Close X
Thursday, October 31, 2024
ADVT 
National

Nova Scotia law society defends decision to bar students from proposed school

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 18 Dec, 2014 10:30 AM

    HALIFAX — The Nova Scotia Barristers' Society has the authority to deny accreditation to graduates from a Christian university in British Columbia that requires students to abstain from sex outside heterosexual marriage, a lawyer for the self-regulating body told a court hearing Thursday.

    Marjorie Hickey told the Nova Scotia Supreme Court that the law society draws its authority from a section in the Legal Profession Act that says the purpose of the society is to "uphold and protect the public interest in the practice of law."

    Hickey told the judicial review hearing that the law society has broader powers than just overseeing the qualifications and conduct of its members.

    She went on to say that the law society imposed the ban on articling students from a proposed law school at Trinity Western University in Langley, B.C., because its requirement regarding heterosexual marriage represents unlawful discrimination against gays and lesbians under the charter and violates the Nova Scotia Human Rights Act.

    "What the barristers' society is doing is saying that a law degree ... cannot be from an institution that endorses unlawful discrimination," she told Judge Jamie Campbell.

    Hickey said that when the law society made its decision back in April, the move marked the culmination of a comprehensive consultation process that included many briefs from those in support of the school.

    She also said it was important to remember that the law society has implemented many reforms that have focused on eliminating discrimination in the justice system. Those changes include measures aimed at eliminating barriers for "historically disadvantaged groups."

    She said the law society has also done its best to reach out to the lesbian, gay, bisexual, transsexual and queer communities.

    The university's so-called community covenant, which all students are required to sign, stands opposed to the law society's core values, she said.

    Earlier this week, a lawyer for the university told the court the law society overstepped its jurisdiction when it decided to ban graduates from the bar admission program unless the school dropped the requirement.

    Brian Casey said the law society has jurisdiction over its membership in Nova Scotia, nothing more.

    He suggested the court should overturn the law society's regulation on the grounds that it infringes on future students' charter rights of freedom of religion, freedom of expression and freedom of association.

    Casey said the barristers' society has no authority to refuse a student because of the school's conduct.

    He argued that the law society had failed to produce evidence that the proposed law school — to open in 2016 — would harm anyone in Nova Scotia.

    However, Campbell said it appeared the law society was arguing that if it accepted articling students from a school that promoted discriminatory behaviour, that could lead to stress in Nova Scotia's gay community.

    Casey said there was no proof of that before the court.

    The school bills itself as the largest, independent Christian liberal arts institution in Canada with about 4,000 students.

    Earlier this month, the British Columbia government revoked its support for the law school, saying the university can't enrol students in the program because of the "uncertainty" over approval by the B.C. Law Society.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Alberta approach to climate change could be a model for North America: Harper

    Alberta approach to climate change could be a model for North America: Harper
    OTTAWA — Prime Minister Stephen Harper says the Alberta approach to pricing and controlling greenhouse gas emissions could serve as a model for all of North America.

    Alberta approach to climate change could be a model for North America: Harper

    Stateless Yukon Man, 60, Ponders Declaring Refugee Status In Canada

    Stateless Yukon Man, 60, Ponders Declaring Refugee Status In Canada
    VANCOUVER — Donovan McGlaughlin admits his story is hard to believe, but he wants Canadians to keep an open mind as he explains why he may have to apply as a political refugee in the country he's called home for his 60 years.

    Stateless Yukon Man, 60, Ponders Declaring Refugee Status In Canada

    Decision to build Site C dam 'incredibly stupid': First Nations leader

    Decision to build Site C dam 'incredibly stupid': First Nations leader
    VANCOUVER — A look at what was said about the B.C. government's decision to proceed with the controversial $8.8 billion Site C hydroelectric dam.

    Decision to build Site C dam 'incredibly stupid': First Nations leader

    Not criminally responsible defence not a 'get out of jail free card': expert

    Not criminally responsible defence not a 'get out of jail free card': expert
    TORONTO — Critics may see it as an easy way out, but defence lawyers argue those seeking to be declared not criminally responsible for their crimes must overcome serious hurdles at trial and may end up spending more time in custody than if they had pleaded guilty.

    Not criminally responsible defence not a 'get out of jail free card': expert

    How could cozier U.S.-Cuba relationship affect Canadian business interests?

    How could cozier U.S.-Cuba relationship affect Canadian business interests?
    OTTAWA — Experts believe closer ties between the United States and Cuba will eventually make economic waves for Canadian business.

    How could cozier U.S.-Cuba relationship affect Canadian business interests?

    What does hunger look like in Nunavut? One man's struggle to feed his kids

    What does hunger look like in Nunavut? One man's struggle to feed his kids
    IQALUIT, Nunavut — Israel Mablick's youngest son clings to his neck as another one of his children and his nephew bounce around on a thin mattress stuffed into a cramped space that doubles as a bedroom and a living room.

    What does hunger look like in Nunavut? One man's struggle to feed his kids