Close X
Thursday, December 12, 2024
ADVT 
National

Man set to argue driving while black led to vehicle stop, gun conviction

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 12 Jan, 2015 04:04 PM

    TORONTO — A man convicted of a gun offence takes his case to Ontario's top court on Tuesday to argue he was a victim of driving while black.

    In a factum filed with court, lawyers for Richard Steele say his trial judge erred in failing to properly consider evidence of "racial profiling" in finding him guilty.

    In 2010, an Ontario Superior Court justice convicted Steele of concealing a loaded handgun under the front passenger seat of his mother's car after being pulled over in Hamilton. There were four black men in the car.

    Court documents show his lawyer, Anthony Moustacalis, says the gun the officer found should have been excluded as evidence, because Const. Yvonne Stephens conducted an improper search of the vehicle.

    Moustacalis also maintains police only pulled the vehicle over because of the driver's race.

    He says the officer's request to help the driver find the vehicle's insurance card — which led to the discovery of the gun under the seat — was "bizarre" and did not amount to obtaining informed consent for the search. In addition, Moustacalis says the officer violated Steele's right to privacy.

    The lawyer also argues the officer's trial testimony showed inconsistencies, including where Steele's hands were during the stop.

    For its part, the Crown denies racial profiling had anything to do with the incident, and says the officer's behaviour was not unusual or racist.

    The officer couldn't see the car's occupants when she pulled it over, and Stephens was within her rights to check for valid driving documentation, according to the prosecution's factum.

    At trial, the judge relied in part on evidence from another Hamilton officer that Stephens had never exhibited racial bias in the 10 years he knew her.

    "(That) gives me comfort for my conclusion," the justice said.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Canadian military deploys counter-intelligence team during Arctic exercise

    Canadian military deploys counter-intelligence team during Arctic exercise
    OTTAWA — The Canadian military has been routinely deploying a counter-intelligence team to guard against possible spying, terrorism and sabotage during its annual Arctic exercise, according to internal documents.

    Canadian military deploys counter-intelligence team during Arctic exercise

    From Hey Rosetta to Joseph Boyden, artists want buffer around Gros Morne park

    From Hey Rosetta to Joseph Boyden, artists want buffer around Gros Morne park
    ST. JOHN'S, N.L. — Canadian artists, writers and musicians ranging from Hey Rosetta to novelist Joseph Boyden are pushing for action to protect Gros Morne National Park in western Newfoundland.

    From Hey Rosetta to Joseph Boyden, artists want buffer around Gros Morne park

    Police forces balk at tracking fees imposed by Rogers Communications

    Police forces balk at tracking fees imposed by Rogers Communications
    OTTAWA — The RCMP and many other police forces are refusing to pay new fees imposed by Rogers Communications for helping track suspects through their mobile phones.

    Police forces balk at tracking fees imposed by Rogers Communications

    Lawyers for complainants want police chief called before G20 hearing

    Lawyers for complainants want police chief called before G20 hearing
    TORONTO — Lawyers for three complainants involved in a disciplinary hearing for a senior police officer charged over mass arrests during Toronto's G20 summit are trying to have the city's police chief called to testify.

    Lawyers for complainants want police chief called before G20 hearing

    Power Problem At Transit Hub Halts Vancouver SkyTrains During Morning Commute

    Power Problem At Transit Hub Halts Vancouver SkyTrains During Morning Commute
    VANCOUVER — A temporary electrical issue at downtown Vancouver's transit hub has caused delays for passengers during their morning commute.

    Power Problem At Transit Hub Halts Vancouver SkyTrains During Morning Commute

    Ontario motel manager finds odd lodger: a 1.5-metre-long boa constrictor

    Ontario motel manager finds odd lodger: a 1.5-metre-long boa constrictor
    OWEN SOUND, Ont. — A central Ontario motel manager found a strange visitor lodging in one of the rooms on the weekend.

    Ontario motel manager finds odd lodger: a 1.5-metre-long boa constrictor