Close X
Thursday, December 12, 2024
ADVT 
National

Police forces balk at tracking fees imposed by Rogers Communications

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 12 Jan, 2015 10:39 AM

    OTTAWA — The RCMP and many other police forces are refusing to pay new fees imposed by Rogers Communications for helping track suspects through their mobile phones.

    Police say the telecommunications firm is legally obligated to provide such court-ordered services and to cover the cost as part of its duty to society.

    Rogers says while it picks up the tab for most judicially approved requests, in some cases it will charge a minimal fee.

    The quietly simmering dispute underscores long-standing tensions over who should pay when police call on telephone and Internet providers to help investigate cases.

    It began late last May when Rogers wrote to RCMP divisions and other police services across Canada to say it would usher in new fees to law enforcement on Aug. 1 . The fees applied to help in executing warrants for tracking customers' movements through cellphone data, and for production of affidavits certifying records in cases where testimony is required to explain the records in court.

    RCMP officials responsible for covert operations told their superiors in a June briefing note there was no legal basis for the planned fees and that Rogers could be charged under the Criminal Code for failing to comply with a court order if it refused to provide the services unless compensated.

    The note, obtained by The Canadian Press under the Access to Information Act, points to a 2008 Supreme Court of Canada decision in which the judges said companies would generally be expected to comply with court orders on their own dime unless costs became unreasonable.

    In the case at hand, the court said it was not unreasonable for Tele-Mobile Co. to pay annual costs of between $400,000 and $800,000 to comply with production orders.

    The RCMP note suggested that the Canadian Association of Chiefs of Police be asked to issue a collective response to Rogers that "police will not be paying the fees requested."

    The association's board was briefed in late June, and early the next month the chiefs recommended to police services that they not sign "acknowledgment of fees" notices distributed by Rogers.

    "It is the (association's) view that police services throughout Canada should not be required to bear the costs associated with court-ordered activities," the recommendation said. "The demand for these services will only increase as electronic crimes committed over mobile services continues to grow."

    The chiefs interpret the Supreme Court decision as requiring Rogers to "bear the reasonable burdens of compliance with such orders as part of its general corporate responsibility to the community," said Tim Smith, a spokesman for the association.

    Rogers spokesman Kevin Spafford said the company dropped the demand for fees related to affidavits prior to the Aug. 1 changes.

    However, where possible Rogers does recover costs for location tracking of mobile devices, Spafford said.

    "For most court-ordered requests for information, we assume all costs associated with providing a response," he said. "In some cases we charge a minimal fee to recover our costs based on the work required to comply with requests."

    It was up to individual police services to decide whether to sign the Rogers agreements, Smith said.

    However, the association understands that "a vast majority" heeded the recommendation and are not paying the fees, he added.

    Smith stressed that — the current disagreement notwithstanding — police services across Canada "enjoy a positive business relationship" with Rogers.

    Sgt. Greg Cox, an RCMP spokesman, also said there had been "no substantive change" in the force's dealings with Rogers or other telecommunications firms.

    Rogers, the RCMP and the chiefs' association all refused to say how much money the company is requesting under the new fee structure.

    Although they have concerns about the new Rogers fees, the Mounties did pay more than $2 million to telecom firms in 2012-13 in connection with customer information and intercept-related activities, the force says.

    "The RCMP is working with all major telcos to determine sustainability of the current situation and associated costs," Cox said.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Burnaby's Marine Pub Destroyed In Suspicious Fire

    Burnaby's Marine Pub Destroyed In Suspicious Fire
    BURNABY, B.C. — A neighbourhood pub in Burnaby was destroyed in a massive three-alarm fire early Saturday. The cause of the blaze at the Marine Pub is still under investigation but the Burnaby Fire Department says it is suspicious.

    Burnaby's Marine Pub Destroyed In Suspicious Fire

    B.C. Students' Science Project Finally Launches Successfully Into Space From Cape Canaveral

    B.C. Students' Science Project Finally Launches Successfully Into Space From Cape Canaveral
    KAMLOOPS, B.C. — A group of B.C. students has finally put a science project into space after suffering a setback last year. The project was aboard a rocket that successfully blast off from Cape Canaveral in Florida early Saturday morning.

    B.C. Students' Science Project Finally Launches Successfully Into Space From Cape Canaveral

    RCMP Charge Two Brothers With Terrorism Related Charges

    RCMP Charge Two Brothers With Terrorism Related Charges
    An RCMP statement alleges that Ashton Carleton Larmond and Carlos Larmond, both 24, were planning to leave Canada to engage in terrorist activities abroad.

    RCMP Charge Two Brothers With Terrorism Related Charges

    No Winning Tickets Drawn For $50 Million Lotto Max Jackpot

    No Winning Tickets Drawn For $50 Million Lotto Max Jackpot
    There were also two MaxMillions prizes of $1-million each up for grabs, and a winning ticket for one of those prizes was sold somewhere in British Columbia.

    No Winning Tickets Drawn For $50 Million Lotto Max Jackpot

    Twin Brothers Appear In Ottawa Court On Terrorism-related Charges

    Twin Brothers Appear In Ottawa Court On Terrorism-related Charges
    OTTAWA — The lawyer for Ottawa twin brothers charged with terrorism-related offences says he plans to vehemently dispute the charges against them, after the pair appeared in Ottawa court on Saturday via video link.

    Twin Brothers Appear In Ottawa Court On Terrorism-related Charges

    Review Launched, More Penalties Meted Out In Dalhousie University Scandal

    Review Launched, More Penalties Meted Out In Dalhousie University Scandal
    The 13 male dentistry students at Dalhousie University who were allegedly members of a Facebook page where sexually violent content about women was posted will no longer attend classes with the rest of their classmates, the president of the university announced Friday.

    Review Launched, More Penalties Meted Out In Dalhousie University Scandal