Close X
Monday, November 18, 2024
ADVT 
National

Python Owner Not Cavalier Or Reckless, Defence Lawyer Says In Closing Argument

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 08 Nov, 2016 12:33 PM
    FREDERICTON — Jean-Claude Savoie didn't cover a ventilation pipe above his python's enclosure not because he was careless or reckless, but because he simply didn't believe the large snake could possibly fit through it, his lawyer told a New Brunswick jury in closing arguments Tuesday.
     
    The python travelled through a ventilation duct and dropped into the living room where the boys slept. Savoie's own son, sleeping in another room, was unharmed.
     
    A number of witnesses have said it was common to see the cover of the vent on the enclosure's floor.
     
    Defence lawyer Leslie Matchim said Tuesday the snake did try to escape about a month or so before the boys were killed, but got stuck partway through the pipe, convincing Savoie and others that it could not escape that way.
     
    "They were wrong, but not from a lack of caring," he said.
     
    Matchim said Savoie didn't go out and buy the snake. The Canadian Wildlife Service asked him to take it after the snake was seized in Saint John, and Savoie was never given any money to care for the snake in the subsequent 11 years. 
     
    Matchim says Savoie lived in the apartment with his three-year-old son.
     
    "Would he put his own safety and that of his son at risk?" Matchim asked.
     
    The boys had spent Aug. 4, 2013, petting animals and playing at a farm owned by Savoie's father before a sleepover in Savoie's apartment.
     
    Matchim said the trip to the farm with the children showed Savoie was a good father and guardian and was not cavalier with their safety.
     
    Matchim said the issue here is foreseeability.
     
    "Does omission constitute criminal negligence?" he said.
     
    He said Savoie didn't cover the ventilation pipe because he didn't think there was any chance the snake could exit through the ventilation pipe.
     
    "There is no need to install a barrier if you've come to that conclusion in your mind," he said.
     
    Matchim said there's no proof Savoie was being reckless.
     
    "Accidents happen, but not everyone who causes an accident is guilty of criminal negligence causing death," he said.  
     
    He says if the jury finds reasonable doubt, they must find Savoie not guilty.
     
    Earlier in the day, a snake expert from Florida testified it would have been "common sense" to cover the ventilation pipe after an escape attempt.
     
    Eugene Bessette was the only witness for the defence.
     
    During cross-examination by Crown prosecutor Pierre Roussel, Bessette told the court he was impressed by photos of the snake's enclosure in Savoie's apartment, calling the locked door "very sufficient" security.
     
    Roussel referred to earlier testimony about the snake's escape attempt through a ventilation pipe above the enclosure, and asked what Bessette would have done if there was such an escape attempt at his snake farm.
     
    "I would have made an attempt to rectify the situation," Bessette said.
     
    "You would have covered the opening?" Roussel asked. "You would cover the hole for the safety of the animal and the public?"
     
    "That would be common sense," Bessette said.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    N.B. Criminal Lawyer Wins Back Controversial 'DUI DR' Licence Plates

    N.B. Criminal Lawyer Wins Back Controversial 'DUI DR' Licence Plates
      Wendell Maxwell has practised criminal law — with emphasis on impaired driving cases — for 48 years.

    N.B. Criminal Lawyer Wins Back Controversial 'DUI DR' Licence Plates

    Environment minister seeks UNESCO world heritage site nominations

    GRAND PRE, N.S. — For the first time in more than a decade, Ottawa is asking Canadians to nominate national gems as candidates for UNESCO World Heritage Sites.

    Environment minister seeks UNESCO world heritage site nominations

    Grieving Ontario Mother Of Slain Man Livid, Depressed Over Controversial Plea Deal

    Grieving Ontario Mother Of Slain Man Livid, Depressed Over Controversial Plea Deal
    Wesley Hallam, 29, was killed in 2011 at a drug-fuelled house party in Sault Ste. Marie, Ont., where he was stabbed to death, decapitated and dismembered. 

    Grieving Ontario Mother Of Slain Man Livid, Depressed Over Controversial Plea Deal

    Brampton School Didn't Dash Teen's Acting Dreams, Judge Says In Dismissing Lawsuit

    Brampton School Didn't Dash Teen's Acting Dreams, Judge Says In Dismissing Lawsuit
    The lawsuit filed by Tiffany Peters alleged that negligence on the part of staff at Bramalea Secondary School in Brampton, Ont. led to a knee injury she sustained while taking part on the track and field team.

    Brampton School Didn't Dash Teen's Acting Dreams, Judge Says In Dismissing Lawsuit

    Quebec Zoo Employee In Stable Condition After Being Attacked By Lion

    Quebec Zoo Employee In Stable Condition After Being Attacked By Lion
    A lion at Quebec's Granby Zoo attacked an employee Monday, fracturing her backbone, the head of the facility said. The woman, in her early 20s, was in hospital in stable condition but zoo director Paul Gosselin called her injuries "severe."

    Quebec Zoo Employee In Stable Condition After Being Attacked By Lion

    Canada-Wide Arrest Warrant Issued For Fourth Suspect In Newfoundland Murder

    Canada-Wide Arrest Warrant Issued For Fourth Suspect In Newfoundland Murder
    Investigators say a Canada-wide arrest warrant has been issued for 23-year-old Chesley John Lucas of Paradise on charges of first-degree murder, forcible confinement, robbery and arson.

    Canada-Wide Arrest Warrant Issued For Fourth Suspect In Newfoundland Murder