Close X
Friday, October 11, 2024
ADVT 
National

Meta's news ban in Canada: screenshots win, local news loses, study shows

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 21 May, 2024 09:42 AM
  • Meta's news ban in Canada: screenshots win, local news loses, study shows

The time, money and effort Iain Burns put into growing an audience on Facebook for several local news outlets in British Columbia felt like it disappeared in a single day. 

Facebook pages for Now Media Group, which publishes news in B.C.'s Okanagan Valley, have since gone dark. 

Last August, Meta removed news on its Facebook and Instagram platforms for Canadian users in response to the Liberal government's Online News Act. 

As the managing editor with Now Media Group, Burns watched as his audience — and revenue — dropped because of it. 

"We lost 70 per cent of our audience when that happened," along with 50 per cent of revenue, said Burns in an interview from Kelowna, B.C.

The company used Facebook to get clicks on its news stories, which in return brought in ad revenue for those views. 

"We're not the only ones. Many, many outlets are in this situation."

A recent paper by the Media Ecosystem Observatory — a collaboration between McGill University and the University of Toronto — offers an initial glimpse into the effect of the Meta news ban. 

National news outlets lost about 64 per cent of the engagement previously generated by users on their Facebook pages, the preliminary research shows. 

Local news outlets lost about 85 per cent of their Facebook engagement, the study says, and almost half of all local news outlets stopped posting on Facebook entirely in the four months following the ban. 

Some outlets "have gone dark entirely because they're no longer getting the ad revenue being driven from Facebook to their sites," said Aengus Bridgman, who directs the Media Ecosystem Observatory.

"And so this is hugely consequential for both Canadians and for news outlets."

Some outlets were able to maintain engagement on their Facebook pages because their news is still viewable outside Canada, and they have maintained an international audience. 

While news outlets suffered, Meta itself was seemingly unaffected. 

"One of the remarkable things we saw was the overall behaviour on the platform didn't decrease," said Bridgman. 

"We didn't see Canadians saying, 'Oh, I no longer use Facebook, I no longer use Instagram.' It doesn't seem there's been sort of an exodus from the platform in any meaningful way."

The researchers found 33 per cent of Canadians still used Facebook or Instagram to get news about politics and current events several times a month, even though they couldn't see content from news outlets on either platform.

For the study, researchers collected Facebook data between June and December of 2023, tracking engagement before and after the ban. 

They analyzed the Facebook pages of 987 Canadian news outlets, 183 politicians, commentators and advocacy groups, as well as 589 political and local community groups. 

They saw a similar volume of posting within political discussion groups but instead of links to news articles, people posted screenshots of them, Bridgman said. 

That means readers are seeing the content, but outlets aren't seeing the revenue.

"This study is pretty depressing, I think, from a public good perspective," he said.

The preliminary findings haven't yet been peer reviewed, but The Media Ecosystem Observatory plans to release a report in the summer. 

Burns said some Facebook users have posted screenshots of his original content to their feeds or local community groups. 

"The sad thing is politicians do it too," Burns said 

He's also seen fake news stories masquerading as screenshots of national publications.

"Just from a reach point of view, it is very sad to spend hours and hours on a really good story, a proper good exclusive, and publish it, and then see it gets maybe 20 per cent of the reach it would have got before August 2023," Burns said. 

The decision by Meta to remove news has created one of the largest disruptions to Canada's information ecosystem in recent years, the study says. 

Meta resisted the measures in the Liberal government's Online News Act from the beginning, arguing that it was based on a "fundamentally flawed premise."

The law required Meta and Google to enter into negotiation with news publishers for licensing agreements to their content. 

In response, Meta removed news links from its platform and Google was granted an exemption to the law by agreeing to pay Canadian news outlets $100 million a year.

Burns said he doesn't qualify for any of that money because his newsroom hasn't been designated as a qualified Canadian journalism organization under the Income Tax Act  — a decision he said he's tried to have reversed. 

