Close X
Saturday, March 1, 2025
ADVT 
National

MPs split over freedom of expression in Bill C-10

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 30 Apr, 2021 10:39 PM
  • MPs split over freedom of expression in Bill C-10

Days of debate over whether revisions to the Broadcasting Act could undermine Canadian rights and freedoms continued Friday.

Liberal and opposition members of Parliament split along party lines while discussing the public outcry sparked by an April 23 amendment to Bill C-10 brought by Liberal members of Parliament..

The bill sponsored by Heritage Minister Steven Guilbeault is intended to update the Broadcasting Act to better reflect how people and companies use the internet, including social media platforms.

The government says internet platforms such as YouTube and Facebook distribute video content or music to Canadians, and should be overseen by the CRTC, which regulates TV and radio broadcasters.

But Conservative MP Rachael Harder argues the heritage committee went too far by removing a section of the proposed legislation that excluded user-generated content from CRTC oversight.

Harder said there's widespread fear the CRTC could undermine individual freedom of expression by regulating how internet platforms distribute content generated by ordinary users.

This includes, "the things that we post on Facebook, the things we post on YouTube, the things that inspiring artists post. The cat videos that my grandmother posts, in order to share with her friends and engage with them," Harder said.

"When this change was made, it removed the protections that were once offered to those individuals who use these platforms."

Harder said there have been many experts who have written or said that the amendment passed last week is a threat to free speech and democracy because it removes protections for user-generated content.

She specifically read from an opinion by former CRTC chairman Peter Menzies who wrote the legislation "doesn't just infringe on free expression, it constitutes a full-blown assault upon it (free expression), and through it, the foundation of democracy."

Harder attempted to have the heritage committee agree to ask the Justice Department for a new analysis of C-10's impact on charter rights but debate on her motion was blocked by Liberal MPs in a 5-4 vote.

After the committee ended a regular two-hour session, Guilbeault said Bill C-10 poses no threat to individual rights and described the Conservative allegations as "100 per cent false and, frankly, ludicrous."

"I mean, to think that we would somehow adopt legislation that would be counter to the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, is a pure fabrication," Guilbeault said in an interview.

He also scoffed at the notion that people's right to post cat videos is at risk.

"Just the very thought of the CRTC somehow starting to deal with cat videos. Like it boggles my mind," Guilbeault said.

The purpose of Bill C-10's reforms to the Broadcasting Act are about having the law cover both conventional and online broadcasters.

Bill C-10 is supported by "just about every" artist and cultural organization "because platforms like YouTube aren't paying artists fairly for what they do. And Bill C-10 is about that. It's about fairness."

MORE National ARTICLES

Ottawa extends anti-ISIL mission another year

Ottawa extends anti-ISIL mission another year
The Liberal government previously set a cap of 850 troops for the mission several years ago, but Canada had been slowly withdrawing troops from the region over the last year.

Ottawa extends anti-ISIL mission another year

Pfizer to double vaccine deliveries in June

Pfizer to double vaccine deliveries in June
Pfizer is going to send five million more vaccine doses to Canada in June than it previously planned, and AstraZeneca will ship 4.4 million doses by the end of June.

Pfizer to double vaccine deliveries in June

U.S. breaking international law: Meng's lawyer

U.S. breaking international law: Meng's lawyer
Gib van Ert told a British Columbia Supreme Court judge today that if Canada extradites her to face the charges, it will be guilty of breaking international law as well.

U.S. breaking international law: Meng's lawyer

West Kelowna RCMP investigate stabbing

West Kelowna RCMP investigate stabbing
On March 28th, 2021 just before 2:00 a.m., West Kelowna RCMP and Kelowna RCMP were called to the Postill Lake Road area for a report of multiple victims of a stabbing at an outdoor gathering.

West Kelowna RCMP investigate stabbing

A look at the rare blood clot condition VIPIT

A look at the rare blood clot condition VIPIT
The National Advisory Committee on Immunization says the vaccine should not be used by people younger than age of 55, while Health Canada has issued guidelines around what to look for if you suspect you have had an adverse reaction.

A look at the rare blood clot condition VIPIT

B.C. imposes new COVID-19 restrictions

B.C. imposes new COVID-19 restrictions
Dr. Bonnie Henry says starting at midnight until April 19, indoor dining and activity at fitness centres are paused, while the Whistler Blackcomb ski resort will be closed as cases spread in the community.

B.C. imposes new COVID-19 restrictions