Close X
Monday, November 11, 2024
ADVT 
National

Quebec Bill Calls Animals 'Sentient Beings' And Includes Jail Time For Cruelty

The Canadian Press, 05 Jun, 2015 06:42 PM
  • Quebec Bill Calls Animals 'Sentient Beings' And Includes Jail Time For Cruelty
MONTREAL — Proposed Quebec legislation would impose heavy fines and jail time for serial animal abusers and go so far as to criminalize flushing live goldfish down the toilet.
 
"If you have a goldfish you have to take care of it," said Quebec Agriculture Minister Pierre Paradis, who tabled the legislation Friday. "Don't get a goldfish if you don't want to take care of it."
 
The bill states that "animals are not things. They are sentient beings and have biological needs."
 
For many people, that might seem obvious, but in Quebec an animal currently has the same legal rights as a piece of furniture.
 
"The biggest change (in the bill) is that up to now, an animal in Quebec is considered as a movable, like a piece of equipment," Paradis said. "It goes from that to being a sentient being."
 
Paradis believes his bill will transform Quebec from the jurisdiction with some of the least strict animal-welfare rules in North America — it is considered the puppy-mill capital of the continent — to one with some of the toughest.
 
He said he was inspired by Manitoba, Ontario and British Columbia, which he noted have the strongest animal-welfare laws in the country.
 
Paradis also looked to France, which updated its own laws last January to change the status of animals to sentient beings from their prior status of movable property.
 
The bill has separate rules for pet owners, farmers with livestock, owners of pet shops, or people who sell animal-based products such as furs.
 
Pet owners "must ensure that the animal's welfare and safety are not compromised," meaning domesticated animals have to receive "care that is consistent with (their) biological needs," the bill states.
 
Farmers must guarantee that their animals are "treated with dignity as much as possible" from the moment they are born to the day they are slaughtered.
 
But farm animals don't get the same protection as pets. They must be treated "in accordance with generally recognized rules," the bill reads.
 
That, says the head of animal advocacy for the SPCA in Montreal, means chickens, will still be allowed to be kept in enclosures no wider than a sheet of paper — called battery cages — for their entire lives.
 
"Whatever the (food) industry does on a wide scale is exempt," said Alanna Devine.
 
"I don't know if this means they'll be treated with dignity and respect."
 
She said the bill is unclear regarding the status of many wild and exotic animals and those found in zoos.
 
Devine's interpretation of the bill is that someone who shoots a squirrel in a park, for instance, is not covered in the legislation.
 
Despite wondering about how the bill be enforced, Devine called the legislation a "positive step."
 
Paradis said there will be no new money for inspectors but that his department has enough people to ensure the bill's provisions can be enforced.
 
The legislation gives inspectors the power to demand to see an animal if they have "reasonable cause" to suspect the pet is being mistreated.
 
They can also obtain a warrant from a judge to enter a home and seize animals.
 
First-time offenders face fines as low as $250 and as high as $250,000.
 
The fines can double and triple for repeat offenders. Judges will have the discretion to sentence serial violators of the proposed law to jail for up to 18 months.
 
Devine agrees with the fact that even goldfish owners should be subject to the law.
 
"We know scientifically that fish are sentient and can feel pain," she said. "If animals are capable of suffering then they should be included (in the bill)."

MORE National ARTICLES

Paraglider, 60, Taken To Hospital After Plunging Down Victoria Cliff

Paraglider, 60, Taken To Hospital After Plunging Down Victoria Cliff
Victoria Fire Department Batallion Chief Bob Jones says the 60-year-old man was flying with a group when he was struck by a down draft at about 8 p.m.

Paraglider, 60, Taken To Hospital After Plunging Down Victoria Cliff

Canada Loses 19,700 Jobs In April, Unemployment Rate Sticks At 6.8%

Canada Loses 19,700 Jobs In April, Unemployment Rate Sticks At 6.8%
OTTAWA — The Canadian economy lost 19,700 net jobs last month as the headline number in the latest labour-market data came in lower than economists' expectations.

Canada Loses 19,700 Jobs In April, Unemployment Rate Sticks At 6.8%

Ontario Woman Accused Of Faking Rare Neurological Disease To Raise $100,000

Ontario Woman Accused Of Faking Rare Neurological Disease To Raise $100,000
Police say Cynthia Lynn Smith claimed to be suffering from Chronic Inflammatory Demyelinating Polyneuropathy and acted out many of its symptoms.

Ontario Woman Accused Of Faking Rare Neurological Disease To Raise $100,000

Rob Ford Says New Ontario Sex-ed Curriculum Makes Him 'Absolutely Sick'

Rob Ford Says New Ontario Sex-ed Curriculum Makes Him 'Absolutely Sick'
The controversial former mayor of Toronto made his comments in an interview with The Rebel, an outlet run by former Sun TV host Ezra Levant. But Ford appears to have some details of the curriculum wrong.

Rob Ford Says New Ontario Sex-ed Curriculum Makes Him 'Absolutely Sick'

Timeline: The Case Of Former Guantanamo Bay Detainee Omar Khadr

Timeline: The Case Of Former Guantanamo Bay Detainee Omar Khadr
The federal government lost its bid Thursday to block former Guantanamo Bay prisoner Omar Khadr from being granted bail, clearing the way for him to get his first taste of freedom in almost 13 years.

Timeline: The Case Of Former Guantanamo Bay Detainee Omar Khadr

Toronto's Zain Rajani Is The First Baby Born Using 'Game-Changing' Egg-Enhancing Treatment

Toronto's Zain Rajani Is The First Baby Born Using 'Game-Changing' Egg-Enhancing Treatment
TORONTO — A Canadian woman is the first mother to give birth after undergoing a new procedure that boosts the health of women's eggs to improve the success rate of in-vitro fertilization.

Toronto's Zain Rajani Is The First Baby Born Using 'Game-Changing' Egg-Enhancing Treatment