Close X
Thursday, November 14, 2024
ADVT 
National

Ontario Woman's Facebook Message Undermines Sex-assault Conviction Against Ex-Husband

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 04 Nov, 2016 12:51 PM
    TORONTO — A seven-year-old Facebook message has scuttled a conviction against a man accused by his ex-wife of sexually assaulting and threatening to kill her.
     
    In a decision released Friday, Ontario's top court said evidence about the message, had it been allowed at trial, could have affected the guilty verdict handed down to the man, who can only be identified as A.B.
     
    "The message was allegedly sent about midpoint in the time frame of the sexual assault allegations," the Appeal Court said in its decision. "It would not be unfair to say that the message recounted several incidents of sexual activity between the appellant and complainant, and made it clear that the sexual activity was consensual on the complainant's part."
     
    Police charged A.B. with sexually assaulting the woman after they had separated and he was living with a new partner. The complainant said her ex had forced himself on her three times, but he insisted the sex was entirely consensual.
     
    To bolster his position, he raised the issue of the Facebook message sent in February 2009, which he said was sent by his former spouse to his new partner and now wife.
     
    At trial in late 2011 in Barrie, Ont., the complainant maintained she had no memory of sending the message, and further testified she didn't think she had done so. In any event, after the prosecution objected on procedural grounds, Superior Court Justice Guy Di Tomaso ruled against further cross-examination and directed jurors to set aside the evidence they had heard about the post.
     
    The jury convicted A.B., prompting him to turn to the higher court.
     
     
    Appeal Court submissions show an expert forensic analysis of a computer belonging to A.B.'s new wife turned up the relevant message on her Facebook account. Its date and content had not been manipulated. In addition, the message was found to have come from a computer address associated with the complainant's brother.
     
    "When interviewed about the results of the investigation, the complainant acknowledged having sent the message," the Appeal Court noted.
     
    On appeal, A.B. asked to be allowed to introduce the Facebook posting and the results of the forensic analysis as fresh evidence along with his ex-wife's admission that she had, in fact, sent it. The prosecution did not object.
     
    "The proposed fresh evidence is relevant to a potentially decisive issue — the complainant's credibility on the issue of consent — which was, after all, the only scontroverted element of the offence at trial," the Appeal Court ruled.
     
    "The message had impeachment value as a statement inconsistent with the complainant's claim of non-consent asserted at trial."
     
     
    Both sides in the dispute agreed the new evidence was believable, and, the prosecution acknowledged, could have affected the verdict if jurors had access to the information.
     
    As a result, the Appeal Court agreed to allow the message evidence, quashed the conviction and ordered a new trial. At the request of both prosecution and defence, the court then stayed its new trial order, essentially putting an end to the case.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Calgary Police Officers Face Criminal Charges In Arrest That Injured Man

    CALGARY — A unit that reviews police actions in Alberta is alleging that officers broke a man's ribs and caused his lung to collapse and lied about him resisting arrest.

    Calgary Police Officers Face Criminal Charges In Arrest That Injured Man

    Calgary's Varun Aurora Found Guilty Of Role In $23 Million Fraud But Not Going To Jail

    Calgary's Varun Aurora Found Guilty Of Role In $23 Million Fraud But Not Going To Jail
    He has been sentenced to two years less a day, to be served in the community.

    Calgary's Varun Aurora Found Guilty Of Role In $23 Million Fraud But Not Going To Jail

    Woman's Body Found In Burnaby B.C., Homicide Team Investigating

    Police say they are investigating a homicide in Burnaby, B.C.

    Woman's Body Found In Burnaby B.C., Homicide Team Investigating

    Elderly Woman Found Dead In Calgary Home, Police Charge 85-Yr-Old Husband With Murder

    Elderly Woman Found Dead In Calgary Home, Police Charge 85-Yr-Old Husband With Murder
    An 85-year-old Calgary man has been charged with second-degree murder after his wife was found dead early Tuesday. Insp. Don Coleman says police got a 911 call from the victim's husband.

    Elderly Woman Found Dead In Calgary Home, Police Charge 85-Yr-Old Husband With Murder

    Japan Denies Being 'Black Hole' For Children Abducted By Estranged Parent

    Japan Denies Being 'Black Hole' For Children Abducted By Estranged Parent
    In a statement, the Japanese Ministry of Foreign Affairs said its top priority is to protect the interests of the children involved in such disputes.

    Japan Denies Being 'Black Hole' For Children Abducted By Estranged Parent

    Calgary Man, 85, Charged In Wife's Death Likely To Have Dementia

    Calgary Man, 85, Charged In Wife's Death Likely To Have Dementia
    CALGARY — Loved ones say a 85-year-old Calgary man accused of murdering his 80-year-old wife had been suffering from dementia for years.

    Calgary Man, 85, Charged In Wife's Death Likely To Have Dementia