Thursday, March 28, 2024
ADVT 
National

Ontario Appeal Court Hearing Case Of Man With HIV Convicted Of Sex Assault

The Canadian Press, 12 Feb, 2020 08:27 PM

    TORONTO - A man who is HIV-positive was convicted of three counts of aggravated sexual assault based on a legal standard that isn't in line with scientific evidence, his lawyers argued before Ontario's top court on Wednesday.

     

    They are requesting that the Court of Appeal for Ontario overturn the three convictions or order a new trial for the man, identified by the initials N.G., based on evidence that proper condom use is enough to prevent transmission of the virus.

     

    "It's clear the needle can be moved," Wayne Cunningham told the three-judge panel. "What we propose in this case is that fresh new evidence moves that needle."

     

    In the trial, which ended in November 2017, court heard N.G. used condoms in sexual encounters with three women who consented without knowing his HIV status.

     

    As it stands, common law holds that a person with a low concentration of HIV in the blood does not need to inform sexual partners of their status if they use a condom.

     

    The trial judge found condoms weren't enough in N.G.'s case because he did not have a low viral load, raising potential doubt about the possibility of transmission despite wearing a condom.

     

    Cunningham argued Wednesday that new evidence shows condoms are enough to prevent transmission and the common law should reflect that.

     

    He argued a person with HIV using a condom should be obligated to inform their partner only if and when that contraceptive fails.

     

    But Crown attorney Grace Choi argued that takes the wrong approach to the law.

     

    "Whether there is a realistic possibility of HIV transmission should be a forward-looking estimate," she said, likening the approach to that of criminal law surrounding drunk driving and improper gun storage. In those cases, the risky behaviour itself is the crime, not the outcome of that behaviour, she said.

     

    Improper condom use is more common than some might like to acknowledge, Choi said, and it's seldom on purpose.

     

    "Human beings, being human, make mistakes," she said.

     

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Mounties Looking For Missing 61-Year-Old Woman Monica Winter And Her Dog

    Police immediately began a search and later confirmed she was last seen on February 7, 2020, leaving from work in the 1200-block of West Broadway Avenue in Vancouver.    

    Mounties Looking For Missing 61-Year-Old Woman Monica Winter And Her Dog

    Man Arrested On 2 Outstanding Warrants Faces 2 New Charges In Richmond

    Man Arrested On 2 Outstanding Warrants Faces 2 New Charges In Richmond
    The male was identified as Coleton SZALAY. SZALAY had a Canada-wide warrant stemming from a robbery out of Vancouver as well as a warrant for theft under $5,000 out of Richmond.  

    Man Arrested On 2 Outstanding Warrants Faces 2 New Charges In Richmond

    Pipeline Protests Hit B.C. Legislature And Canada's Rail Network

    Hundreds of protesters blocked the entrances to the British Columbia legislature on Tuesday as demonstrations in support of Indigenous hereditary chiefs who oppose a pipeline project continued to flare across the country.

    Pipeline Protests Hit B.C. Legislature And Canada's Rail Network

    Provincial Health Officer Says Four People With Coronavirus In B.C. Doing Well

    Dr. Bonnie Henry says the individuals in the Vancouver region are being monitored by health professionals and three of them are living in a home with others.

    Provincial Health Officer Says Four People With Coronavirus In B.C. Doing Well

    Changes To Popular Child Care Fund To Maximize Spaces

    Changes To Popular Child Care Fund To Maximize Spaces
    In the past 15 months, the Province has supported the fastest creation of licensed child care spaces in B.C.’s history.

    Changes To Popular Child Care Fund To Maximize Spaces

    Pattullo Bridge Replacement Will Mean Safer, Easier, Toll-free Commutes

    The contract for the Pattullo Bridge replacement has been awarded, creating good jobs and training opportunities for workers who will help build the toll-free crossing to better connect communities in the Lower Mainland.    

    Pattullo Bridge Replacement Will Mean Safer, Easier, Toll-free Commutes