Close X
Sunday, November 10, 2024
ADVT 
National

Man hiking near Fairy Creek, B.C., wrongfully arrested by Mounties, review finds

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 11 Sep, 2024 04:34 PM
  • Man hiking near Fairy Creek, B.C., wrongfully arrested by Mounties, review finds

Members of a controversial RCMP policing unit violated a man's rights and acted unreasonably when they demanded to search him before arresting him near a British Columbia old-growth logging protest site in 2021, the Civilian Review and Complaints Commission for the RCMP has found. 

The commission released a review of a complaint made by a man who had been hiking a forest service road with a group in September 2021 on Vancouver Island near Fairy Creek, where logging activity ignited protests against forestry firm Teal Cedar Products.  

In April 2021, the company was granted a court injunction to stop people from impeding access to forest service roads, leading to the RCMP's community-industry response group to set up "exclusion zones" to stop protesters from obstructing logging in the forest. 

The commission's review released Wednesday said the man was hiking and encountered a pair of police officers at an "access control point."

The officers "told the group that they had to submit to searches of their backpacks and provide identification before they could go any further," the commission's complaint review said. 

The man objected to the search, told officers he had a right to be on a public road, and refused to obey when the RCMP ordered him to leave. The officers then "arrested the man and one of his friends for the criminal offence of obstructing a peace officer in the execution of their duty and transported him out of the area for processing." 

The commission found the arrest was "groundless," and the demand to search his backpack was "unfounded" because he had been lawfully using the forest service road and also "wanted to protest the RCMP's restrictions." 

"The arrest raises serious questions about the quality of the training given to RCMP members acting to enforce the injunction, and about the attitudes of the individual police officers on the ground towards the rule of law and civil liberties," the review said. 

The man was not obligated to identify himself or submit to a police search after coming upon Mounties who refused to identify themselves by name, only reading out their badge numbers "quickly," and refused to repeat them, the review said. 

Video footage of the interaction seen by the commission showed how officers were "dismissive and disdainful" about identifying themselves, and "refused to repeat their regimental numbers or even acknowledge that they were required by the RCMP’s own policy to wear a name tag on their uniforms," it said. 

One officer also wore a "thin blue line" patch against RCMP uniform policy, the review concluded, with video evidence showing "that the RCMP member took a disrespectful and even hostile tone when the man questioned the presence of the patch on the RCMP member’s uniform when it was associated with white supremacist groups." 

The thin blue line patch, depicted as a black-and-white Canadian flag with a blue line through the centre, had become a symbol of solidarity among police officers across Canada, but the RCMP directed that officers not wear the patch on duty as other groups viewed the symbol as racist. 

The commission's review said the RCMP Commissioner supported many of the findings of the review, including how they were "inconsistent" with court rulings about exclusion zones.

The RCMP Commissioner, though, disagreed about "policy gaps" around the wearing of name tags, and about whether the thin blue line patch was "a deliberate display of disobedience or insubordination, or that the members knew that this symbol may propagate hatred or white supremacist views."

The RCMP Commissioner, the review said, didn't support "mandatory harsher penalties" for wearing the patch, instead supporting any disciplinary action to be taken "case by case." 

"One of the explicit goals of the civil injunction was to permit public access to the area," the commission's review said. "It would be a perverse irony to rely on the goal of preserving public access to justify the RCMP’s activities to impede, obstruct, and interfere with that access on such a large and intrusive scale." 

Police actions in Fairy Creek have been sharply criticized by a B.C. Supreme Court judge for overstepping the terms of a court injunction granted to Teal Cedar in 2021 after logging activity in the ecologically sensitive area set off protests, leading to hundreds of arrests. 

The judge found in 2021 that "exclusion zones, checkpoints, searches, and restrictions on media members clearly interfere with important liberties." 

Justice Douglas Thompson ruled that "the degree of interference with liberties of members of the public and members of the media is substantial and serious." 

The Civilian Review and Complaints Commission for the RCMP is still working on completing a review of the actions of the Mounties' community industry response group in a "systemic investigation," after the judge threw out numerous cases against logging protesters for police failures in properly enforcing the court injunction in Fairy Creek. 

MORE National ARTICLES

Four people dead after crash involving semi truck and SUV outside Calgary

Four people dead after crash involving semi truck and SUV outside Calgary
Four people are dead after a crash involving an SUV and a semi truck hauling a grain trailer at a rural intersection northeast of Calgary. RCMP say they were called about a crash Friday morning at the intersection of highways 9 and 564 in Rocky View County.

Four people dead after crash involving semi truck and SUV outside Calgary

Vancouver police investigating homicide after two men shot in vehicle

Vancouver police investigating homicide after two men shot in vehicle
Vancouver police are investigating a suspected homicide after two men were shot in a vehicle, which then collided with two other vehicles.  A statement says police were called just before 9 p.m. on Friday to the city’s Sunset neighbourhood.

Vancouver police investigating homicide after two men shot in vehicle

B.C. port employers say foremen's union plans industry-wide strike vote

B.C. port employers say foremen's union plans industry-wide strike vote
The BC Maritime Employers Association says it has been told by a lawyer for the foremen's union that an industry-wide strike vote will take place in coming weeks. The employers' group says the lawyer for ILWU Local 514 informed them of the vote this week after a case management meeting with the Canada Industrial Relations Board.

B.C. port employers say foremen's union plans industry-wide strike vote

Darpan 10 with Martin Thibodeau, Regional President, British Columbia at RBC Royal Bank,

Darpan 10 with Martin Thibodeau, Regional President, British Columbia at RBC Royal Bank,
With over 30 years of experience, I am Martin Thibodeau, Regional President, British Columbia at RBC Royal Bank, leading a team of more than 8,000 workers and partners in BC, dedicated to providing financial advice and services to almost 2 million personal, small business and commercial clients. 

Darpan 10 with Martin Thibodeau, Regional President, British Columbia at RBC Royal Bank,

Here are the facts about British Columbia's wildfire situation on July 26

Here are the facts about British Columbia's wildfire situation on July 26
Wildfires of note: Five. Shetland Creek fire, Kamloops Fire Centre; Antler Creek fire, Cariboo Fire Centre; Aylwin Creek fire, Southeast Fire Centre; Komonko Creek fire, Southeast Fire Centre; Dogtooth FSR fire, Southeast Fire Centre.

Here are the facts about British Columbia's wildfire situation on July 26

B.C.'s top doctor ends public health emergency declared for COVID-19

B.C.'s top doctor ends public health emergency declared for COVID-19
British Columbia's top doctor says she is ending the public health emergency declared in response to the COVID-19 pandemic in March 2020.  Provincial health officer Dr. Bonnie Henry says any remaining restrictions, including the vaccination requirement for health-care workers, are being rescinded.

B.C.'s top doctor ends public health emergency declared for COVID-19