Close X
Thursday, December 12, 2024
ADVT 
National

Med Student Accused Of Sister Sex Abuse Staves Off Extradition To U.S.

The Canadian Press, 30 Jun, 2015 01:11 PM
    TORONTO — A medical student alleged to have abused two teenaged sisters in a manner a judge once described as close to torture has staved off extradition to the United States to stand trial.
     
    In a decision Tuesday, Ontario's top court ruled that a judge who approved extradition was wrong to accept evidence that pointed to Marco (Mark) Viscomi as the perpetrator.
     
    That evidence included a 10-digit Internet protocol address — which uniquely identifies a computer on the Internet — that was assigned to Viscomi's account.
     
    "Was it open to the extradition judge to draw the inference...that it was Mr. Viscomi who was the user of that IP address at the relevant time?" Justice Robert Blair wrote for the court. "The answer to that question is no."
     
    The case arose in January 2012, when someone had a webcam chat with a 17-year old girl in Virginia Beach, Va. The person could see the girl, but she could not see him. According to the complaint, the person used threats to force the girl to expose her breasts, and then to engage in explicit sexual and sexually violent activities with her 13-year-old sister.
     
    American police tracked the communications through the IP address and information from an Internet service provider to a home in Stouffville, Ont., about 50 kilometres north of Toronto. Viscomi, in the final stages of becoming a medical doctor, was living there with his parents.
     
    Acting on the information, Ontario police searched the home and his student residence, seizing computers and peripherals. They arrested and charged him in March 2012, and released him on bail.
     
    Five months later, they re-arrested him at the request of the Americans. They withdrew the Canadian charges in favour of extradition proceedings to the U.S., where he faced a maximum 30-year jail term if convicted.
     
    In August 2012, Justice Mary Lou Benotto, then on Superior Court, denied him bail. "The allegations involve sadistic, sexualized conduct with children which verges on torture," she said. "They suggest systemic psychological and physical abuse of children."
     
    In May 2013, Ontario Superior Court Justice Ken Campbell ordered Viscomi sent to the United States for trial. In doing so, Campbell accepted evidence that pointed to Viscomi as the person who had abused the victims for his "prurient, voyeuristic pleasure."
     
    The Appeal Court, however, found several problems with the evidence on which Campbell relied.
     
    "Everyone acknowledges that Internet child luring and exploitation occurred," the Appeal Court said. "The linchpin issue concerning the Viscomi proceedings is whether he is the 'someone' who was on the other end of the video call."
     
    For one thing, the court said, there was no definitive proof that it was in fact Viscomi using the computer identified by the IP address. Blair compared it with deciding that a person was driving a car at a given time based solely on its ownership papers.
     
    Nor was their evidence proving that an IP address combined with other subscriber information allows police to compile an unassailable history of a person's activity on the Internet, the court ruled.
     
    "Speculation, educated guesses, and even common sense and human experience cannot provide a substitute for such evidence," Blair said. 
     
    The court also quashed the government's order that was based on Campbell's ruling committing Viscomi for extradition but left it to the Crown as whether it may try again to act against him.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Vancouver Becomes First In Canada To Regulate Medical Marijuana Dispensaries

    Vancouver Becomes First In Canada To Regulate Medical Marijuana Dispensaries
    In a eight to three vote, councillors approved imposing a $30,000 licensing fee, requiring stores to be located 300 metres from schools, community centres and each other, and banning shops from certain areas.

    Vancouver Becomes First In Canada To Regulate Medical Marijuana Dispensaries

    Search Underway For Hiker Duo Who Didn't Return From B.C.'s Southern Interior

    Search Underway For Hiker Duo Who Didn't Return From B.C.'s Southern Interior
    A search for Lynne Carmody and Rick Moynan began Monday near the village of Keremeos.  

    Search Underway For Hiker Duo Who Didn't Return From B.C.'s Southern Interior

    Newly Appointed B.C. Committee To Review Mining Rules After Tailings Pond Breach

    Bill Bennett says a committee will determine how to best enact seven recommendations from an expert report into last year's tailings pond breach in the Cariboo region.

    Newly Appointed B.C. Committee To Review Mining Rules After Tailings Pond Breach

    Fired B.C. Workers Call For Public Inquiry Into Health Research Debacle

    In a letter to Health Minister Terry Lake, the seven workers and the sister of a man who killed himself shortly after being dismissed said the inquiry must have the power and authority to subpoena people and get statements under oath. 

    Fired B.C. Workers Call For Public Inquiry Into Health Research Debacle

    Woman Remains In Serious Condition, Three Others In Hospital After Megabus Crash Near Lancaster, Ont

    Woman Remains In Serious Condition, Three Others In Hospital After Megabus Crash Near Lancaster, Ont
    The Ontario Provincial Police say their investigation continues into the collision between a double-decker Megabus and a tractor-trailer Tuesday afternoon.

    Woman Remains In Serious Condition, Three Others In Hospital After Megabus Crash Near Lancaster, Ont

    Former Vancouver Olympics CEO John Furlong Accuses Lawyer Of Sullying Dead Wife's Reputation

    VANCOUVER — Former Vancouver Olympics CEO John Furlong raised his voice and thumped his fist during testimony as he defended himself at a British Columbia Supreme Court defamation trial on Tuesday.

    Former Vancouver Olympics CEO John Furlong Accuses Lawyer Of Sullying Dead Wife's Reputation