Close X
Tuesday, November 12, 2024
ADVT 
National

Omar Khadr Bail Application A 'violation' Of His U.s. Plea Deal, Ottawa Says

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 17 Mar, 2015 02:58 PM
    TORONTO — Canadian courts have no authority to grant Omar Khadr bail while he appeals his war-crimes conviction in the United States but should refuse to release him even if they do have the power, the federal government argues in a new legal brief.
     
    Allowing Khadr out, Ottawa says in its filings, would undermine public confidence in the justice system, subvert international law, and damage Canada's relations with the U.S.
     
    The brief prepared in response to Khadr's bail application notes that he pleaded guilty before a U.S. military commission in Guantanamo Bay and waived his right to appeal the conviction. It also states his transfer to Canada to serve out his sentence was done under a treaty that required the American legal proceedings to have been final.
     
    His bail application — to be heard March 24 and 25 in Edmonton — constitutes a "direct violation" of his plea deal, Ottawa says.
     
    "His transfer was premised upon an agreement that Canada would continue enforcement of this sentence," according to the brief, filed with the Court of Queen's Bench.
     
    "Unless and until this sentence is varied or vacated by an American court of competent jurisdiction, Canada…must continue to enforce it."
     
    Countries may be loathe to return Canadian convicts if they know bail is a possibility, the brief adds.
     
    In October 2010, Khadr admitted to five war crimes — including murder in violation of the law of war — committed as a 15-year-old in Afghanistan in July 2002. In return, he was handed an eight-year sentence on top of the eight years he had already spent in pretrial custody.
     
    He transferred to Canada in September 2012 under the International Transfer of Offenders Act and is incarcerated in Innisfail, Alta.
     
    Now 28, the Toronto-born Khadr has since said he only pleaded guilty to get out of Guantanamo given that he faced indefinite detention even if he had been acquitted.
     
    Khadr's stalled challenge also argues the widely discredited military commission had no right to try him given that what he pleaded guilty to were not crimes under international or U.S. law — a view supported by several legal experts and even some American courts. He also says Washington failed to give his appeal waiver any legal effect.
     
    As a result, he says, his U.S. war crimes appeal stands a good chance of success — if it ever gets heard. While Ottawa says it would be inappropriate to weigh in on that point, it does say Canadian courts have no basis on which to consider the merits of his argument.
     
    Khadr also insists the Alberta court does have jurisdiction to hear his bail application because the transfer act calls for his sentence to be administered under Canadian law. His filing describes him as a "model prisoner" who has support from an array of professionals.
     
    While Conservative cabinet ministers have consistently branded Khadr a hardened, dangerous terrorist, the government's legal brief makes no such assertion.
     
    It does, however, note that Khadr's conviction includes the equivalent of first-degree murder — the hand-grenade death of U.S. special forces soldier Sgt. Chris Speer — for which bail is rarely granted.
     
    "This court must consider the seriousness of the offences to which the applicant has pled guilty as well as the facts underlying those offences that he has agreed to be true," the brief states.
     
    Khadr has also applied for parole — to be heard in June.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Loved Ones, Troops Say Goodbye To 'Drew,' A Canadian Soldier Killed In Iraq

    Loved Ones, Troops Say Goodbye To 'Drew,' A Canadian Soldier Killed In Iraq
    OTTAWA — A huge Canadian flag snapped in the wind Saturday outside an Ottawa cathedral where loved ones and dozens of uniformed soldiers said their final goodbyes to the soldier who was killed a week ago in Iraq.

    Loved Ones, Troops Say Goodbye To 'Drew,' A Canadian Soldier Killed In Iraq

    B.C. Constable And Colleagues Who Investigated Him Broke Rules: Adjudicator

    B.C. Constable And Colleagues Who Investigated Him Broke Rules: Adjudicator
    VICTORIA — A police complaint adjudicator has ruled against a Vancouver police officer who was accused of corrupt practice and improper disclosure of information.

    B.C. Constable And Colleagues Who Investigated Him Broke Rules: Adjudicator

    Police Identify Surrey Truck Driver As Suspect In Homeless Pedestrian's Hit-And-Run Death

    Police Identify Surrey Truck Driver As Suspect In Homeless Pedestrian's Hit-And-Run Death
    SURREY, B.C. — RCMP have identified a truck driver believed to be responsible for the hit-and-run death of a pedestrian in Surrey, B.C.

    Police Identify Surrey Truck Driver As Suspect In Homeless Pedestrian's Hit-And-Run Death

    Witness To Deadly B.C. Boat Crash Recalls Tears From Man On Trial

    Witness To Deadly B.C. Boat Crash Recalls Tears From Man On Trial
    KAMLOOPS, B.C. — A man whose speedboat crashed on a B.C. lake cradled the head of a dying houseboat operator and cried as he waited for help to arrive, a witness has testified.

    Witness To Deadly B.C. Boat Crash Recalls Tears From Man On Trial

    Cpl. Cirillo's Death Spurred Benefit Changes For Injured Reservists: Kenney

    The killing of a soldier as he stood guard at the National War Memorial spurred Ottawa to fill a gap in the benefit program for reservists who are injured during military service, putting the part-timers on equal financial terms with regular members of the Canadian Forces, the defence minister said Friday.

    Cpl. Cirillo's Death Spurred Benefit Changes For Injured Reservists: Kenney

    Quebec Woman In Hijab Controversy Rejects Money Raised Through Crowdfunding

    Quebec Woman In Hijab Controversy Rejects Money Raised Through Crowdfunding
    MONTREAL — A Quebec woman who was refused her day in court because she was wearing a hijab has said no thanks to $47,000 raised on her behalf through a crowdfunding campaign.

    Quebec Woman In Hijab Controversy Rejects Money Raised Through Crowdfunding