Close X
Thursday, October 10, 2024
ADVT 
National

Parliamentary Budget Officer says budget for Arctic patrol ships 'insufficient'

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 28 Oct, 2014 10:52 AM
  • Parliamentary Budget Officer says budget for Arctic patrol ships 'insufficient'

OTTAWA - There's a fresh spat brewing between the Parliament's top bean counter and the Conservative government, this time over Arctic patrol ships.

Parliamentary Budget Officer Jean-Denis Frechette said there's little chance the government can afford to buy between six and eight vessels on a budget of $3.1 billion.

Frechette said that's only enough money to pay for four Arctic patrol ships — and even then, there's only a 50 per cent chance the vessels get built on that budget.

The number of ships could drop to three if there is a delay of more than a year, he added.

"PBO analysis suggests that the current budget will be insufficient to procure six to eight (Arctic/offshore patrol ships) as planned," the PBO said in a report released Tuesday.

"Rather, it is more likely that, if there are no delays, the current budget will allow for four ships to be built. However, any delay over a year would mean that the budget would likely only be sufficient to build three ships."

Public Works Minister Diane Finley's office shot back, saying the PBO got its numbers wrong.

"The numbers provided by the PBO are based on erroneous data, rough cost estimates of international vessels with varied capabilities and derived using inaccurate specifications," Finley spokesman Marcel Poulin wrote in an email.

"In fact, when explaining one of his assumptions the PBO states that he 'was unable to locate reliable, sufficiently contemporary Canadian data on an acquisition of this nature.'"

Frechette and assistant PBO Mostafa Askari said that's because the government refused to give them all the information they needed to do their work.

The Department of National Defence refused to give the PBO a statement of operating requirements for the ships, Askari said. The PBO requested the document under the Access to Information Act, he added, but what it got back was heavily redacted.

"The department made its own judgement about what we are supposed to get at PBO," Frechette said.

"Because it's not financial or economic data, they consider that as not being part of the mandate. We dispute that. We disagree with that.

"Having the blueprint of a ship is part of the information that you require to do an economic or budget analysis of the acquisition for Arctic offshore ships."

Industry and military sources have told The Canadian Press that the government has scaled back its original plan to buy between six and eight vessels, choosing instead to buy five with an option for a sixth.

But the president of Irving Shipbuilding, which was selected in 2011 to build the ships, said the federal government has not changed its mind. The deadline to sign a deal to begin constructing the vessels is the end of the year.

Defence and industry experts have said it's not unusual for the government to scale back large procurement projects to reduce costs.

The PBO said if the government wants at least six ships, the budget would need to be increased by $470 million.

This is not the first disagreement between the government and the PBO.

Former PBO Kevin Page often found himself at odds with the Conservatives during his tenure. He once tried to challenge the government in court to turn over information on its cost-cutting programs. The Federal Court sidestepped the question of whether the government can deny information to the PBO.

Frechette said he has a "different relationship" with the government.

"It's a different style, I'm a different person," he said.

"We do have, I think, with many departments a better relationship. It's not a matter of better or worse or whatever. It's really just a different approach that we're having. But we still have some difficulties.

"This is a good example of, you know, the department not providing the information."

MORE National ARTICLES

Most who contest benefits decisions win their appeals, tribunal says

Most who contest benefits decisions win their appeals, tribunal says
The majority of ailing Canadians who have appealed an initial decision to deny them Canada Pension Plan disability benefits have won their appeals, the country's new social security tribunal says.

Most who contest benefits decisions win their appeals, tribunal says

What did you just call me? Harper tags Trudeau as an elite in run-up to election

What did you just call me? Harper tags Trudeau as an elite in run-up to election
In the communications arsenal the Conservatives are building against Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau, the word "elite" is proving to be one of the most popular put-downs.

What did you just call me? Harper tags Trudeau as an elite in run-up to election

Harper draws parallels between Taliban and Islamist militants in Iraq, Syria

Harper draws parallels between Taliban and Islamist militants in Iraq, Syria
Stephen Harper is drawing parallels between the Islamist militants who have seized a swath of territory across Iraq and Syria and the Taliban insurgents who controlled much of Afghanistan before the U.S.-led invasion.

Harper draws parallels between Taliban and Islamist militants in Iraq, Syria

Vancouver Island marina to reopen but beach still barred due to contamination

Vancouver Island marina to reopen but beach still barred due to contamination
A popular marina and boat launch on Vancouver Island will reopen next week — temporarily — after being closed more than a year ago because of toxic contamination.

Vancouver Island marina to reopen but beach still barred due to contamination

Port authority OKs controversial coal-shipping facility in Metro Vancouver

Port authority OKs controversial coal-shipping facility in Metro Vancouver
Metro Vancouver’ port authority has approved construction of a controversial coal-shipping facility in a major marine terminal.

Port authority OKs controversial coal-shipping facility in Metro Vancouver

New Brunswick Liberal leader hypocritical on energy, Premier David Alward says

New Brunswick Liberal leader hypocritical on energy, Premier David Alward says
Premier David Alward strove to clearly set apart his position on energy from that of his main rival as the New Brunswick election campaign began Thursday, accusing Liberal Leader Brian Gallant of being hypocritical on the issue.

New Brunswick Liberal leader hypocritical on energy, Premier David Alward says