Thursday, March 28, 2024
ADVT 
National

Parts Of Prostitution Law Found Unconstitutional, Ontario Judge Rules

The Canadian Press, 21 Feb, 2020 09:55 PM

    TORONTO - Significant parts of Canada's prostitution law that bans advertising in the sex trade or making money from sexual services are unconstitutional, an Ontario court judge ruled on Friday in a case involving a couple who ran an escort agency.

     

    In addition, Judge Thomas McKay said the ban on procuring sexual services also violates the charter.

     

    Because the judgment is from a provincial court, it is not binding, and the law remains in effect unless an appellate court sides with McKay in the event of an appeal.

     

    Nevertheless, a lawyer for one of the accused praised what he called the precedential decision.

     

    "Today is a good day for the safety and protection of sex workers," lawyer James Lockyer said in an interview.

     

    At issue are parts of the law enacted by the former Conservative government under Stephen Harper in November 2014 after the previous law had been struck down. The new law criminalized the purchase of sex, and communication for that purpose. It also outlawed related advertising.

     

    "We argued the new law made it even less safe for (sex workers)," Lockyer said.

     

    In this case, police charged Hamad Anwar and Tiffany Harvey, of London, Ont., for running an escort agency known as Fantasy World Escorts. Their business employed several adult women in the city.

     

    Evidence was that the couple advertised their business and used their website to recruit both new clients and new employees, promising an average salary of $2,500 to $5,000 a week, paid annual vacation, benefits and help with tuition and book payments for students. Anwar set the fee schedule for clients and the business also maintained a code of ethics for clientele.

     

    The couple challenged the constitutionality of the legislation under which they were charged. Among other things, they argued the law prevented sex workers from using third parties for protection, and stopped them from forming their own associations to look out for one another.

     

    They also argued the law violated their freedom of expression and their right to be free from unreasonable government interference.

     

    While the prosecution conceded the law infringes on the rights of those in the sex trade, it argued the violations were justified in a free and democratic society. It maintained the law aims to reduce prostitution while striking a balance for sex worker freedoms.

     

    McKay, who noted the bill treats sellers of their own sexual services as victims, disagreed with the prosecution. After hearing eight days of evidence at the trial in Kitchener, Ont., he found the three provisions did violate the charter and could not otherwise be justified.

     

    The judge found a wide variety of reasons that adults engage in sex work, with money a primary motivator. Many of them are self-employed or work independently much of the time, he found. While some third parties might be abusive partners or predators, most aren't, McKay said. They do administration, offer training and support, and security, he said.

     

    "Canadian research suggests that coercion and control of sex workers by third parties is not pervasive."

     

    The judge found that the rules against procuring further isolates already marginalized or inexperienced sex workers, who are "effectively prevented" from approaching their more experienced peers for advice or support. The third-party ban, McKay said, makes it all but impossible for most sex workers to work co-operatively with others, whether for health and safety reasons or sharing staff.

     

    It was not immediately clear if the prosecution would seek to appeal.

     

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Ombudsman Calls For National Consultations, Plan For Supporting Veterans

    Ombudsman Calls For National Consultations, Plan For Supporting Veterans
    OTTAWA - The watchdog for Canadian veterans is calling for nationwide consultations to develop a much-needed vision and plan to support veterans and their families with all their needs.

    Ombudsman Calls For National Consultations, Plan For Supporting Veterans

    Trudeau Says Time For Blockades To End, Indigenous Leaders To Work With Government

    OTTAWA - Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says after two weeks, barricades on rail lines and other major transportation routes have to come down.    

    Trudeau Says Time For Blockades To End, Indigenous Leaders To Work With Government

    Ottawa, Province, First Nations Sign Deal To Protect Southern Mountain Caribou

    VANCOUVER - The federal and British Columbia governments and two First Nations have signed a long-awaited agreement to protect the endangered southern mountain caribou herds.    

    Ottawa, Province, First Nations Sign Deal To Protect Southern Mountain Caribou

    MISSING: Richmond RCMP Request Public's Help Locating 16-Year-Old JATINDER SINGH

    Richmond RCMP is requesting the public's assistance in locating a missing Richmond resident. 

    MISSING: Richmond RCMP Request Public's Help Locating 16-Year-Old JATINDER SINGH

    Over 3,000 Tonne Gold Mine Found in UP's Sonbhadra, 5 Times That of India's Reserves

    According to current prices, the value of this amount of gold could be around Rs 12 lakh crore. Sonbhadra is counted among the most backward districts of the country.

    Over 3,000 Tonne Gold Mine Found in UP's Sonbhadra, 5 Times That of India's Reserves

    Vancouver Police Crack Down On Property Crime, Arrest 26 Suspects In Three Months

    An ongoing Vancouver Police project targeting property crime in downtown Vancouver has resulted in 150 criminal charges recommended to Crown counsel over three months.

    Vancouver Police Crack Down On Property Crime, Arrest 26 Suspects In Three Months

    PrevNext