Close X
Friday, January 10, 2025
ADVT 
National

Men convicted in death of family crossing Manitoba border seek acquittal, new trial

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 06 Jan, 2025 11:14 AM
  • Men convicted in death of family crossing Manitoba border seek acquittal, new trial

The two men found guilty of human smuggling in the case of a family from India who froze to death while trying to walk across the Canada-U.S. border in Manitoba in 2022 are seeking acquittal, or new trials.

The two men, Steve Shand of Florida and Harshkumar Patel, an Indian national arrested in Chicago, were convicted by a Minnesota jury in November on all four counts each were facing.

Lawyers for Patel and Shand made their cases for acquittal or a new trial in separate motions filed on Friday in the United States District Court of Minnesota.

During the trial the prosecution had argued Shand and Patel were part of an international smuggling ring that brought people from India to Canada on student visas, then sent them on foot across the border to the U.S.

They were accused of carrying out smuggling trips between Manitoba and Minnesota on several occasions in December 2021 and January 2022.

Patel was alleged to have organized the logistics and paid Shand for picking up migrants on the U.S. side in rented vehicles.

Shand was arrested while driving a van on a remote road just south of the border during a blizzard on Jan. 19, 2022, when the temperature was –23 C, but the wind chill made it feel like the –35 C to –38 C range.

There were two adult migrants in the van and several others were found on foot nearby.

Hours later, the frozen bodies of Jagdish Patel, 39; his wife Vaishaliben Patel, 37; their 11-year-old daughter, Vihangi; and their three-year-old son, Dharmik, were found in a field in Manitoba, metres from the U.S. border.

The family was not related to Harshkumar Patel.

Patel's and Shand's lawyers argue that the evidence presented to the jury was insufficient to prove the men's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

A motion filed by Patel's lawyer, Thomas Leinenweber, claims that no evidence was brought forward that proved his client was involved in the conspiracy or that he knew the individuals being transported were crossing the border illegally.

"There was no testimony by any witness that Patel knew or acted in reckless disregard that the people crossing the border were aliens not lawfully in the United States," the motion reads. "Likewise, there was no forensic testimony that Patel knew or acted in reckless disregard of this fact."

"Because this is an essential element to all four counts that Patel was found guilty of, this Court should enter an order granting judgment of acquittal on all counts."

The motion also claims that Patel was not "Dirty Harry" -- the contact saved in Shand's phone who Shand was communicating with.

Patel's lawyer filed another motion that requests, in absence of an acquittal, that a new trial be ordered.

That motion argues in part that Patel should be granted a new trial because the court had denied his previous request to be tried separately from Shand.

According to the motion, a joint trial was unfair because Shand's defence in court rested entirely on Patel being guilty.

"Shand’s counsel repeatedly argued that Shand was an innocent taxi driver simply picking up passengers at the border of Canada and the United States at the behest of Patel," the motion reads.

Because of the strategy of his co-defendant, "Patel was forced to face two parties trying to establish his guilt – the government and co-defendant," it continued.

Patel's lawyer argues that this scenario "was clearly irreconcilable with Patel’s right to a fair trial" and made it so the jury was unable to "compartmentalize" the evidence presented to them.

Despite this, Patel's motion for a new trial also says he joins in all arguments made by Shand in Shand's motion for a new trial.

Shand's motion, filed by lawyer Aaron Morrison, also argues that the evidence put forward at trial was insufficient to prove his guilt.

The motion also argues that if the government's "late disclosures" of evidence were filed on time, the outcome of the trial could've been different.

Patel and Shand were expected to be sentenced in March.

MORE National ARTICLES

Arrest in smuggling operation: CBSA

Arrest in smuggling operation: CBSA
The Canada Border Services Agency says a 34-year-old Vancouver resident has been arrested for their suspected involvement in a cigarette smuggling operation. It says an investigation into the operation was launched in February after C-B-S-A officers intercepted numerous contraband cigarette shipments at Vancouver International Airport Commercial Operations and the Vancouver International Mail Centre.

Arrest in smuggling operation: CBSA

Landslide on tracks stops Amtrak passenger runs between Seattle and Vancouver

Landslide on tracks stops Amtrak passenger runs between Seattle and Vancouver
A landslide that blocked railway tracks has stopped Amtrak passenger service between Vancouver and Seattle. Amtrak says in a statement Thursday that the landslide near White Rock, B.C., led Burlington Northern Santa Fa Railway to place a 48-hour moratorium on passenger service. 

Landslide on tracks stops Amtrak passenger runs between Seattle and Vancouver

Emissions in Canada fell last year, though still far off Paris targets

Emissions in Canada fell last year, though still far off Paris targets
For the first time since the pandemic, Canada had a year-over-year decline in its greenhouse gas emissions — though it is still a long way off its 2030 target. A preliminary emissions report Thursday from the federal government shows greenhouse gases emitted in 2023 fell by six million tonnes compared to 2022, the equivalent to what about 1.4 million passenger vehicles emit over the course of a year.

Emissions in Canada fell last year, though still far off Paris targets

Forfeited Hells Angels clubhouse in Kelowna sold to the city

Forfeited Hells Angels clubhouse in Kelowna sold to the city
A former Hells Angels clubhouse that was seized by the British Columbia government in 2023 after years of fighting in court has been sold to the City of Kelowna.  A statement from Public Safety Minister Garry Begg says the sale of the home in Kelowna includes a "right of entry," which means the province's civil forfeiture office can take the property back if it is ever acquired and used for organized crime in the future.

Forfeited Hells Angels clubhouse in Kelowna sold to the city

Dozens get sick with 'norovirus-like' illness after eating raw B.C. oysters

Dozens get sick with 'norovirus-like' illness after eating raw B.C. oysters
Health officials in British Columbia say at least 64 people have become sick after eating raw oysters from restaurants and retail locations. A statement from the BC Centre for Disease Control and the provincial health authority says the "norovirus-like" gastrointestinal illnesses have been reported since Nov. 1 in the Vancouver Coastal Health, Fraser Health and Island Health regions. 

Dozens get sick with 'norovirus-like' illness after eating raw B.C. oysters

Vancouver Police Union criticizes assault case's handling after officer's suicide

Vancouver Police Union criticizes assault case's handling after officer's suicide
The president of the Vancouver Police Union has criticized the handling of a sexual assault case that ended in the suicide of a Central Saanich Police officer. Ralph Kaisers says in a letter to members that was obtained by The Canadian Press that the "tragic loss" of the officer came after public statements that risked "undermining the presumption of innocence."

Vancouver Police Union criticizes assault case's handling after officer's suicide