Close X
Monday, December 2, 2024
ADVT 
National

Passport redesign just the latest battle in the culture war over Canadian identity

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 19 May, 2023 10:36 AM
  • Passport redesign just the latest battle in the culture war over Canadian identity

The government hit delete on Terry Fox.

That's how Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre put it when he posted a nearly five-minute video on Twitter condemning the Liberal government for its passport redesign, while standing in front of the National War Memorial, another image removed from future Canadian passports.

That video, which calls the passport Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's "colouring book" because it features images of a squirrel eating a nut and a man raking leaves, reached nearly a million people in a week, far exceeding Poilievre's other recent videos.

"This is troll politics," said Jason Hannan, an associate professor at the University of Winnipeg in the department of rhetoric, writing and communications.

"It’s not like Canadian identity has ever hinged on passport design. It's not like Canadians ever went to bed at night thinking happy thoughts about passports. It's an utterly fabricated issue."

The Liberals aren't the first to "delete" marketing, branding or advertising work done by previous governments, said Alex Marland, a professor of political science at Memorial University of Newfoundland who studies political marketing.

"The reality is that all governments do these things and shape countries in their own image whenever they can," he said.

"The general pattern is the Liberal party tends to take Canada in a more independent direction, and Conservatives tend to take Canada in a more historical direction, in a history as they perceive it."

Marland said a specific portrait of Queen Elizabeth II would hang in the foreign affairs office when Conservatives were in power, and be replaced with artwork by a Quebec artist when the Liberals took office.

Then there was former prime minister Stephen Harper, who repainted the government plane red, white and blue with "True North Strong and Free" written on it, and put "royal" back into the names of the Royal Canadian Air Force and Royal Canadian Navy.

The Liberals have been involved in changing the coat of arms, the national anthem and the Canadian flag to the current versions.

While it's not new for politicians to attack government decisions, Poilievre has framed the passport redesign as a culture war issue, suggesting that Canadian history, identity, values and iconic figures are at stake, said Hannan, who's writing a book on the topic.

Hannan said a culture war is a battle for the heart and soul of a nation. The notion exploded in Canada during the COVID-19 pandemic with the politicization of masks and vaccines.

"It's a struggle to define what we stand for, what we should be striving for. It's a struggle over what it means to belong to this or that country, over what it means to be Canadian, who we are and who we're not," Hannan said.

"So if you can control that conversation, you can wield considerable political power."

Hannan said this can lead to a harmful and toxic culture, like what has been seen in the United States in recent years.

"It's severely corrosive to the culture of democracy because it elevates these fake issues over real and substantive issues," he said.

"Unfortunately, when you don’t have a meaningful political vision for a better society — when you can’t actually say what it is that you want for Canada other than vague ideas and meaningless talk about 'freedom' — then you stoke fear and outrage and hatred."

He said if politicians are successful in stoking that fear, they can "bring people who would ordinarily never talk to each other … in a kind of unison, shouting against the enemy."

But given that the next government can bring in its own redesign, some say the outrage is overblown.

"These things are not forever. We're not redesigning our Parliament buildings that will be built for 100 years," said David Soberman, a professor of marketing at the University of Toronto.

 

MORE National ARTICLES

B.C. proposes six new ridings, expands to 93 seats

B.C. proposes six new ridings, expands to 93 seats
The proposed increase of six new electoral districts includes four in the Lower Mainland in Vancouver, Burnaby, Surrey and Langley, one on Vancouver Island in Langford and another in Kelowna in the B.C. Interior.

B.C. proposes six new ridings, expands to 93 seats

Man arrested after stabbing death on B.C. bus

Man arrested after stabbing death on B.C. bus
Seventeen-year-old Ethan Bespflug was killed on a bus in Surrey, B.C., last Tuesday. Police say they don't believe the attack was random and they hope to have an update on possible charges soon.

Man arrested after stabbing death on B.C. bus

Review blames weather for Vancouver airport mess

Review blames weather for Vancouver airport mess
The report says two dozen aircraft with passengers aboard waited up to 11 hours on the tarmac because there were no gates available, while passengers were given inaccurate information and communication from the airport authority was inadequate.

Review blames weather for Vancouver airport mess

Man beaten by Vancouver police kind, loyal: sister

Man beaten by Vancouver police kind, loyal: sister
Myles Gray, 33, died on Aug. 13, 2015, following a beating involving seven officers that sent him into cardiac arrest and left him with a broken eye socket, a partially dislocated jaw, a crushed voice box and a ruptured testicle and other injuries.

Man beaten by Vancouver police kind, loyal: sister

PSAC sets strike deadline for federal government

PSAC sets strike deadline for federal government
The Public Service Alliance of Canada says some 155,000 employees are prepared to walk off the job beginning Wednesday, including 35,000 workers from the Canada Revenue Agency. The biggest sticking point in the talks appears to be pay, with the union calling for raises to keep up with inflation and the rising cost of living.

PSAC sets strike deadline for federal government

CBC should exit Twitter over new label: expert

CBC should exit Twitter over new label: expert
The executive director of the Master of Public Policy in Digital Society at McMaster University says an exit from Twitter would be an opportunity for CBC to refresh the public's understanding of how its funded and maintain editorial independence.

CBC should exit Twitter over new label: expert