Close X
Monday, November 25, 2024
ADVT 
National

Police Should Have Said Halifax Man In Chemicals Case Couldn't Make Bomb: Lawyer

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 07 May, 2015 12:37 PM
    HALIFAX — Police should have informed the public they knew a stockpile of chemicals that led to evacuations in two cities lacked key bomb ingredients, says a defence lawyer representing the man who was arrested in the high-profile case.
     
    Mike Taylor was referring Thursday to one of several court exhibits released in the case of 42-year-old Christopher Phillips, who has been charged with uttering threats and possessing a weapon — the hazardous chemical osmium tetroxide. 
     
    Phillips and Taylor briefly appeared in Nova Scotia Supreme Court to confirm a judge-only trial is set for June 1.
     
    An exhibit released to The Canadian Press contains an analysis by forensics expert Melanie Brochu, who wrote that chemicals police found in Phillips' cottage in Grand Desert, N.S., didn't include the ingredients needed for homemade explosives.
     
    "Although some chemicals could be used as reagents to make explosives, I did not see all the requisite precursors typically required to actually make homemade explosives," Brochu wrote in a report entry dated Jan. 22 — the day after Phillips' arrest.
     
    "Advised the incident commander that the labeled chemical products personally observed via live video stream did not corroborate the suspect was making homemade explosives."
     
    The rural community around the cottage was evacuated, as were neighbourhoods in Halifax and the hotel where Phillips was taken into custody in Ottawa.
     
    Chief Supt. Roland Wells said at a news conference on Jan. 23 that the chemicals in Grand Desert were stacked from floor to ceiling and many were unstable and there was "an extreme fire risk" due to the volatility of the chemicals.
     
    The RCMP said in an emailed comment Thursday that Wells didn't know about Brochu's analysis at the time of his news conference, and "the processing of the scene by RCMP and Halifax Fire was not complete until two days later."
     
    "Comments made with respect to the volatility of the chemicals were indicative of the storage state of the chemicals. They were not referencing what could be made by combining them," said the email.
     
    Taylor says the lack of ingredients for bombs should have been conveyed to help reduce public anxieties.
     
    "I absolutely think they should have let the public know that there wasn't that risk," he said.
     
    "It created a lot of unnecessary anxiety. It created a picture of Mr. Phillips and the whole situation that was not accurate."
     
    Phillips has since testified that he owned the chemicals to extract heavy metals and was running a chemical business.
     
    The exhibits also contain an email Phillips wrote to a friend in the United States about how he would like to send him a container of highly toxic osmium tetroxide as "the ultimate Christmas present."
     
    The email says the container would include instructions that it is "to be used only in the event of forceful entry by the police."
     
    The instructions suggest poking a hole in the vial with a stick and throwing "entire box at any police officer that has decided to take up residence on your property."
     
    In the next paragraph, Phillips says he realizes his email could be stored and adds, "and I do ... stress that the box will not be designed to actually be used as a weapon."
     
    Taylor said outside court the email is the key element in the Crown's case, and he will argue strongly it doesn't amount to a criminal offence.
     
    "There are a couple of comments in this email that I can point to that suggest this isn't even close to an actual threat being made by Mr. Phillips," he said.
     
    However, the Crown has argued there are reasonable grounds to continue the case against the former U.S. citizen, who has been in a provincial jail since his arrest.
     
    Phillips was denied bail in a hearing on March 17 due to a lack of suitable guarantor and he remains in jail in Yarmouth, N.S.
     
    Defence lawyers routinely ask for publication bans on bail hearings, which judges must grant upon their request.
     
    But in Phillips' case, Taylor told the judge he did not want such a ban on the exhibits - including the email, and the memo written by Brochu.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Ontario Sex Ed Curriculum: Hundreds Of Kids Stay Home To Protest; 5 Things To Know

    Ontario Sex Ed Curriculum: Hundreds Of Kids Stay Home To Protest; 5 Things To Know
    TORONTO — A parent-led campaign to keep children home from class in protest of Ontario's new sexual-education curriculum gained early traction on Monday as at least one school reported that nearly all of its students were absent.

    Ontario Sex Ed Curriculum: Hundreds Of Kids Stay Home To Protest; 5 Things To Know

    Seniors Filing For Insolvency With Bigger Debts Than Young, Report Finds

    Seniors Filing For Insolvency With Bigger Debts Than Young, Report Finds
    OTTAWA — A new report says seniors and those approaching retirement are making up a growing proportion of those filing for insolvency in Ontario and have bigger debts compared with younger people.

    Seniors Filing For Insolvency With Bigger Debts Than Young, Report Finds

    Crown, Defence Lawyer Haggle Over Evidence At Duffy Trial

    Crown, Defence Lawyer Haggle Over Evidence At Duffy Trial
    OTTAWA — Mike Duffy's trial is taking a short detour as the Crown and defence haggle over a piece of evidence.

    Crown, Defence Lawyer Haggle Over Evidence At Duffy Trial

    Doing The Right Thing Comes At A Cost Harper Tells WW2 Vets At Ve Day Service

    Doing The Right Thing Comes At A Cost Harper Tells WW2 Vets At Ve Day Service
    HOLTEN, Netherlands — Prime Minister Stephen Harper paid tribute to Canada's war dead at a service in the Netherlands this morning.

    Doing The Right Thing Comes At A Cost Harper Tells WW2 Vets At Ve Day Service

    Ottawa To Pay Nunavut More Than $250 Million In Land Claim Lawsuit Settlement

    Ottawa To Pay Nunavut More Than $250 Million In Land Claim Lawsuit Settlement
    IQALUIT, Nunavut — Ottawa will pay Nunavut $256 million as part of a settlement of a longstanding lawsuit. Most of that money will be used to fund training for Inuit to enter the territory's civil service.

    Ottawa To Pay Nunavut More Than $250 Million In Land Claim Lawsuit Settlement

    Voters Go To The Polls On P.E.I., Liberals Seeking Third Straight Majority

    Voters Go To The Polls On P.E.I., Liberals Seeking Third Straight Majority
    CHARLOTTETOWN — Voters on Prince Edward Island will determine the fate today of a premier who has been on the job for just over two months.

    Voters Go To The Polls On P.E.I., Liberals Seeking Third Straight Majority