choices if the law is ever struck down.
     
    First of all, it could choose to not open the Constitution, thus not honouring its commitment to the Commonwealth and leaving open the possibility Canada could have a monarch other than the one who reigns in Britain.
     
     
    Or Canada could choose to seek the consent of the provinces, which risks triggering a series of constitutional disputes that could last years and be politically destabilizing for the country.
     
    "But that might be the occasion to force things through," Taillon said.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Jail Guards Say Health In Danger From Inmate Attacks Using Fluids

    Jail Guards Say Health In Danger From Inmate Attacks Using Fluids
    The Union of Canadian Correctional Officers says prisoners at the Atlantic Institution in New Brunswick have attacked guards with blood, urine and excrement in recent weeks.

    Jail Guards Say Health In Danger From Inmate Attacks Using Fluids

    Court Case Of Calgary Woman Allowed Doctor-Assisted Death Sets Example For Others

    The Calgary woman, known only as Ms. S in court documents, was granted an exemption Monday to end her life with the help of two doctors in Vancouver. She died later that day.

    Court Case Of Calgary Woman Allowed Doctor-Assisted Death Sets Example For Others

    Poll Suggests Two-Thirds Support For Energy East, But Big Regional Divides

    Poll Suggests Two-Thirds Support For Energy East, But Big Regional Divides
    The proposal to ship Alberta crude to Atlantic Canada had the strongest backing in Alberta and Saskatchewan — 87 per cent and 78 per cent, respectively.

    Poll Suggests Two-Thirds Support For Energy East, But Big Regional Divides

    Snail Mail Out: Alberta Switching To E-Reminders For ID, Licence Renewals, To Save $3 Million A Year

    Snail Mail Out: Alberta Switching To E-Reminders For ID, Licence Renewals, To Save $3 Million A Year
    Danielle Larivee, acting minister of Service Alberta, says the move will save taxpayers $3 million a year.

    Snail Mail Out: Alberta Switching To E-Reminders For ID, Licence Renewals, To Save $3 Million A Year

    Coroner Identifies Alberta Man Who Died Of Injuries In B.C. Avalanche

    Coroner Identifies Alberta Man Who Died Of Injuries In B.C. Avalanche
    The BC Coroners Service says 64-year-old Douglas Churchill was from Canmore, Alta.

    Coroner Identifies Alberta Man Who Died Of Injuries In B.C. Avalanche

    Manitoba Liberal Candidate Jamie Hall Resigns Over Derogatory Tweets About Women

    WINNIPEG — A Manitoba Liberal candidate who was criticized for using derogatory terms to refer to women on social media has resigned.

    Manitoba Liberal Candidate Jamie Hall Resigns Over Derogatory Tweets About Women