It was denied that designation on grounds it doesn't produce original content, he said, despite reporting on local council meetings, provincial politics and, recently, a news conference by Prime Minister Justin Trudeau. 

A reporter for one of his outlets posed a question to the prime minister about Meta that garnered national news coverage — something Burns said he found "ironic."

In response to the question about whether his government would compromise with Meta so that people in B.C. could access news links about wildfire season, Trudeau said the web giant is "irresponsible" and promised not to "bow down to them." 

With a loss of revenue and no access to the Google money, Burns said his team is trying to shift more video coverage to grow its audience back.

Facebook "kind of showed who's boss, really, didn't they?" Burns said. "They showed they were the stronger party and I think that was a real lesson here."

MORE National ARTICLES

Upcoming mortgage renewals part of why BoC held rate at 5%: Macklem

Upcoming mortgage renewals part of why BoC held rate at 5%: Macklem
Bank of Canada governor Tiff Macklem says the central bank held its key interest rate at five per cent in part because of the effect a wave of upcoming mortgage renewals is expected to have on the economy. Macklem appeared before a Senate committee alongside senior deputy governor Carolyn Rogers on Wednesday following the Bank of Canada's most recent interest rate decision and monetary policy report.

Upcoming mortgage renewals part of why BoC held rate at 5%: Macklem

Make the next federal vote a 'carbon tax election,' Poilievre challenges Trudeau

Make the next federal vote a 'carbon tax election,' Poilievre challenges Trudeau
The Conservatives moved on Wednesday to make carbon pricing the ballot box question in the next election, seizing on the public's anxiety about affordability and seeing a crack in the Liberals' carbon-price armour. "A carbon tax election," Leader Pierre Poilievre proposed in a speech to his caucus in Ottawa.

Make the next federal vote a 'carbon tax election,' Poilievre challenges Trudeau

Tories hold lead over Liberals, Canadians report limited trust in institutions: poll

Tories hold lead over Liberals, Canadians report limited trust in institutions: poll
The Conservative party is maintaining a steady lead over Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's Liberals, a new poll suggests, at a time when Canadians are reporting limited trust in their institutions.  Pierre Poilievre's Tories are 14 percentage points ahead of the governing party, according to the survey by polling firm Leger. Forty per cent of respondents said they would vote Conservative, 26 per cent Liberal and 17 per cent NDP if an election were held that day.

Tories hold lead over Liberals, Canadians report limited trust in institutions: poll

No Canadians among hundreds of foreigners preparing to exit Gaza Strip

No Canadians among hundreds of foreigners preparing to exit Gaza Strip
The Palestinian death toll in the Israel-Hamas war has reached 8,805, according to the Hamas-run Health Ministry in Gaza. In the occupied West Bank, 130 Palestinians have been killed in violence and Israeli raids. More than 1,400 people in Israel have been killed, most of them civilians slain in the initial Oct. 7 attack by Hamas. In addition, around 240 hostages were taken from Israel into Gaza by the militant group.

No Canadians among hundreds of foreigners preparing to exit Gaza Strip

Federal government to level out number of new permanent residents in Canada in 2026

Federal government to level out number of new permanent residents in Canada in 2026
New targets tabled in Parliament show the government plans to level out the number of new permanent residents to Canada in 2026, forecasting an end to record-breaking year-over-year immigration. Immigration Minister Marc Miller submitted new targets for the next three years, which call for the number of new permanent residents to hold steady at 500,000 in 2026.  

Federal government to level out number of new permanent residents in Canada in 2026

B.C. Coroner's death panel recommends issuing drugs without prescription to stop ODs

B.C. Coroner's death panel recommends issuing drugs without prescription to stop ODs
A death review panel from the British Columbia Coroners Service is recommending community groups be allowed to hand out drugs without a prescription in an attempt to stop the relentless overdose death toll. The panel's report coincided with the monthly overdose death toll of 175 people in September, which the coroners service says is a 10 per cent drop from the same month a year ago, but still equal to 5.8 deaths a day across B.C. 

B.C. Coroner's death panel recommends issuing drugs without prescription to stop ODs