Close X
Thursday, November 28, 2024
ADVT 
National

Oilsands Being Left In The Ground Is Just A Matter Of Fact, Experts Say

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 13 Aug, 2015 02:01 PM
    EDMONTON — The furor over a New Democrat candidate's remarks about leaving Alberta's oilsands in the ground reflects how poorly the issue is understood, say energy experts.
     
    To many, Toronto Centre candidate Linda McQuaig's recent statement is just the simple fact of the matter. 
     
    "The shock is that anyone would be shocked by this," said Mark Jaccard, an environmental economist at Simon Fraser University.
     
    Jaccard, who recently signed a letter with 100 scientific colleagues calling for a moratorium on new oilsands development, said Prime Minister Stephen Harper's goals for emission reductions preclude complete development of the massive resource.
     
    Harper has agreed with a G7 goal of up to 70 per cent greenhouse gas cuts by 2050 and a carbon-free economy by the end of the century.
     
    But estimates suggest the oilsands hold about 168 billion barrels. At current production of about two million barrels a day, that's 230 years worth of emissions.
     
    Jaccard said Harper's G7 promise automatically shuts in bitumen — unless massive costs are paid by the rest of society.
     
    "Let's say you kept oilsands frozen at its current output level," he said.  "(That means) you can't have any coal-fired power generation in Canada. You've got to convert about two-thirds of the vehicle stock to plug-in hybrid electrics and any kind of large trucks have to be on biodiesel."
     
    And the more oilsands production increases, the more carbon has to come out of the rest of the economy.
     
    "You could expand the oilsands a bit if the rest of us went to zero emissions," he said. "It would be insane, but it would be possible."
     
    Or the costs of keeping emissions in check could be borne by industry, said Allan Fogwill of the Canadian Energy Research Institute, an independent research group. Greater energy efficiency or techno-fixes such as carbon capture and storage could reduce Canada's overall carbon footprint and still allow for oilsands expansion.
     
    "We have the technical solutions available to go down any path," he said. "The limiting factor is how much those solutions cost."
     
    That limiting factor may be as important as government policy, said Erin Flanagan of the clean energy think-tank Pembina Institute.  
     
    She points to research suggesting oil prices are likely to remain below the cost of production for new oilsands projects well into the next decade. By then, markets may have changed permanently.
     
    "Will they come out of the ground or won't they come out of the ground? That question is being answered already by global oil markets," she said.
     
    The Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers declined to comment during the election. A spokesman pointed to 2012 research that suggested burning the entire economic oilsands resource would increase global temperatures by 0.03 C.
     
    McQuaig's point has been made before.
     
    In 2008, a report from the National Roundtable on the Environment and the Economy — a Harper-appointed body the government later shut down — said "research indicates that the only option to attain deep emission reductions is to reduce industrial output in some sectors, notably oilsands and mining."
     
    Still, her remarks prompted a political back-and-forth between New Democrats and Conservatives that lasted days.
     
    Time to get real, said Jaccard.
     
    Even Saudi Arabia has begun to acknowledge some of its hydrocarbons will remain undeveloped, he said.
     
    "It's kind of like we're in a dialogue in Canada that reminds me of Saudi Arabia 20 years ago."
     
    Flanagan said governments need to think about mitigating risks in a changing world.
     
    "The level of fanfare around these comments is really troubling. It shows we're not ready to have that mature conversation."

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Sask. Gov Wraps Up Public Consultations On Farmland Ownership Restrictions

    Sask. Gov Wraps Up Public Consultations On Farmland Ownership Restrictions
    Saskatchewan's agriculture minister says almost all options are on the table as the government considers the future of farmland ownership restrictions in the province.

    Sask. Gov Wraps Up Public Consultations On Farmland Ownership Restrictions

    Man Who Found Knife Blade In Back Three Years After Stabbing Files Lawsuit

    Man Who Found Knife Blade In Back Three Years After Stabbing Files Lawsuit
    YELLOWKNIFE — A man from the Northwest Territories has filed a lawsuit against health officials claiming they failed to find a knife blade buried in his back for three years.

    Man Who Found Knife Blade In Back Three Years After Stabbing Files Lawsuit

    Judge allows sailors charged in sex assault to return to U.K. until trial

    Judge allows sailors charged in sex assault to return to U.K. until trial
    HALIFAX — A Nova Scotia Supreme Court judge has ruled three British sailors charged with a sexual assault in Halifax can return to the United Kingdom while on bail.

    Judge allows sailors charged in sex assault to return to U.K. until trial

    NDP wastes little time connecting return of Duffy trial to campaign trail

    NDP wastes little time connecting return of Duffy trial to campaign trail
    OTTAWA — The NDP wasted little time Wednesday in using the return of Mike Duffy as political leverage against the Conservatives, while Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau seemed to want to wash his hands of it.

    NDP wastes little time connecting return of Duffy trial to campaign trail

    Dozens Drop Out Of 'biased' Energy Board Review Of Trans Mountain Pipeline

    Dozens Drop Out Of 'biased' Energy Board Review Of Trans Mountain Pipeline
    Dozens of participants have dropped out of the controversial National Energy Board review of Kinder Morgan's proposed Trans Mountain pipeline expansion, saying they can no longer support a "biased" and "unfair" process.

    Dozens Drop Out Of 'biased' Energy Board Review Of Trans Mountain Pipeline

    Class Action Lawsuit Alleges Abuse At Ontario Schools For The Deaf

    Class Action Lawsuit Alleges Abuse At Ontario Schools For The Deaf
    A Toronto man alleges he was abused for years at Ontario schools for the deaf and has launched a class action lawsuit on behalf of other former students against the provincial government.

    Class Action Lawsuit Alleges Abuse At Ontario Schools For The Deaf